Grant: Master's Award: Canada Graduate Scholarships
University of Toronto
$17,500.00
The Complex Experience of Stress among Surgeons in the Operating Room
FY 2013-14
Summary
Surgery is an inherently stressful profession, with the operating room providing a significant source of stress to the surgeon. While individual surgeons privately admit that stress in the operating room (OR) is prevalent, the surgical community does not overtly recognize or prepare trainees for it. The OR is a complex environment where many factors play into the experience of stress by the surgeon. There are internal factors which affect the surgeon, such as fatigue and mood, as well as external factors such as the team and environment. Stress is an exceedingly complex phenomenon that consists not only of a physiologic component, but also social, intellectual and emotional components. Trying to study stress by looking at only one dimension would fail to gain insight into the important interactions that may exist between these factors. To begin to understand the complex phenomenon of stress in the OR we need to be able to identify stressful moments and see how various measures of stress might best capture these moments.
As a first step in this research program, this study will explore and refine the methodology for studying the complex phenomenon of stress, capturing physiological, emotional and socio-cultural influences. The physiologic data will include such parameters as heart rate and sweat gland activity so that we can learn if the surgeon is physiologically stressed. The observational data will be collected via an observer who will take timed observation notes of the events during surgery. The observer will attempt to identify stressful moments by interpreting tension in the OR. The subjective data will be collected with a short survey measuring stress and anxiety as well as brief pre and post-operative interviews with the surgeons to gain access to their personal thoughts and experiences of stress. We will then compare the three sets of data to see what relationships exist between the different measures of stress. We anticipate that there will be events where all three prongs of data measuring stress will match up, but that there will also be moments that are seen as stressful in one or two categories and perhaps not the other. For example, there will likely be moments that will show physiologic arousal, which may be be perceived as stressful to the surgeon. Conversely, there will likely be events that are perceived as stressful that will not show as much of a physiologic arousal as anticipated. This study is the first of its kind and it will help us learn what measures we can use to identify and study stressful moments as they are experienced by the surgeon in the OR.
This research program has the potential to benefit society as a whole, but particularly three groups: surgeons, members of the intra-operative team and patients. Previous studies have shown that stress significantly contributes to burnout, and the burnout rate in surgeons is amongst the highest in the medical profession at 30-38%. While some surgeons deal particularly well with stress in the OR, there are others who do not. If these stressful moments are better understood, programs can be created to not only help practicing surgeons better prepare for them, but also improve the education of surgical trainees. Second, the operating room team is a complex high-functioning unit consisting of surgeons, anaesthetists, nurses and trainees. Understanding and alleviating surgeon stress should help to improve team dynamics such as communication and shared mental models. Finally, knowing that stress can negatively affect a surgeon’s skills, it follows that better understanding stress in the OR may help to make it a safer environment for patients.
Department
Program
Master's Award: Canada Graduate Scholarships
Recipient
Location
Ontario, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
CIHR Funding Decisions Database
As published
Id
311995
Name
Seemann Natashia M
Region
Ontario
Country
Canada
Orgtype
Institution Paid; Research Institution
Prcname2
Special Cases - Awards Programs
Projecttitle
The Complex Experience of Stress among Surgeons in the Operating Room
Programtype2
Studentship Programs
Orgnameinp2
University of Toronto
Cihramount2
$17,500
Cihrequipment2
$0
Programname2
Master's Award: Canada Graduate Scholarships
Keyworddelim
Decision-Making; Expertise; Operating Room; Stress; Surgeon
Abstract
Surgery is an inherently stressful profession, with the operating room providing a significant source of stress to the surgeon. While individual surgeons privately admit that stress in the operating room (OR) is prevalent, the surgical community does not overtly recognize or prepare trainees for it. The OR is a complex environment where many factors play into the experience of stress by the surgeon. There are internal factors which affect the surgeon, such as fatigue and mood, as well as external factors such as the team and environment. Stress is an exceedingly complex phenomenon that consists not only of a physiologic component, but also social, intellectual and emotional components. Trying to study stress by looking at only one dimension would fail to gain insight into the important interactions that may exist between these factors. To begin to understand the complex phenomenon of stress in the OR we need to be able to identify stressful moments and see how various measures of stress might best capture these moments.
As a first step in this research program, this study will explore and refine the methodology for studying the complex phenomenon of stress, capturing physiological, emotional and socio-cultural influences. The physiologic data will include such parameters as heart rate and sweat gland activity so that we can learn if the surgeon is physiologically stressed. The observational data will be collected via an observer who will take timed observation notes of the events during surgery. The observer will attempt to identify stressful moments by interpreting tension in the OR. The subjective data will be collected with a short survey measuring stress and anxiety as well as brief pre and post-operative interviews with the surgeons to gain access to their personal thoughts and experiences of stress. We will then compare the three sets of data to see what relationships exist between the different measures of stress. We anticipate that there will be events where all three prongs of data measuring stress will match up, but that there will also be moments that are seen as stressful in one or two categories and perhaps not the other. For example, there will likely be moments that will show physiologic arousal, which may be be perceived as stressful to the surgeon. Conversely, there will likely be events that are perceived as stressful that will not show as much of a physiologic arousal as anticipated. This study is the first of its kind and it will help us learn what measures we can use to identify and study stressful moments as they are experienced by the surgeon in the OR.
This research program has the potential to benefit society as a whole, but particularly three groups: surgeons, members of the intra-operative team and patients. Previous studies have shown that stress significantly contributes to burnout, and the burnout rate in surgeons is amongst the highest in the medical profession at 30-38%. While some surgeons deal particularly well with stress in the OR, there are others who do not. If these stressful moments are better understood, programs can be created to not only help practicing surgeons better prepare for them, but also improve the education of surgical trainees. Second, the operating room team is a complex high-functioning unit consisting of surgeons, anaesthetists, nurses and trainees. Understanding and alleviating surgeon stress should help to improve team dynamics such as communication and shared mental models. Finally, knowing that stress can negatively affect a surgeon’s skills, it follows that better understanding stress in the OR may help to make it a safer environment for patients.
Competitiondate
201312
Approvedterm2
1 yr 0 mth
Pinamesdelim
Seemann, Natashia M
Approvedterm
1 an 0 mois
Cihrcontribution2
~ $17,500~ $0~