Canada Spends Logo

Explore our Budget 2026 analysis

Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual

University of British Columbia

$55,000.00

Is mentalizing for social evaluation? Studies with human infants.

FY 2022-23

Summary
Typically developing humans are exquisitely tuned into mental states, readily thinking about what others intend, know, and believe. Indeed, mentalizing is imperative for key features of the human species including effective social learning and maintaining long-term cooperative relationships. Given the ubiquity and adaptiveness of mentalizing in human life, significant effort in the cognitive sciences has been dedicated to elucidating its underlying nature and developmental origins. In this research program, we will examine a particular hypothesis about the human mentalizing system via 3 streams of studies with preverbal infants, which stems both from past NSERC-supported work suggestive that infants may be particularly willing and/or able to mentalize within socially evaluative versus non-evaluative contexts [for instance, contexts where agents' mental states are prosocial or antisocial versus neutral or non-social], as well as from recent notorious failures to replicate key results within the developmental mentalizing literature. Specifically, we hypothesize that mentalizing develops first and foremost to facilitate effective social evaluation, allowing highly interdependent humans to cooperate effectively by readily distinguishing good from bad cooperative partners. From this primary function, humans come to apply their mentalizing capacities to reasoning about all kinds of agents in possession of all kinds of mental states. The proposed research examines 4 sub-hypotheses under the overarching hypothesis that mentalizing is for social evaluation via 3 research streams, using a multi-method approach including infant looking time, predictive looking, EEG/ERP, and fNIRS. Each stream will explore whether and to what extent infants are more likely to mentalize in socially evaluative contexts, through carefully controlled experiments comparing contexts more versus less relevant to social evaluation. Specifically, we will explore (1) if reasoning about social mental states is privileged relative to reasoning about physical mental states; (2) if reasoning about valenced social mental states is privileged relative to reasoning about neutral social mental states, especially negative ones; and (3) if once an agent has previously been identified as possessing valenced social mental states, especially negative ones, that agent will be particularly likely to engage mentalizing systems in the future, even while acting neutrally or non-socially. The proposed use of multiple distinct (but complementary) methods will provide training in cutting-edge research methods to a variety of Highly Qualified Personnel, and maximize our chances of acquiring crucial convergent evidence for our hypotheses. Together, these studies will serve to better elucidate the underlying nature of the human mentalizing system, informing our basic understanding of how and why we mentalize.
Program
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Location
British Columbia, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data

As published

Application id
RGPIN-2022-05037
Name nom
Hamlin, Jane
Department département
Psychology - Psychology
Organization id
2
Institution établissement
University of British Columbia
Province en
British Columbia
Province fr
Colombie-Britannique
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2022
Competition year année de concours
2022
Award amount
55000
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
DISCOVERY RESEARCH
Group fr
RECHERCHE AXÉE SUR LA DÉCOUVERTE
Committee code
1502
Committee name en
Biological Systems and Functions
Committee name fr
Systèmes et fonctions biologiques
Area of application code
1200
Area of application group en
Advancement of knowledge
Area of application group fr
Avancement des connaissances
Area of application en
Advancement of knowledge
Area of application fr
Avancement des connaissances
Research subject code
6300
Research subject group en
Psychology
Research subject group fr
Psychologie
Research subject en
Psychology
Research subject fr
Psychologie
Installment
inst:1
Partie
1
Nb partie
5
Application title
Is mentalizing for social evaluation? Studies with human infants.
Application summary
Typically developing humans are exquisitely tuned into mental states, readily thinking about what others intend, know, and believe. Indeed, mentalizing is imperative for key features of the human species including effective social learning and maintaining long-term cooperative relationships. Given the ubiquity and adaptiveness of mentalizing in human life, significant effort in the cognitive sciences has been dedicated to elucidating its underlying nature and developmental origins. In this research program, we will examine a particular hypothesis about the human mentalizing system via 3 streams of studies with preverbal infants, which stems both from past NSERC-supported work suggestive that infants may be particularly willing and/or able to mentalize within socially evaluative versus non-evaluative contexts [for instance, contexts where agents' mental states are prosocial or antisocial versus neutral or non-social], as well as from recent notorious failures to replicate key results within the developmental mentalizing literature. Specifically, we hypothesize that mentalizing develops first and foremost to facilitate effective social evaluation, allowing highly interdependent humans to cooperate effectively by readily distinguishing good from bad cooperative partners. From this primary function, humans come to apply their mentalizing capacities to reasoning about all kinds of agents in possession of all kinds of mental states. The proposed research examines 4 sub-hypotheses under the overarching hypothesis that mentalizing is for social evaluation via 3 research streams, using a multi-method approach including infant looking time, predictive looking, EEG/ERP, and fNIRS. Each stream will explore whether and to what extent infants are more likely to mentalize in socially evaluative contexts, through carefully controlled experiments comparing contexts more versus less relevant to social evaluation. Specifically, we will explore (1) if reasoning about social mental states is privileged relative to reasoning about physical mental states; (2) if reasoning about valenced social mental states is privileged relative to reasoning about neutral social mental states, especially negative ones; and (3) if once an agent has previously been identified as possessing valenced social mental states, especially negative ones, that agent will be particularly likely to engage mentalizing systems in the future, even while acting neutrally or non-socially. The proposed use of multiple distinct (but complementary) methods will provide training in cutting-edge research methods to a variety of Highly Qualified Personnel, and maximize our chances of acquiring crucial convergent evidence for our hypotheses. Together, these studies will serve to better elucidate the underlying nature of the human mentalizing system, informing our basic understanding of how and why we mentalize.
University of British Columbia - $55,000 Grant (2022-… | Canada Spends