Grant: Operating Grant: Knowledge to Action
University of Toronto
$200,000.00
Pain pain go away: improving the vaccination experience at school
FY 2015-16
Summary
Background: There is a crucial and urgent need to minimize pain and fear during school-based mass vaccinations as negative experiences with vaccine injections are associated with several adverse outcomes. Acutely, inadequate pain and fear mitigation leads to severe distress, fainting (which can cause injury due to falls) and vaccine refusal. In the long-term, unvaccinated students are at higher risk of acquiring vaccine-preventable diseases (including cancer). Students who fear pain and needles into adulthood avoid other important preventive health care (e.g., dental care) further contributing to negative outcomes. Although evidence-based strategies exist to mitigate vaccination pain and fear, they have not been integrated into school vaccination policies and programs, that is, there is a knowledge-to-care gap. With prior CIHR-funding, we developed a clinical practice guideline (CPG) that includes pain, fear and fainting mitigation strategies, and specific guidance for school-based mass vaccinations. In preliminary work leading up to this project, we documented the perceptions and preferences of relevant stakeholders (students, parents, teachers, immunizers) regarding vaccination pain and fear and their mitigation. With vaccine refusal rates approaching an alarming 25% in this population, 5% (one-fifth) which is attributed to pain or fear of needles, there is both a need and opportunity to address this issue.
Methods: This project brings together researchers from Help ELiminate Pain in Kids & Adults (HELPinKids&Adults) – an inter-disciplinary cross-Canada group of individuals leading Knowledge Translation (KT) activities in this area – and knowledge users (Niagara Region Public Health) with the goal of making our CPG actionable in the school-based mass vaccination context, the primary vehicle for vaccination of school-aged children (> 6 years). We plan a 2-year project that includes 3 objectives that constitute 3 phases of the project: 1) to collaboratively develop an implementation framework (action plan) for the CPG with targeted stakeholder groups, 2) to adapt and develop tools and processes for the different users that address pain, fear and fainting mitigation, and 3) to integrate the tools and processes into vaccination clinics at participating schools and evaluate feasibility and preliminary performance measures. We will utilize qualitative and quantitative methods and data will be analyzed sequentially throughout the project as the results of one phase will inform the next.
Impact: This study uses a knowledge user-centred approach to address sub-optimal practices during school-based mass vaccination, allowing for approaches that are relevant to the real world. We project downstream benefits on health outcomes by improving preventive health behaviours. Tools and strategies will be shared across the country to inform broader CPG uptake.
Applicants and Research Environment: Our study team consists of an accomplished interdisciplinary, multi-sectoral and multi-institutional group of scientists, policy makers and health providers from across Canada. Taddio and MacDonald have extensive clinical research experience; Hirji, Bucci, and Halpert have expertise in health policy/implementation; Taddio, McMurtry and Law have content expertise; this is complemented by discipline-specific skills. Robson provides family/child perspective. The team collaborated on the project plan and is committed to its success, including long-term sustainability.
Department
Program
Operating Grant: Knowledge to Action
Recipient
Location
Ontario, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
CIHR Funding Decisions Database
As published
Id
336586
Name
Taddio Anna
Region
Ontario
Country
Canada
Orgtype
Institution Paid; Research Institution
Instname2
Human Development, Child and Youth Health
Theme2
Health systems / services
Prcname2
Operating Grant: Knowledge to Action
Projecttitle
Pain pain go away: improving the vaccination experience at school
Programtype2
Operating Grants
Orgnameinp2
University of Toronto
Cihramount2
$200,000
Cihrequipment2
$0
Programname2
Operating Grant: Knowledge to Action
Keyworddelim
Clinical Practice Guideline; Fainting; Fear Management; Implementation Science; Knowledge Translation; Pain Management; Qualitative Research; School; Vaccination
Abstract
<html>
<body>
<p>
<strong>Background:</strong> There is a crucial and urgent need to minimize pain and fear during school-based mass vaccinations as negative experiences with vaccine injections are associated with several adverse outcomes. Acutely, inadequate pain and fear mitigation leads to severe distress, fainting (which can cause injury due to falls) and vaccine refusal. In the long-term, unvaccinated students are at higher risk of acquiring vaccine-preventable diseases (including cancer). Students who fear pain and needles into adulthood avoid other important preventive health care (e.g., dental care) further contributing to negative outcomes. Although evidence-based strategies exist to mitigate vaccination pain and fear, they have not been integrated into school vaccination policies and programs, that is, there is a knowledge-to-care gap. With prior CIHR-funding, we developed a clinical practice guideline (CPG) that includes pain, fear and fainting mitigation strategies, and specific guidance for school-based mass vaccinations. In preliminary work leading up to this project, we documented the perceptions and preferences of relevant stakeholders (students, parents, teachers, immunizers) regarding vaccination pain and fear and their mitigation. With vaccine refusal rates approaching an alarming 25% in this population, 5% (one-fifth) which is attributed to pain or fear of needles, there is both a need and opportunity to address this issue.<br>
<strong>Methods:</strong> This project brings together researchers from Help ELiminate Pain in Kids & Adults (HELPinKids&Adults) – an inter-disciplinary cross-Canada group of individuals leading Knowledge Translation (KT) activities in this area – and knowledge users (Niagara Region Public Health) with the goal of making our CPG actionable in the school-based mass vaccination context, the primary vehicle for vaccination of school-aged children (> 6 years). We plan a 2-year project that includes 3 objectives that constitute 3 phases of the project: 1) to collaboratively develop an implementation framework (action plan) for the CPG with targeted stakeholder groups, 2) to adapt and develop tools and processes for the different users that address pain, fear and fainting mitigation, and 3) to integrate the tools and processes into vaccination clinics at participating schools and evaluate feasibility and preliminary performance measures. We will utilize qualitative and quantitative methods and data will be analyzed sequentially throughout the project as the results of one phase will inform the next.<br>
<strong>Impact:</strong> This study uses a knowledge user-centred approach to address sub-optimal practices during school-based mass vaccination, allowing for approaches that are relevant to the real world. We project downstream benefits on health outcomes by improving preventive health behaviours. Tools and strategies will be shared across the country to inform broader CPG uptake.<br>
<strong>Applicants and Research Environment</strong>: Our study team consists of an accomplished <em>interdisciplinary, multi-sectoral and multi-institutional group of</em> scientists, policy makers and health providers from across Canada. Taddio and MacDonald have extensive clinical research experience; Hirji, Bucci, and Halpert have expertise in health policy/implementation; Taddio, McMurtry and Law have content expertise; this is complemented by discipline-specific skills. Robson provides family/child perspective. The team collaborated on the project plan and is committed to its success, including long-term sustainability.</p>
</body>
</html>
Competitiondate
201510
Approvedterm2
2 yrs 0 mth
Pinamesdelim
Taddio, Anna; Hirji, Mohamed M; McMurtry, C. Meghan
Approvedterm
2 ans 0 mois
Cihrcontribution2
~ $200,000~ $0~