Grant: Project Grant
McMaster University
$267,749.00
Randomized trial Evaluating first time shoulder Dislocation: sUrgery vs Conservative carE (REDUCE)
FY 2024-25
Summary
The shoulder is the most commonly dislocated joint in the body and the most common reason for surgical referral in the young active patient. It is estimated that over 85,000 dislocations occur in North America annually. Anterior dislocations are the most common type of shoulder dislocation and are often complicated by subsequent instability and recurrent dislocation, with reported rates as high as 42%. The estimated annual societal cost in North America due to first-time shoulder dislocations (FTDs) exceeds $1.2 billion CAD. Re-dislocation and continued instability result in decreased quality of life, shoulder pain, and decreased physical activity. The current standard of care for the majority of FTDs is brief immobilization followed by physiotherapy. Failure of non-operative management with a recurrent dislocation or further complaints of instability remain the indication for surgical stabilization. Proponents of the non-operative approach argue that approx. 50% of patients are adequately treated non-operatively without additional surgical risks. Proponents of primary surgical stabilization argue that evidence for early non-operative management is inconclusive, recurrent instability rates are unacceptably high, and delay in treatment results in further injury to the joint. There is no consensus on which produces better outcomes due to a lack of evidence. Available literature consists of 5 small trials with wide CIs, a high fragility index of 3.5, and small sample sizes. Orthopaedic surgeons managing FTDs have little high-quality evidence on which to base clinical decisions, with all available evidence at high risk of bias. We propose a multi-centre pilot RCT to assess the feasibility of a larger trial comparing the effect of surgical stabilization compared to non-operative management in patients with a post-traumatic anterior FTD. The findings of the definitive trial will help guide clinical practice for this challenging clinical scenario.
Department
Program
Project Grant
Recipient
Location
Ontario, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
CIHR Funding Decisions Database
As published
Id
508538
Name
Khan Mohammed M
Region
Ontario
Country
Canada
Orgtype
Institution Paid; Research Institution
Instname2
Musculoskeletal Health and Arthritis
Theme2
Clinical
Prcname2
Clinical Investigation - B 2
Projecttitle
Randomized trial Evaluating first time shoulder Dislocation: sUrgery vs Conservative carE (REDUCE)
Programtype2
Operating Grants
Orgnameinp2
McMaster University
Cihramount2
$267,749
Cihrequipment2
$0
Programname2
Project Grant
Keyworddelim
Orthopaedic Surgery; Pilot Study; Randomized Trial; Shoulder Dislocation; Shoulder Surgery; Sport Medicine
Abstract
The shoulder is the most commonly dislocated joint in the body and the most common reason for surgical referral in the young active patient. It is estimated that over 85,000 dislocations occur in North America annually. Anterior dislocations are the most common type of shoulder dislocation and are often complicated by subsequent instability and recurrent dislocation, with reported rates as high as 42%. The estimated annual societal cost in North America due to first-time shoulder dislocations (FTDs) exceeds $1.2 billion CAD. Re-dislocation and continued instability result in decreased quality of life, shoulder pain, and decreased physical activity. The current standard of care for the majority of FTDs is brief immobilization followed by physiotherapy. Failure of non-operative management with a recurrent dislocation or further complaints of instability remain the indication for surgical stabilization. Proponents of the non-operative approach argue that approx. 50% of patients are adequately treated non-operatively without additional surgical risks. Proponents of primary surgical stabilization argue that evidence for early non-operative management is inconclusive, recurrent instability rates are unacceptably high, and delay in treatment results in further injury to the joint. There is no consensus on which produces better outcomes due to a lack of evidence. Available literature consists of 5 small trials with wide CIs, a high fragility index of 3.5, and small sample sizes. Orthopaedic surgeons managing FTDs have little high-quality evidence on which to base clinical decisions, with all available evidence at high risk of bias. We propose a multi-centre pilot RCT to assess the feasibility of a larger trial comparing the effect of surgical stabilization compared to non-operative management in patients with a post-traumatic anterior FTD. The findings of the definitive trial will help guide clinical practice for this challenging clinical scenario.
Competitiondate
202409
Approvedterm2
3 yrs 0 mth
Pinamesdelim
Khan, Mohammed M
Approvedterm
3 ans 0 mois
Cihrcontribution2
~ $267,749~ $0~