Canada Spends Logo

Explore our Budget 2026 analysis

Grant: Knowledge Synthesis Grant

Université Laval

$100,000.00

Realist review of strategies and impacts of service user and family engagement in collaborative mental health care

FY 2015-16

Summary
Primary care is a crucial part of the mental health system. For the more than 4 million Canadians suffering from depression or anxiety disorders each year, the bulk of their care will be delivered in primary care, most often by family doctors. However, many family doctors find it challenging to provide high-quality depression and anxiety care and there are longstanding quality gaps in the recognition and treatment of these disorders in primary care. This has led to the emergence of a new model of care, called collaborative mental health care (CMHC), in which primary care and mental health providers work more closely together to provide more coordinated, complimentary services. Evidence supporting CMHC’s effectiveness have led to it becoming a focal point of mental health policy in Canada and internationally. Yet CMHC is also a “complex” intervention made up of multiple interacting parts, which poses challenges for implementation and scaling-up given that there is not yet a clear understanding of which intervention components are most important. In May 2014, a group of researchers and knowledge users (KUs) began collaborating in order to shed light on the importance of one component of CMHC of common interest to them, i.e. the engagement of mental health service users and families in care. There is a strong international consensus that such engagement is the foundation for a more effective and person-centred mental health system. Yet across CMHC interventions, some include strategies for engaging service users or their families in care while others do not. The team agreed that clinicians, decision makers and service users currently lacked an awareness of the full range of engagement strategies that could be integrated within CMHC and that major knowledge gaps existed about the specific impacts of these strategies in the context of CMHC. Guided by an integrated KT approach, we thus set out to answer the following research question: What strategies have been used to engage people with depression or anxiety disorders and their families in CMHC and how do these strategies work, for whom, and in what circumstances? Our selected method is a realist review. A realist review is a theory-driven approach to knowledge synthesis where the aim is to build and test theories about how and why interventions work and about the various contextual and other factors that contribute to their success or failure. Our review will combine systematic and iterative approaches and draw on a variety of data sources, including both quantitative and qualitative research. We are a large, interdisciplinary and international team that is primed for success. Our expertise covers key content areas (CMHC, service user and family engagement, interprofessional care) and review methods (systematic reviews, 4 also trained in realist reviews). Two persons with lived experience of depression are core team members and will contribute to all phases of the review. Our KUs are enthusiastic, committed, and positioned to optimize the impacts of this review at provincial, national and international levels. Together we will produce clear guidance on service user and family engagement in CMHC, a better theoretical understanding of how and why engagement strategies work, tools to support implementation, and scientific and lay communications. This review should ultimately lead to the development and spread of more effective, person- and family-centred CMHC in Canada and abroad.
Program
Knowledge Synthesis Grant
Location
Quebec, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
CIHR Funding Decisions Database

As published

Id
330845
Name
Légaré France
Region
Québec
Country
Canada
Orgtype
Institution Paid; Research Institution
Instname2
Health Services and Policy Research
Theme2
Health systems / services
Prcname2
Knowledge Synthesis Grant
Projecttitle
Realist review of strategies and impacts of service user and family engagement in collaborative mental health care
Programtype2
Operating Grants
Orgnameinp2
Université Laval
Cihramount2
$100,000
Cihrequipment2
$0
Programname2
Knowledge Synthesis Grant
Keyworddelim
Collaborative Mental Health Care; Depression And Anxiety; Engaging Caregivers And Families In Care; Integrated Knowledge Translation; Primary Care; Realist Review; Service User Engagement; Theory-Driven Research
Abstract
<html> <body> <p>Primary care is a crucial part of the mental health system. For the more than 4 million Canadians suffering from depression or anxiety disorders each year, the bulk of their care will be delivered in primary care, most often by family doctors. However, many family doctors find it challenging to provide high-quality depression and anxiety care and there are longstanding quality gaps in the recognition and treatment of these disorders in primary care. This has led to the emergence of a new model of care, called collaborative mental health care (CMHC), in which primary care and mental health providers work more closely together to provide more coordinated, complimentary services. Evidence supporting CMHC&rsquo;s effectiveness have led to it becoming a focal point of mental health policy in Canada and internationally. Yet CMHC is also a &ldquo;complex&rdquo; intervention made up of multiple interacting parts, which poses challenges for implementation and scaling-up given that there is not yet a clear understanding of which intervention components are most important.<br> <br> In May 2014, a group of researchers and knowledge users (KUs) began collaborating in order to shed light on the importance of one component of CMHC of common interest to them, i.e. the engagement of mental health service users and families in care. There is a strong international consensus that such engagement is the foundation for a more effective and person-centred mental health system. Yet across CMHC interventions, some include strategies for engaging service users or their families in care while others do not. The team agreed that clinicians, decision makers and service users currently lacked an awareness of the full range of engagement strategies that could be integrated within CMHC and that major knowledge gaps existed about the specific impacts of these strategies in the context of CMHC.<br> <br> Guided by an integrated KT approach, we thus set out to answer the following research question: What strategies have been used to engage people with depression or anxiety disorders and their families in CMHC and how do these strategies work, for whom, and in what circumstances?<br> <br> Our selected method is a realist review. A realist review is a theory-driven approach to knowledge synthesis where the aim is to build and test theories about how and why interventions work and about the various contextual and other factors that contribute to their success or failure. Our review will combine systematic and iterative approaches and draw on a variety of data sources, including both quantitative and qualitative research.<br> <br> We are a large, interdisciplinary and international team that is primed for success. Our expertise covers key content areas (CMHC, service user and family engagement, interprofessional care) and review methods (systematic reviews, 4 also trained in realist reviews). Two persons with lived experience of depression are core team members and will contribute to all phases of the review.<br> <br> Our KUs are enthusiastic, committed, and positioned to optimize the impacts of this review at provincial, national and international levels. Together we will produce clear guidance on service user and family engagement in CMHC, a better theoretical understanding of how and why engagement strategies work, tools to support implementation, and scientific and lay communications. This review should ultimately lead to the development and spread of more effective, person- and family-centred CMHC in Canada and abroad.</p> </body> </html>
Competitiondate
201505
Approvedterm2
1 yr 0 mth
Pinamesdelim
Gervais, Michel; Légaré, France
Approvedterm
1 an 0 mois
Cihrcontribution2
~ $100,000~ $0~
Université Laval - $100,000 Grant (2015-16) | Canada Spends