Canada Spends Logo

Explore our Budget 2026 analysis

Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual

University of Toronto

$43,988.00

The effort paradox: Exploring effort's costs and benefits

FY 2023-24

Summary
Cognitive control allows people to restrain their hearts, bodies, and minds away from the temptations of everyday life and toward safer and healthier ambitions. Although it can be assessed by seemingly trivial tasks (e.g., color naming), cognitive control predicts an impressive variety of behaviors of both personal and societal significance, including weight gain, university grades, problem gambling, and addiction. Given its far reach, the study of cognitive control is of great importance not only to cognitive scientists, but also to economists and other policy makers. The proposed program of research builds on my past work on the basic processes underlying cognitive control, especially my research on the emotional and neural foundations of cognitive control. By studying the phenomenology of control, I have confirmed not only that control feels unpleasant, characterized by feelings of anxiety, frustration, and effort, I have also examined how this unpleasant emotion corresponds with evoked brain potentials, neural oscillations, pupil dilation, and facial muscle movements. Given these emotions and attendant physiological and neurological states, my research has contributed to the view that the effort required for control is unpleasant and that people avoid it. The primary objective of the proposed program of hypothesis-driven research is to explore this effort avoidance to offer clues about how to overcome it. In specific, I examine the neural processes underlying the costs of control by asking not only when effortful control is costly, but also how it might be valued. As part of this program, I will explore how to increase the value of effortful control so that people become more willing to engage it. In contrast to the dominant view in cognitive neuroscience and economics, I have recently proposed the existence of an effort paradox: effort, I suggested, is not only costly, but also valued. Sometimes humans view the same outcomes as more rewarding if more (not less) effort was used to attain them (e.g., running a marathon). Effort can even be experienced as valuable or rewarding in its own right, when high effort is repeatedly paired with high reward. Although there is a convergence of evidence supporting the effort paradox, some aspects of my framework need further empirical support, especially at the level of the human brain. Here, I attempt to integrate the rich evidence that effort can add value with dominant models of effort in neuroscience and economics. In sum, by investigating the effort paradox, I can advance effort theorizing and its widespread applications. I specifically explore how effort adds value retrospectively to the products of our past efforts; but also, how effort adds value prospectively, becoming a secondary reinforcer and rewarding by itself. Given the evidence that effort can add value prospectively, I also examine if I can increase effort willingness by training and rewarding effort.
Program
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Location
Ontario, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data

As published

Application id
RGPIN-2019-05280
Name nom
Inzlicht, Michael
Department département
Psychology and Neuroscience
Organization id
31
Institution établissement
University of Toronto
Province en
Ontario
Province fr
Ontario
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2023
Competition year année de concours
2019
Award amount
43988
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
DISCOVERY RESEARCH
Group fr
RECHERCHE AXÉE SUR LA DÉCOUVERTE
Committee code
1502
Committee name en
Biological Systems and Functions
Committee name fr
Systèmes et fonctions biologiques
Area of application code
1210
Area of application group en
Advancement of knowledge
Area of application group fr
Avancement des connaissances
Area of application en
Psychology
Area of application fr
Psychologie
Research subject code
9999
Research subject group en
Not available
Research subject group fr
Not available
Research subject en
Non disponible
Research subject fr
Non disponible
Application title
The effort paradox: Exploring effort's costs and benefits
Keyword
Cognitive control; EEG; Effort; Effort discounting; Emotion; Learned industriousness; Motivation; Neuroscience
Application summary
Cognitive control allows people to restrain their hearts, bodies, and minds away from the temptations of everyday life and toward safer and healthier ambitions. Although it can be assessed by seemingly trivial tasks (e.g., color naming), cognitive control predicts an impressive variety of behaviors of both personal and societal significance, including weight gain, university grades, problem gambling, and addiction. Given its far reach, the study of cognitive control is of great importance not only to cognitive scientists, but also to economists and other policy makers. The proposed program of research builds on my past work on the basic processes underlying cognitive control, especially my research on the emotional and neural foundations of cognitive control. By studying the phenomenology of control, I have confirmed not only that control feels unpleasant, characterized by feelings of anxiety, frustration, and effort, I have also examined how this unpleasant emotion corresponds with evoked brain potentials, neural oscillations, pupil dilation, and facial muscle movements. Given these emotions and attendant physiological and neurological states, my research has contributed to the view that the effort required for control is unpleasant and that people avoid it. The primary objective of the proposed program of hypothesis-driven research is to explore this effort avoidance to offer clues about how to overcome it. In specific, I examine the neural processes underlying the costs of control by asking not only when effortful control is costly, but also how it might be valued. As part of this program, I will explore how to increase the value of effortful control so that people become more willing to engage it. In contrast to the dominant view in cognitive neuroscience and economics, I have recently proposed the existence of an effort paradox: effort, I suggested, is not only costly, but also valued. Sometimes humans view the same outcomes as more rewarding if more (not less) effort was used to attain them (e.g., running a marathon). Effort can even be experienced as valuable or rewarding in its own right, when high effort is repeatedly paired with high reward. Although there is a convergence of evidence supporting the effort paradox, some aspects of my framework need further empirical support, especially at the level of the human brain. Here, I attempt to integrate the rich evidence that effort can add value with dominant models of effort in neuroscience and economics. In sum, by investigating the effort paradox, I can advance effort theorizing and its widespread applications. I specifically explore how effort adds value retrospectively to the products of our past efforts; but also, how effort adds value prospectively, becoming a secondary reinforcer and rewarding by itself. Given the evidence that effort can add value prospectively, I also examine if I can increase effort willingness by training and rewarding effort.