Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Simon Fraser University
$26,000.00
An epidemiological approach to the analysis of indicators and reference points of ecosystem and population health
FY 2010-11
Summary
Fisheries and ecosystem scientists are often given the role of determining whether a population or ecosystem is healthy for input into conservation and management decisions such as endangered species listings, setting fishing regulations, or permitting for activities such as mining or forestry. For populations, we rely on indicators such as abundance and mortality rates. We could also include factors such as disease prevalence and toxic chemical concentrations. With ecosystems, there are numerous potential indicators such as species richness, food-web complexity, and productivity. However, there is little guidance as to the correct cut-off between healthy and unhealthy for each indicator or how to combine results from multiple indicators.
I propose to learn from the experience of medical researchers, who have been dealing with this very issue for decades. When performing clinical trials to develop a new indicator and reference point for healthy versus unhealthy (e.g., for a new illness), there is often no way to definitively determine whether the test patients have the disease. Statistical methods such as latent class models allow them to determine the cut-offs while taking into account the fact that the cost of a misdiagnosis can be high and asymmetric. A healthy person may get unnecessary treatment, or an ill person may go untreated. These models can then be applied to new patients to estimate the probability they are ill based on a suite of indicators.
The goal of this proposal is to adapt and apply these methods from medical science to the challenges being faced by fisheries and aquatic ecosystem scientists in conservation and management contexts. Despite not being able to definitively determine the health status of our test populations and ecosystems, we will develop indicators and reference points which can then be used to estimate the probability that a population or ecosystem is in an unhealthy state, taking into account the asymmetric costs of a mistake. This will help us better understand the factors related to population and ecosystem health, and will help us make more informed decisions as to when action or increased monitoring is needed.
Program
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Recipient
Location
British Columbia, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data
As published
Application id
371765-2009
Name nom
Cooper, Andrew
Department département
Resource and Environmental Management, School of
Organization id
5
Institution établissement
Simon Fraser University
Province en
British Columbia
Province fr
Colombie-Britannique
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2010
Competition year année de concours
2009
Award amount
26000
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
Discovery grants programs
Group fr
Programmes de subventions à la découverte
Committee code
18
Committee name en
Evolution & Ecology
Committee name fr
Évolution et écologie
Area of application code
405
Area of application group en
Environment
Area of application group fr
Environnement
Area of application en
Modelling and mathematical simulation of natural processes
Area of application fr
Modélisation et simulation mathématique des processus naturels
Research subject code
4702
Research subject group en
Evolution and ecology
Research subject group fr
Évolution et écologie
Research subject en
Aquatic ecology and limnology
Research subject fr
Écologie aquatique et limnologie
Partie
2
Nb partie
5
Application title
An epidemiological approach to the analysis of indicators and reference points of ecosystem and population health
Keyword
NSERC
Application summary
Fisheries and ecosystem scientists are often given the role of determining whether a population or ecosystem is healthy for input into conservation and management decisions such as endangered species listings, setting fishing regulations, or permitting for activities such as mining or forestry. For populations, we rely on indicators such as abundance and mortality rates. We could also include factors such as disease prevalence and toxic chemical concentrations. With ecosystems, there are numerous potential indicators such as species richness, food-web complexity, and productivity. However, there is little guidance as to the correct cut-off between healthy and unhealthy for each indicator or how to combine results from multiple indicators.
I propose to learn from the experience of medical researchers, who have been dealing with this very issue for decades. When performing clinical trials to develop a new indicator and reference point for healthy versus unhealthy (e.g., for a new illness), there is often no way to definitively determine whether the test patients have the disease. Statistical methods such as latent class models allow them to determine the cut-offs while taking into account the fact that the cost of a misdiagnosis can be high and asymmetric. A healthy person may get unnecessary treatment, or an ill person may go untreated. These models can then be applied to new patients to estimate the probability they are ill based on a suite of indicators.
The goal of this proposal is to adapt and apply these methods from medical science to the challenges being faced by fisheries and aquatic ecosystem scientists in conservation and management contexts. Despite not being able to definitively determine the health status of our test populations and ecosystems, we will develop indicators and reference points which can then be used to estimate the probability that a population or ecosystem is in an unhealthy state, taking into account the asymmetric costs of a mistake. This will help us better understand the factors related to population and ecosystem health, and will help us make more informed decisions as to when action or increased monitoring is needed.