Canada Spends Logo

Explore our Budget 2026 analysis

Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual

York University

$18,745.00

Coherence of probability and contingency judgements

FY 2013-14

Summary
A fundamental requirement of human rationality is that judgments be internally consistent and logically coherent. Studies of systematic violations of coherence have revealed much about the cognitive processes underlying judgment, and tests of coherence are of pragmatic value given that they can offer important indications of judgment quality. The overarching objective of this research program is to develop a comprehensive theoretical account of the cognitive processes underlying probability judgment and more complex types of judgment that require the integration of frequency or probability information, such as judgments of contingency and probable causation. The proposed research, which will be comprised of 11 core experiments, will directly build upon recent theoretical developments in cognitive psychology that address the nature of judgment processes. One set of experiments will provide critical tests of recent theories that make specific predictions regarding how information is mentally represented and how such representations, in turn, are used as inputs into assessment processes, which proximally determine judgment responses. A second set of experiments will examine whether systematic violations of coherence in judgment that have been documented in tasks in which all of the relevant information is explicitly described in text are similarly manifested in tasks in which the same information must be acquired through exposure to individual cases presented on a trial-by-trial basis. The final set of experiments will examine whether more complex types of judgment, including causal and non-causal contingency judgments, also exhibit systematic violations of coherence criteria. In particular, these experiments will examine how the formulation of a hypothesis about an inter-event relation influences the manner in which information pertinent to contingency judgment is integrated. The proposed research will draw upon multiple experimental methods and include measures of judgment, belief, response time, representation, and assessment processes. The research findings will be disseminated in peer-review, cognitive psychology journals and at scientific conferences on judgment and reasoning.
Program
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Location
Ontario, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data

As published

Application id
249537-2007
Name nom
Mandel, David
Department département
Psychology
Organization id
38
Institution établissement
York University
Province en
Ontario
Province fr
Ontario
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2013
Competition year année de concours
2007
Award amount
18745
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
Discovery grants programs
Group fr
Programmes de subventions à la découverte
Committee code
12
Committee name en
Psychology: Brain, Behaviour & Cognitive Sciences
Committee name fr
Psychologie: Cerveau, comportement et science cognitive
Area of application code
405
Area of application group en
Environment
Area of application group fr
Environnement
Area of application en
Modelling and mathematical simulation of natural processes
Area of application fr
Modélisation et simulation mathématique des processus naturels
Research subject code
6304
Research subject group en
Psychology
Research subject group fr
Psychologie
Research subject en
Cognitive science -- fundamental
Research subject fr
Science cognitive -- principes fondamentaux
Partie
5
Nb partie
5
Application title
Coherence of probability and contingency judgements
Keyword
NSERC
Application summary
A fundamental requirement of human rationality is that judgments be internally consistent and logically coherent. Studies of systematic violations of coherence have revealed much about the cognitive processes underlying judgment, and tests of coherence are of pragmatic value given that they can offer important indications of judgment quality. The overarching objective of this research program is to develop a comprehensive theoretical account of the cognitive processes underlying probability judgment and more complex types of judgment that require the integration of frequency or probability information, such as judgments of contingency and probable causation. The proposed research, which will be comprised of 11 core experiments, will directly build upon recent theoretical developments in cognitive psychology that address the nature of judgment processes. One set of experiments will provide critical tests of recent theories that make specific predictions regarding how information is mentally represented and how such representations, in turn, are used as inputs into assessment processes, which proximally determine judgment responses. A second set of experiments will examine whether systematic violations of coherence in judgment that have been documented in tasks in which all of the relevant information is explicitly described in text are similarly manifested in tasks in which the same information must be acquired through exposure to individual cases presented on a trial-by-trial basis. The final set of experiments will examine whether more complex types of judgment, including causal and non-causal contingency judgments, also exhibit systematic violations of coherence criteria. In particular, these experiments will examine how the formulation of a hypothesis about an inter-event relation influences the manner in which information pertinent to contingency judgment is integrated. The proposed research will draw upon multiple experimental methods and include measures of judgment, belief, response time, representation, and assessment processes. The research findings will be disseminated in peer-review, cognitive psychology journals and at scientific conferences on judgment and reasoning.