Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual
University of Waterloo
$56,000.00
Narrative Representations in Decision-Making Under Uncertainty: Deconstructing the Currency of Thought
FY 2023-24
Summary
Many of life's decisions are based on narratives-mental representations incorporating several kinds of structure, including causation, analogy, time, and valence-as my research program has shown (Johnson et al., 2022, BBS). For example, a decision whether to marry depends on causal knowledge about relationships, analogies to others' marriages, and more. Although cognitive science has long studied mental representation-how our minds format information for cognitive processing-little is known about how our minds coordinate different kinds of structure represented jointly, as in many real-world choices. The next phase in my research program, thus, poses a fundamental question about cognitive mechanisms: How do people structure, construct, and update mental representations that coordinate multiple types of information? Four short-term objectives will guide this quest: First, my lab will develop a computational model formalizing a mechanistic theory of narrative representation. This model implements both an account of how narratives are mentally structured and how they are processed (constructed and updated). It embodies assumptions, based on my own and others' prior research, about what makes a narrative coherent and why one narrative is selected over another. Second, we will compile a corpus of real narratives underlying major life decisions using interviews. After extracting the formal structure underlying the verbal narratives-using both content coding and computational linguistics techniques-we will use this corpus to test the model's assumptions. Third, we will use memory experiments to test the mechanisms underlying narrative coherence. The model predicts that, given an incomplete narrative, people will falsely remember information they infer via the coherence principles. Fourth, we will use reasoning experiments to test the mechanisms underlying how narratives are constructed and then updated with new information. We will compare participants' inferences with the model. Collectively, this research yields a comprehensive model of how our minds coordinate multiple types of information into unified narratives, feeding into my lab's long-term vision to understand how sense-making processes underlie thought and action: How narratives act as a currency of thought. This work creates training opportunities for 2 MAs, 3 PhDs, and 6 undergraduates, who will learn computational modeling, experimental design, statistical analysis, and text mining-skills in demand both in academia and industry (e.g., data science, user experience research). It will inform conversations in cognitive science around explanation, causation, analogy, representation, and decision-making, as one of the first attempts to formally model and experimentally test the state-of-the-art in explanatory reasoning for complex, realistic systems of information. Beyond academia, this work will have implications for high-stakes decision-making and explainable artificial intelligence.
Program
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Recipient
Location
Ontario, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data
As published
Application id
RGPIN-2023-03700
Name nom
Johnson, Samuel
Department département
Psychology
Organization id
33
Institution établissement
University of Waterloo
Province en
Ontario
Province fr
Ontario
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2023
Competition year année de concours
2023
Award amount
56000
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
DISCOVERY RESEARCH
Group fr
RECHERCHE AXÉE SUR LA DÉCOUVERTE
Committee code
1502
Committee name en
Biological Systems and Functions
Committee name fr
Systèmes et fonctions biologiques
Area of application code
1210
Area of application group en
Advancement of knowledge
Area of application group fr
Avancement des connaissances
Area of application en
Psychology
Area of application fr
Psychologie
Research subject code
9999
Research subject group en
Not available
Research subject group fr
Not available
Research subject en
Non disponible
Research subject fr
Non disponible
Application title
Narrative Representations in Decision-Making Under Uncertainty: Deconstructing the Currency of Thought
Keyword
Analogy; Causal reasoning; Decision-making; Intuitive theories; Judgment; Mental representation; Narratives; Reasoning
Application summary
Many of life's decisions are based on narratives-mental representations incorporating several kinds of structure, including causation, analogy, time, and valence-as my research program has shown (Johnson et al., 2022, BBS). For example, a decision whether to marry depends on causal knowledge about relationships, analogies to others' marriages, and more. Although cognitive science has long studied mental representation-how our minds format information for cognitive processing-little is known about how our minds coordinate different kinds of structure represented jointly, as in many real-world choices. The next phase in my research program, thus, poses a fundamental question about cognitive mechanisms: How do people structure, construct, and update mental representations that coordinate multiple types of information? Four short-term objectives will guide this quest: First, my lab will develop a computational model formalizing a mechanistic theory of narrative representation. This model implements both an account of how narratives are mentally structured and how they are processed (constructed and updated). It embodies assumptions, based on my own and others' prior research, about what makes a narrative coherent and why one narrative is selected over another. Second, we will compile a corpus of real narratives underlying major life decisions using interviews. After extracting the formal structure underlying the verbal narratives-using both content coding and computational linguistics techniques-we will use this corpus to test the model's assumptions. Third, we will use memory experiments to test the mechanisms underlying narrative coherence. The model predicts that, given an incomplete narrative, people will falsely remember information they infer via the coherence principles. Fourth, we will use reasoning experiments to test the mechanisms underlying how narratives are constructed and then updated with new information. We will compare participants' inferences with the model. Collectively, this research yields a comprehensive model of how our minds coordinate multiple types of information into unified narratives, feeding into my lab's long-term vision to understand how sense-making processes underlie thought and action: How narratives act as a currency of thought. This work creates training opportunities for 2 MAs, 3 PhDs, and 6 undergraduates, who will learn computational modeling, experimental design, statistical analysis, and text mining-skills in demand both in academia and industry (e.g., data science, user experience research). It will inform conversations in cognitive science around explanation, causation, analogy, representation, and decision-making, as one of the first attempts to formally model and experimentally test the state-of-the-art in explanatory reasoning for complex, realistic systems of information. Beyond academia, this work will have implications for high-stakes decision-making and explainable artificial intelligence.