Canada Spends Logo

Explore our Budget 2026 analysis

Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual

Simon Fraser University

$46,000.00

The formation and consequences of illusory belief

FY 2024-25

Summary
True or false: COVID-19 is a hoax. Consider a situation in which you evaluate this claim along with a photo of the virus. Does the photo tilt you towards saying, "True"? The idea seems ludicrous-after all, the virus photo is merely decorative. It provides no evidence to help you evaluate the claim. But dozens of experiments on thousands of adults worldwide show that this combination of photo plus claim nudges people towards saying the claim is true. The comedian Steven Colbert calls this bias "truthiness," a tendency to search for truth as a feeling in your gut rather than in books. But believing that COVID-19 is a hoax is no joke. This illusory belief has wreaked havoc worldwide. Just as photos that accompany claims increase our belief (truthiness), so too does repeating the claims (the truth effect) and solving an anagram prior to evaluating the claims (the revelation effect). For example, solving, "The pleoard is the fastest land animal" nudges us towards believing that leopards are indeed the fastest land animal (it's actually the cheetah!). In the proposed work, we examine how these three different nudges cause us to misinterpret our gut feelings, affecting our behaviors. We propose 4 projects. Projects 1-3 explore the mechanisms underlying the formation of illusory beliefs; Project 4 explores the consequences of illusory beliefs on our behavior. We focus on two main theories to explain the formation of illusory beliefs: fluency misattribution and referential theory. Fluency misattribution proposes that photos, repetition, and solving anagrams all impact the speed and ease with which people process the claims, leading people to mistake (or misattribute) that fluency as evidence of the claims' truth. Referential theory proposes that photos, repetition, and solving anagrams all change the way people draw on their memory to determine if different parts of a statement are consistent and make sense. Both theories relate to our gut feelings but provide unique predictions that can be tested experimentally by pairing these nudges with coherent and/or contradictory information and measuring response times. Projects 1-3 test fluency misattribution and referential theory predictions while Project 4 focuses on how illusory beliefs affect our behaviours and memory. Specifically, after viewing claims with photos, repeated claims, or solving anagrams related to claims, participants will indicate which claims are true (Projects 1-3). Immediately following each truth claim, participants will indicate which claims they like, or want to share with friends in their social network, or want to fact-check (Project 4). This research has scientific and applied relevance to belief formation and can inform policy on the impact of illusory beliefs in real-world contexts (e.g., social media). The testing of theoretical assumptions benefits the cognitive and behavioural sciences.
Program
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Location
British Columbia, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data

As published

Application id
RGPIN-2024-04193
Name nom
Bernstein, Daniel
Department département
Psychology
Organization id
5
Institution établissement
Simon Fraser University
Province en
British Columbia
Province fr
Colombie-Britannique
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2024
Competition year année de concours
2024
Award amount
46000
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
DISCOVERY RESEARCH
Group fr
RECHERCHE AXÉE SUR LA DÉCOUVERTE
Committee code
1502
Committee name en
Biological Systems and Functions
Committee name fr
Systèmes et fonctions biologiques
Area of application code
1210
Area of application group en
Advancement of knowledge
Area of application group fr
Avancement des connaissances
Area of application en
Psychology
Area of application fr
Psychologie
Research subject code
6300
Research subject group en
Psychology
Research subject group fr
Psychologie
Research subject en
Psychology
Research subject fr
Psychologie
Field of research list names en
Not available
Field of research list names fr
Non disponible
Socioeconomic objective list names en
Not available
Socioeconomic objective list names fr
Non disponible
Application title
The formation and consequences of illusory belief
Keywords
belief; fluency; illusory truth; misinformation; truthiness; fake news
Application summary
True or false: COVID-19 is a hoax. Consider a situation in which you evaluate this claim along with a photo of the virus. Does the photo tilt you towards saying, "True"? The idea seems ludicrous-after all, the virus photo is merely decorative. It provides no evidence to help you evaluate the claim. But dozens of experiments on thousands of adults worldwide show that this combination of photo plus claim nudges people towards saying the claim is true. The comedian Steven Colbert calls this bias "truthiness," a tendency to search for truth as a feeling in your gut rather than in books. But believing that COVID-19 is a hoax is no joke. This illusory belief has wreaked havoc worldwide. Just as photos that accompany claims increase our belief (truthiness), so too does repeating the claims (the truth effect) and solving an anagram prior to evaluating the claims (the revelation effect). For example, solving, "The pleoard is the fastest land animal" nudges us towards believing that leopards are indeed the fastest land animal (it's actually the cheetah!). In the proposed work, we examine how these three different nudges cause us to misinterpret our gut feelings, affecting our behaviors. We propose 4 projects. Projects 1-3 explore the mechanisms underlying the formation of illusory beliefs; Project 4 explores the consequences of illusory beliefs on our behavior. We focus on two main theories to explain the formation of illusory beliefs: fluency misattribution and referential theory. Fluency misattribution proposes that photos, repetition, and solving anagrams all impact the speed and ease with which people process the claims, leading people to mistake (or misattribute) that fluency as evidence of the claims' truth. Referential theory proposes that photos, repetition, and solving anagrams all change the way people draw on their memory to determine if different parts of a statement are consistent and make sense. Both theories relate to our gut feelings but provide unique predictions that can be tested experimentally by pairing these nudges with coherent and/or contradictory information and measuring response times. Projects 1-3 test fluency misattribution and referential theory predictions while Project 4 focuses on how illusory beliefs affect our behaviours and memory. Specifically, after viewing claims with photos, repeated claims, or solving anagrams related to claims, participants will indicate which claims are true (Projects 1-3). Immediately following each truth claim, participants will indicate which claims they like, or want to share with friends in their social network, or want to fact-check (Project 4). This research has scientific and applied relevance to belief formation and can inform policy on the impact of illusory beliefs in real-world contexts (e.g., social media). The testing of theoretical assumptions benefits the cognitive and behavioural sciences.