Grant: Collaborative Research and Development Grants
University of British Columbia
$14,550.00
Stability of reinforced masonry shear walls under seismic loading
FY 2011-12
Summary
Reinforced masonry (RM) shear walls constructed using hollow concrete blocks reinforced with vertical and
horizontal bars can provide a high degree of seismic protection. In Canada, RM buildings are designed using
the Masonry Design Standard (CSA S304.1-04) and the National Building Code of Canada 2005 (NBCC
2005). CSA S304.1 and NBCC 2005 classify RM walls based on their ability to dissipate energy during
earthquake shaking as either ""Conventional Masonry Shear Walls"" (Rd=1.5) or ""Moderately Ductile Masonry
Shear Walls"" (Rd=2.0), with the latter requiring more complex detailing to ensure better performance during an
earthquake. NBCC 2005 requires that an Rd factor of at least 2.0 is provided for post-disaster buildings, which
mandates the use of ""Moderately Ductile Shear Walls"" for such buildings. However, some design requirements
for ""Moderately Ductile Shear Walls"" in CSA S304.1-04 have made this form of structural system impractical
for many common masonry design applications in most of Canada, including in major urban centres with low
seismic risk such as Toronto. The most significant CSA S304.1-04 seismic requirements impacting the
application of RM are the very stringent limits placed on the h/t ratio of 14 to 20 for Moderately Ductile Walls.
These restrictions have been included in CSA S304.1 seismic provisions to ensure stability of RM walls under
the combined effects of axial loads and in-plane bending moments. While out-of-plane instability failures have
frequently been observed in laboratory tests of reinforced concrete walls, there is no indication from past
laboratory tests that RM walls are also vulnerable to this failure mode. The absence of experimental evidence
related to the out-of-plane instability of RM shear walls justifies the need for the proposed research project.
Through systematic experimental and analytical studies, it is expected that the findings of the proposed
research will confirm that the current CSA S304.1 h/t ratio restrictions are excessively stringent. The general
objective of this project is to establish rational criteria for assessing the out-of-plane stability of RM shear walls
and ensure safe and economical seismic design of RM shear wall structures in Canada.
Program
Collaborative Research and Development Grants
Recipient
Location
British Columbia, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data
As published
Application id
390839-2009
Name nom
Elwood, Kenneth
Department département
Civil Engineering
Organization id
2
Institution établissement
University of British Columbia
Province en
British Columbia
Province fr
Colombie-Britannique
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2011
Competition year année de concours
2009
Award amount
14550
Program id
CRDPJ
Program nane en
Collaborative Research and Development Grants
Program name fr
Subventions de recherche et développement coopérative
Group en
Research partnerships programs
Group fr
Programmes de partenariat
Committee code
96
Committee name en
RPP Internal Decision Cttee
Committee name fr
Cté de décision interne - PPR
Area of application code
601
Area of application group en
Construction, urban and rural planning
Area of application group fr
Construction, urbanisme et aménagement rural
Area of application en
Structural engineering
Area of application fr
Génie des charpentes
Research subject code
1100
Research subject group en
Structural engineering
Research subject group fr
Génie des structures
Research subject en
Structural engineering
Research subject fr
Génie des structures
Partie
2
Nb partie
4
Application title
Stability of reinforced masonry shear walls under seismic loading
Keyword
NSERC
Application summary
Reinforced masonry (RM) shear walls constructed using hollow concrete blocks reinforced with vertical and
horizontal bars can provide a high degree of seismic protection. In Canada, RM buildings are designed using
the Masonry Design Standard (CSA S304.1-04) and the National Building Code of Canada 2005 (NBCC
2005). CSA S304.1 and NBCC 2005 classify RM walls based on their ability to dissipate energy during
earthquake shaking as either ""Conventional Masonry Shear Walls"" (Rd=1.5) or ""Moderately Ductile Masonry
Shear Walls"" (Rd=2.0), with the latter requiring more complex detailing to ensure better performance during an
earthquake. NBCC 2005 requires that an Rd factor of at least 2.0 is provided for post-disaster buildings, which
mandates the use of ""Moderately Ductile Shear Walls"" for such buildings. However, some design requirements
for ""Moderately Ductile Shear Walls"" in CSA S304.1-04 have made this form of structural system impractical
for many common masonry design applications in most of Canada, including in major urban centres with low
seismic risk such as Toronto. The most significant CSA S304.1-04 seismic requirements impacting the
application of RM are the very stringent limits placed on the h/t ratio of 14 to 20 for Moderately Ductile Walls.
These restrictions have been included in CSA S304.1 seismic provisions to ensure stability of RM walls under
the combined effects of axial loads and in-plane bending moments. While out-of-plane instability failures have
frequently been observed in laboratory tests of reinforced concrete walls, there is no indication from past
laboratory tests that RM walls are also vulnerable to this failure mode. The absence of experimental evidence
related to the out-of-plane instability of RM shear walls justifies the need for the proposed research project.
Through systematic experimental and analytical studies, it is expected that the findings of the proposed
research will confirm that the current CSA S304.1 h/t ratio restrictions are excessively stringent. The general
objective of this project is to establish rational criteria for assessing the out-of-plane stability of RM shear walls
and ensure safe and economical seismic design of RM shear wall structures in Canada.