Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual
University of Victoria
$72,000.00
Source Monitoring and Response Bias in Human Memory
FY 2016-17
Summary
I propose two lines of research aimed at breakthrough discoveries concerning basic mechanisms of human memory. 1. I will continue my decades-long study of source monitoring, the hypothesized mechanisms by which thoughts and images are attributed to particular sources (e.g., memory vs. inference; memory of a witnessed event vs. of suggestions). Three sub-lines will advance this program of research in fundamentally new and innovative directions: (1a) In a set of co-witness memory studies, we will employ a ground-breaking technology that uses polarized filters to enable two people to sit side by side watching the same back-projection screen and see different versions of a video. This creates rich conditions for co-witness contamination when the two witnesses are invited to talk together about the video event, enabling us to study the conditions that modulate the likelihood that one witness will incorporate portions of another's report into their own memories of the event. (1b) In a series of studies my students and I will explore ""suggested invisibility,"" through which subjects are led to report that they had NOT seen particular witnessed details that they had in fact seen. (1c) In a third sub-line of research on source monitoring, I will extend prior work with Maryanne Garry (Victoria U of Wellington, NZ) testing the idea that accompanying claims with non-probative photos can nudge people toward believing the claims (""truthiness""); the new line of proposed studies tests the hypothesis that photos can have parallel effects on subjects' predictions for the future. 2. The second proposed major line of research aims to contribute to theoretical accounts of response bias in recognition memory. Subjects tested on recognition can exhibit liberal bias (i.e., more often err by saying ""Yes"" when they should say ""No"") or conservative bias (more often err by saying ""No"" when they should say ""Yes"") or no bias (make the two kinds of errors equally often). Bias greatly affects behaviour (e.g., if a soldier erroneously recognizes a civilian as a combatant a tragedy may ensue). (2a) I will follow up my recent discovery, with then-student Justin Kantner (now Assist. Prof. at Cal State Northridge) that there are stable individual differences in response bias: Some people tend to be liberal, others conservative, others neutral. I aim to uncover the mechanisms that underlie this individual difference. (2b) I also aim to illuminate the mechanisms that underlie effects of stimulus materials on response bias. With word lists, response bias on average tends to be neutral (even though some individual subjects are conservative and others are liberal). But we recently discovered that with certain kinds of materials (e.g., scans of paintings) bias is strikingly conservative. There is very little prior research on how and why bias differs across individuals and materials and this work will greatly contribute to models of response bias.
Program
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Recipient
Location
British Columbia, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data
As published
Application id
RGPIN-2016-03944
Name nom
Lindsay, DStephen
Department département
Psychology - Psychology
Organization id
7
Institution établissement
University of Victoria
Province en
British Columbia
Province fr
Colombie-Britannique
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2016
Competition year année de concours
2016
Award amount
72000
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
Discovery grants programs
Group fr
Programmes de subventions à la découverte
Committee code
1502
Committee name en
Biological Systems and Functions
Committee name fr
Systèmes et fonctions biologiques
Area of application code
1210
Area of application group en
Advancement of knowledge
Area of application group fr
Avancement des connaissances
Area of application en
Psychology
Area of application fr
Psychologie
Research subject code
6304
Research subject group en
Psychology
Research subject group fr
Psychologie
Research subject en
Cognitive science -- fundamental
Research subject fr
Science cognitive -- principes fondamentaux
Partie
1
Nb partie
5
Application title
Source Monitoring and Response Bias in Human Memory
Keyword
NSERC
Application summary
I propose two lines of research aimed at breakthrough discoveries concerning basic mechanisms of human memory. 1. I will continue my decades-long study of source monitoring, the hypothesized mechanisms by which thoughts and images are attributed to particular sources (e.g., memory vs. inference; memory of a witnessed event vs. of suggestions). Three sub-lines will advance this program of research in fundamentally new and innovative directions: (1a) In a set of co-witness memory studies, we will employ a ground-breaking technology that uses polarized filters to enable two people to sit side by side watching the same back-projection screen and see different versions of a video. This creates rich conditions for co-witness contamination when the two witnesses are invited to talk together about the video event, enabling us to study the conditions that modulate the likelihood that one witness will incorporate portions of another's report into their own memories of the event. (1b) In a series of studies my students and I will explore ""suggested invisibility,"" through which subjects are led to report that they had NOT seen particular witnessed details that they had in fact seen. (1c) In a third sub-line of research on source monitoring, I will extend prior work with Maryanne Garry (Victoria U of Wellington, NZ) testing the idea that accompanying claims with non-probative photos can nudge people toward believing the claims (""truthiness""); the new line of proposed studies tests the hypothesis that photos can have parallel effects on subjects' predictions for the future. 2. The second proposed major line of research aims to contribute to theoretical accounts of response bias in recognition memory. Subjects tested on recognition can exhibit liberal bias (i.e., more often err by saying ""Yes"" when they should say ""No"") or conservative bias (more often err by saying ""No"" when they should say ""Yes"") or no bias (make the two kinds of errors equally often). Bias greatly affects behaviour (e.g., if a soldier erroneously recognizes a civilian as a combatant a tragedy may ensue). (2a) I will follow up my recent discovery, with then-student Justin Kantner (now Assist. Prof. at Cal State Northridge) that there are stable individual differences in response bias: Some people tend to be liberal, others conservative, others neutral. I aim to uncover the mechanisms that underlie this individual difference. (2b) I also aim to illuminate the mechanisms that underlie effects of stimulus materials on response bias. With word lists, response bias on average tends to be neutral (even though some individual subjects are conservative and others are liberal). But we recently discovered that with certain kinds of materials (e.g., scans of paintings) bias is strikingly conservative. There is very little prior research on how and why bias differs across individuals and materials and this work will greatly contribute to models of response bias.