Canada Spends Logo

Explore our Budget 2026 analysis

Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual

York University

$20,000.00

Eliciting and Using Goal Variability

FY 2014-15

Summary
Goal models are a popular approach for modeling and reasoning about stakeholder intentions in requirements engineering. They have particularly been proposed for use in decision making both during early requirements analysis, when the right set of features for a future system is sought, and at run-time, when stakeholder needs must translate into configurations of a running system. In this proposal we focus on the study of goal models along three directions: (a) their comprehensibility and use as visual artifacts, (b) their elicitation from stakeholders and (c) their utilization in software configuration and customization. With respect to comprehensibility we propose to experimentally study the value of goal models as visual artifacts that facilitate ad-hoc identification of optimal solutions. We are particularly interested in contribution links, elements in the goal models that represent how satisfaction of one stakeholder goal influences satisfaction of the other. We want to study what ways to represent contributions is more suitable for ad-hoc exploration of optimal solutions. We also propose to compare goal models with other decision support visualizations as well as to study whether interaction with automated reasoning tools we have proposed in the past facilitates comprehension. With respect to elicitation, we are interested in how two basic components of goal models come about: the aforementioned contribution elements and variability-inducing decompositions. In terms of contribution elements, we firstly propose to study the role of assumed context and cognitive biases during their elicitation. Our early experiments suggest that such factors can influence the validity of the elicited contribution measures. We also propose to study the role of the choice of elicitation instrument (e.g. various versions of qualitative vs. quantitative scales) in acquiring reliable contribution measures. Variability-inducing decompositions, moreover, are refinements of goals that introduce variation (i.e. decision) points. In the past we have introduced a systematic approach to acquiring such variation points, which we now wish to empirically evaluate in terms of the quality and completeness of the variability it results to. In terms of software configuration and customization, we propose to continue our current work on the design of highly-customizable systems as well as the configuration of existing systems. With respect to designing highly-customizable systems we propose to extend our earlier work on policy-based behavioral customization and define more rigorous ways for developing systems that behave according to policy objects that are directly derived from goal and other requirements models. In terms of existing systems, we propose to study application of conceptual modeling and automated reasoning techniques in order to facilitate configuration of large and complex information systems. We also propose to study common popular systems and the use of data mining techniques for identifying configuration patterns within large numbers of users, aiming at using those patterns for informing and facilitating the configuration process. The proposed research is targeted towards aspects of goal modeling that we find important for enabling its adoption in the industry. We believe that concrete evidence on how we can elicit valid goal models and use them effectively for problem exploration and understanding will make them more appealing to practitioners. Likewise, introducing requirements-based toolsets for defining and controlling variability in software systems both makes the customization process more accessible and efficient and allows software engineers to dramatically increase the adaptability of their systems.
Program
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Location
Ontario, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data

As published

Application id
RGPIN-2014-05824
Name nom
Liaskos, Sotirios
Department département
School of Information Technology
Organization id
38
Institution établissement
York University
Province en
Ontario
Province fr
Ontario
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2014
Competition year année de concours
2014
Award amount
20000
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
Discovery grants programs
Group fr
Programmes de subventions à la découverte
Committee code
1507
Committee name en
Computer Science
Committee name fr
Sciences informatiques
Area of application code
802
Area of application group en
Information and communication services
Area of application group fr
Services d'information et de télécommunications
Area of application en
Information systems and technology
Area of application fr
Systèmes d'information et technologie de l'information
Research subject code
2706
Research subject group en
Information technology
Research subject group fr
Technologie de l'information
Research subject en
Software engineering
Research subject fr
Génie logiciel
Partie
1
Nb partie
5
Application title
Eliciting and Using Goal Variability
Keyword
NSERC
Application summary
Goal models are a popular approach for modeling and reasoning about stakeholder intentions in requirements engineering. They have particularly been proposed for use in decision making both during early requirements analysis, when the right set of features for a future system is sought, and at run-time, when stakeholder needs must translate into configurations of a running system. In this proposal we focus on the study of goal models along three directions: (a) their comprehensibility and use as visual artifacts, (b) their elicitation from stakeholders and (c) their utilization in software configuration and customization. With respect to comprehensibility we propose to experimentally study the value of goal models as visual artifacts that facilitate ad-hoc identification of optimal solutions. We are particularly interested in contribution links, elements in the goal models that represent how satisfaction of one stakeholder goal influences satisfaction of the other. We want to study what ways to represent contributions is more suitable for ad-hoc exploration of optimal solutions. We also propose to compare goal models with other decision support visualizations as well as to study whether interaction with automated reasoning tools we have proposed in the past facilitates comprehension. With respect to elicitation, we are interested in how two basic components of goal models come about: the aforementioned contribution elements and variability-inducing decompositions. In terms of contribution elements, we firstly propose to study the role of assumed context and cognitive biases during their elicitation. Our early experiments suggest that such factors can influence the validity of the elicited contribution measures. We also propose to study the role of the choice of elicitation instrument (e.g. various versions of qualitative vs. quantitative scales) in acquiring reliable contribution measures. Variability-inducing decompositions, moreover, are refinements of goals that introduce variation (i.e. decision) points. In the past we have introduced a systematic approach to acquiring such variation points, which we now wish to empirically evaluate in terms of the quality and completeness of the variability it results to. In terms of software configuration and customization, we propose to continue our current work on the design of highly-customizable systems as well as the configuration of existing systems. With respect to designing highly-customizable systems we propose to extend our earlier work on policy-based behavioral customization and define more rigorous ways for developing systems that behave according to policy objects that are directly derived from goal and other requirements models. In terms of existing systems, we propose to study application of conceptual modeling and automated reasoning techniques in order to facilitate configuration of large and complex information systems. We also propose to study common popular systems and the use of data mining techniques for identifying configuration patterns within large numbers of users, aiming at using those patterns for informing and facilitating the configuration process. The proposed research is targeted towards aspects of goal modeling that we find important for enabling its adoption in the industry. We believe that concrete evidence on how we can elicit valid goal models and use them effectively for problem exploration and understanding will make them more appealing to practitioners. Likewise, introducing requirements-based toolsets for defining and controlling variability in software systems both makes the customization process more accessible and efficient and allows software engineers to dramatically increase the adaptability of their systems.
York University - $20,000 Grant (2014-15) | Canada Spends