Canada Spends Logo

Explore our Budget 2026 analysis

Grant: Knowledge Synthesis Grant - PA: Musculoskeletal Health, Skin & Oral Health

University of Calgary

$95,814.00

Resurfacing as an Alternative to Total Hip Arthroplasty -Knowledge Synthesis of the Causes and Rates of Early Failure

FY 2010-11

Summary
Hip resurfacing is an increasingly popular surgical approach which was developed as an alternative to total hip replacement specifically for younger active patients. In resurfacing, the head of the femur is not removed, but reshaped to accept a new metal-on-metal prosthesis. The safety of resurfacing is controversial given reports of increased risk of adverse events which may lead to early failure (resulting in revisions and reoperations). Despite concerns, there has been no comprehensive, global synthesis on resurfacing safety that addresses differential revision rates by prosthesis type, patient subgroups and prosthesis placement. We propose to undertake a comprehensive search and review of the current literature on the safety of all types of hip resurfacing in hip osteoarthritis patients and report early failure (within 5 years) as a consequence of adverse events and complications compared to the conventional total hip replacement We will follow well-established guidance for undertaking systematic reviews in consultation with our project team and Bone and Joint Clinical Network (BJCN) of Alberta Health Services. We will examine the findings specifically with respect to the type of prosthesis used, reported functional improvement, and patient subgroups (e.g. age, gender, pre-operative diagnosis) who benefit most. We will select studies using predefined criteria using a two-stage review process and evaluate study quality using established instruments. Our findings are important for BJCN because they will use the knowledge synthesis performed here to inform to inform decisions about whether or not resurfacing is safe, and whether only certain types of prostheses should be adopted. The findings will be shared with all surgeons within the province and, if appropriate, will be used by BJCN to alter the procurement, selection process and modify our provincial standard of care. Information will also be shared nationally and internationally as soon as it is available.
Program
Knowledge Synthesis Grant - PA: Musculoskeletal Health, Skin & Oral Health
Location
Alberta, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
CIHR Funding Decisions Database

As published

Id
208242
Name
Marshall Deborah A
Region
Alberta
Country
Canada
Orgtype
Institution Paid; Research Institution
Instname2
Musculoskeletal Health and Arthritis
Theme2
Health systems / services
Prcname2
Knowledge Synthesis Grant
Projecttitle
Resurfacing as an Alternative to Total Hip Arthroplasty -Knowledge Synthesis of the Causes and Rates of Early Failure
Programtype2
Operating Grants
Orgnameinp2
University of Calgary
Cihramount2
$95,814
Cihrequipment2
$0
Programname2
Knowledge Synthesis Grant - PA: Musculoskeletal Health, Skin & Oral Health
Keyworddelim
Arthroplasty Resurfacing; Joint Replacement; Knowledge Synthesis; Knowledge Translation; Osteoarthritis; Systematic Review; Total Hip Replacement
Abstract
Hip resurfacing is an increasingly popular surgical approach which was developed as an alternative to total hip replacement specifically for younger active patients. In resurfacing, the head of the femur is not removed, but reshaped to accept a new metal-on-metal prosthesis. The safety of resurfacing is controversial given reports of increased risk of adverse events which may lead to early failure (resulting in revisions and reoperations). Despite concerns, there has been no comprehensive, global synthesis on resurfacing safety that addresses differential revision rates by prosthesis type, patient subgroups and prosthesis placement. We propose to undertake a comprehensive search and review of the current literature on the safety of all types of hip resurfacing in hip osteoarthritis patients and report early failure (within 5 years) as a consequence of adverse events and complications compared to the conventional total hip replacement We will follow well-established guidance for undertaking systematic reviews in consultation with our project team and Bone and Joint Clinical Network (BJCN) of Alberta Health Services. We will examine the findings specifically with respect to the type of prosthesis used, reported functional improvement, and patient subgroups (e.g. age, gender, pre-operative diagnosis) who benefit most. We will select studies using predefined criteria using a two-stage review process and evaluate study quality using established instruments. Our findings are important for BJCN because they will use the knowledge synthesis performed here to inform to inform decisions about whether or not resurfacing is safe, and whether only certain types of prostheses should be adopted. The findings will be shared with all surgeons within the province and, if appropriate, will be used by BJCN to alter the procurement, selection process and modify our provincial standard of care. Information will also be shared nationally and internationally as soon as it is available.
Competitiondate
201005
Approvedterm2
1 yr 0 mth
Pinamesdelim
Marshall, Deborah A; Wasylak, Tracy J
Approvedterm
1 an 0 mois
Cihrcontribution2
~ $95,814~ $0~
University of Calgary - $95,814 Grant (2010-11) | Canada Spends