Grant: Project Grant - Priority Announcement: Patient-Oriented Research
University of Ottawa
$100,000.00
Which mental health classification serves Canada best? A mixed methods, multicenter comparison of the World Health Organization's ICD-11 Clinical Descriptions and Diagnostic Guidelines with the American Psychiatric Association's DSM-5.
FY 2021-22
Summary
Mental health problems are the number one source of disability among Canadians, affecting their ability to lead productive and fulfilling lives. There continue to be major gaps between those needing care and those receiving it from health services. A key barrier to receiving accurate and timely care is the proper identification of mental health problems. Specialists rely on classifications to properly identify mental health problems. Although the Canadian government must use the World Health Organization (WHO)'s classification, the International Classification of Disease (ICD) to tally diseases including mental health problems for public health purposes, clinicians serving patients use the American Psychiatric Association's classification, the DSM-5, to make their diagnoses. Historically the DSM and ICD systems were comparable but the recently revised version of the ICD, ICD-11, differs significantly from DSM-5. Researchers have found serious problems with DSM-5 including the way it defines mental health problems, the ability of clinicians to use the system reliably, and its usefulness in making care decisions. In contrast, the ICD-11 has been extensively tested and found to be reliable and useful including to patients. The proposed study will directly compare, for the first time, ICD-11 to DSM-5 in four clinical settings to determine which system is more reliable and useful to clinicians. Patients will also provide input about their experience receiving diagnoses under each system. The team is composed of experts working with the WHO to develop ICD-11, the Canadian Institute of Health Information (CIHI), a patient partner, and clinicians. The findings will be used by CIHI to make implementation decisions and recommendations about which system to use in clinical settings. Findings will also inform the WHO in making further revisions to the ICD-11 as well as provide Canadian clinicians with essential information on what classification serves their patients best.
Department
Program
Project Grant - Priority Announcement: Patient-Oriented Research
Recipient
Location
Ontario, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
CIHR Funding Decisions Database
As published
Id
456724
Name
Kogan Cary S
Region
Ontario
Country
Canada
Orgtype
Institution Paid; Research Institution
Instname2
Neurosciences, Mental Health and Addiction
Theme2
Clinical
Prcname2
Randomized Controlled Trials 2
Projecttitle
Which mental health classification serves Canada best? A mixed methods, multicenter comparison of the World Health Organization's ICD-11 Clinical Descriptions and Diagnostic Guidelines with the American Psychiatric Association's DSM-5.
Programtype2
Operating Grants
Orgnameinp2
University of Ottawa
Cihramount2
$100,000
Cihrequipment2
$0
Programname2
Project Grant - Priority Announcement: Patient-Oriented Research
Keyworddelim
Clinical Utility; Diagnostic And Statistical Manual, 5th Edition; Health Statistics; Identification Of Psychiatric Disorders; Patient-Oriented Research; Psychopathology Conceptualizations; Public Mental Health Of Canadians; Reliability And Acceptability Of Mental Health Diagnoses; Who International Classification Of Diseases, 11th Revision
Abstract
Mental health problems are the number one source of disability among Canadians, affecting their ability to lead productive and fulfilling lives. There continue to be major gaps between those needing care and those receiving it from health services. A key barrier to receiving accurate and timely care is the proper identification of mental health problems. Specialists rely on classifications to properly identify mental health problems. Although the Canadian government must use the World Health Organization (WHO)'s classification, the International Classification of Disease (ICD) to tally diseases including mental health problems for public health purposes, clinicians serving patients use the American Psychiatric Association's classification, the DSM-5, to make their diagnoses. Historically the DSM and ICD systems were comparable but the recently revised version of the ICD, ICD-11, differs significantly from DSM-5. Researchers have found serious problems with DSM-5 including the way it defines mental health problems, the ability of clinicians to use the system reliably, and its usefulness in making care decisions. In contrast, the ICD-11 has been extensively tested and found to be reliable and useful including to patients. The proposed study will directly compare, for the first time, ICD-11 to DSM-5 in four clinical settings to determine which system is more reliable and useful to clinicians. Patients will also provide input about their experience receiving diagnoses under each system. The team is composed of experts working with the WHO to develop ICD-11, the Canadian Institute of Health Information (CIHI), a patient partner, and clinicians. The findings will be used by CIHI to make implementation decisions and recommendations about which system to use in clinical settings. Findings will also inform the WHO in making further revisions to the ICD-11 as well as provide Canadian clinicians with essential information on what classification serves their patients best.
Competitiondate
202109
Approvedterm2
1 yr 0 mth
Pinamesdelim
Kogan, Cary S; Denny, Keith; Reed, Geoffrey
Approvedterm
1 an 0 mois
Cihrcontribution2
~ $100,000~ $0~