Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual
University of Alberta
$36,000.00
Evaluating the Influence of Scale on Paleoecological Results
FY 2021-22
Summary
Paleontologists and biologists have struggled with the question "why are there this many species in this place?" for over a century without achieving a consensus. In the face of a global environmental crisis, this question has become critical; we must understand the drivers of biodiversity, ecosystem stability, and extinction. Each study of fossil and biological biodiversity collects data at specific spatial, time, or numerical scales appropriate to each study, but meta-analysis of multiple studies, each with data collected at different scales have proved to be problematic at best and grossly inaccurate at worst. Scientists urgently need to address the issue of scale so that we can accurately understand biodiversity and its implications in addressing conservation. My research will investigate the effects of scale in sampling on analyses and results. Specifically, I am asking: 1) do results change from smaller to larger scales? For example, if an environmental parameter influences the number of species collected in a small sample, would an increase in sample size identify the same environmental factor, or would the analysis point to an entirely different parameter? 2) If results change with an increase in scale, is the change real, coming from an actual ecological/evolutionary driver working at different scales, or to a mathematical artifact that arose from analyzing samples of different scales? Research on present-day species are critical to understanding present-day biodiversity, but these projects are undertaken on ecosystems already impacted by humans. The discipline of conservation paleobiology, which looks at fossil systems to better understand and help restore or preserve modern biodiversity, has shown promise in recovering pre-human-impact, baseline conditions and information of how species respond to environmental crises. Therefore, my lab and I will investigate how scale influences the outcomes of biodiversity research using not only modern marine invertebrate species, but also the fossils of ancient marine shelled animals. The research consists of parallel studies from two time-regions known for exceptional fossil preservation. 1) My lab will compare present-day samples of mollusc shells of Florida to fossil mollusc shells from the past 5 million years (Plio-Pleistocene) in the same area. 2) To investigate if results are generalizable across larger temporal scales, my lab will also collect brachiopod shells from approximately 370 to 390 million years ago (Devonian) of western Canada. The impacts of this research will be substantial for studies in biodiversity and conservation paleobiology, but have broader implications. Any discipline or study that requires sampling, and those samples are affected by space, time, number, or any other quantifiable parameter, are subject to the same sorts of problems imposed by scale and will benefit from the results of my research.
Program
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Recipient
Location
Alberta, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data
As published
Application id
RGPIN-2021-02744
Name nom
Leighton, Lindsey
Department département
Earth and Atmospheric Sciences - Earth and Atmospheric Sciences
Organization id
9
Institution établissement
University of Alberta
Province en
Alberta
Province fr
Alberta
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2021
Competition year année de concours
2021
Award amount
36000
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
Discovery grants programs
Group fr
Programmes de subventions à la découverte
Committee code
1506
Committee name en
Geosciences
Committee name fr
Géosciences
Area of application code
1203
Area of application group en
Advancement of knowledge
Area of application group fr
Avancement des connaissances
Area of application en
Earth sciences
Area of application fr
Sciences de la terre
Research subject code
4010
Research subject group en
Earth science
Research subject group fr
Sciences de la terre
Research subject en
Paleontology, paleobiology
Research subject fr
Paléontologie, paléobiologie
Installment
inst:1
Partie
1
Nb partie
5
Application title
Evaluating the Influence of Scale on Paleoecological Results
Keyword
NSERC
Application summary
Paleontologists and biologists have struggled with the question "why are there this many species in this place?" for over a century without achieving a consensus. In the face of a global environmental crisis, this question has become critical; we must understand the drivers of biodiversity, ecosystem stability, and extinction. Each study of fossil and biological biodiversity collects data at specific spatial, time, or numerical scales appropriate to each study, but meta-analysis of multiple studies, each with data collected at different scales have proved to be problematic at best and grossly inaccurate at worst. Scientists urgently need to address the issue of scale so that we can accurately understand biodiversity and its implications in addressing conservation. My research will investigate the effects of scale in sampling on analyses and results. Specifically, I am asking: 1) do results change from smaller to larger scales? For example, if an environmental parameter influences the number of species collected in a small sample, would an increase in sample size identify the same environmental factor, or would the analysis point to an entirely different parameter? 2) If results change with an increase in scale, is the change real, coming from an actual ecological/evolutionary driver working at different scales, or to a mathematical artifact that arose from analyzing samples of different scales? Research on present-day species are critical to understanding present-day biodiversity, but these projects are undertaken on ecosystems already impacted by humans. The discipline of conservation paleobiology, which looks at fossil systems to better understand and help restore or preserve modern biodiversity, has shown promise in recovering pre-human-impact, baseline conditions and information of how species respond to environmental crises. Therefore, my lab and I will investigate how scale influences the outcomes of biodiversity research using not only modern marine invertebrate species, but also the fossils of ancient marine shelled animals. The research consists of parallel studies from two time-regions known for exceptional fossil preservation. 1) My lab will compare present-day samples of mollusc shells of Florida to fossil mollusc shells from the past 5 million years (Plio-Pleistocene) in the same area. 2) To investigate if results are generalizable across larger temporal scales, my lab will also collect brachiopod shells from approximately 370 to 390 million years ago (Devonian) of western Canada. The impacts of this research will be substantial for studies in biodiversity and conservation paleobiology, but have broader implications. Any discipline or study that requires sampling, and those samples are affected by space, time, number, or any other quantifiable parameter, are subject to the same sorts of problems imposed by scale and will benefit from the results of my research.