Canada Spends Logo

Explore our Budget 2026 analysis

Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual

York University

$29,000.00

The Reasoning Brain

FY 2019-20

Summary
Real-world reasoning is modulated by content, beliefs and emotions. That is, we do not typically reason about X and Y, but about whether climate change is real, or if Mary really prefers to go to the movies with George rather than Paul. The question of how content, beliefs, and emotions affect the reasoning process have been of general intellectual interest for thousands of years. They are still the main issues driving research into logical reasoning in the fields of cognitive psychology, and have led to the popularity of dual mechanism theories (DMT) of reasoning. DMT of reasoning propose two separate systems, one for processing arguments with familiar content that we have beliefs about, and another, formal system, for processing arguments that we have no beliefs about.******We have contributed to this literature by articulating the impact of content, beliefs, and emotions on reasoning at the neural level. A number of outstanding questions remain. The proposed program of research seeks to answer 5 such critical questions:******1. While we know that content and noncontent arguments engage different neural systems, there is also a neural system common to both argument types. Is this common system playing the same or different role in the case of content and noncontent reasoning?******2. The presence of content invariably leads to belief bias effects. Several behavioural studies have recently questioned one aspect of this effect (the detection of conflict and switching of systems) while others suggest that it is a function of cognitive capacity and may be restricted to indeterminate reasoning trials. We ask the question whether indeterminate and inconsistent trials interact differently with belief bias at the neural level, and if the interaction is modulated by cognitive capacity?******3. A further issue with respect to belief bias is raised by Rotello et al.'s claim that the belief bias effect is a misconstrued response bias. We ask the question of what is the relationship between belief bias and response bias at the neural level. ******4. When content acquires valence and arousal, emotions impact the reasoning process. We ask the question whether the orbital/polar prefrontal cortex serve to filter emotional content from arguments before they are passed on to the reasoning system?******5. Finally, we ask the question of what exactly is being filtered by the orbital/polar prefrontal cortex (believability, valence, arousal, or some combination of these).******We propose to carry out neuroimaging and behavioural studies employing univariate, multivariate, and functional connectivity analyses techniques to examine similarities and differences in the underlying neural systems and representations utilized by the brain under various reasoning conditions. The results will augment existing behavioural data and play an important role in resolving key outstanding questions surrounding DMT and be of great interest to cognitive scientists.
Program
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Location
Ontario, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data

As published

Application id
RGPIN-2018-05855
Name nom
Goel, Vinod
Department département
Psychology
Organization id
38
Institution établissement
York University
Province en
Ontario
Province fr
Ontario
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2019
Competition year année de concours
2018
Award amount
29000
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
DISCOVERY RESEARCH
Group fr
RECHERCHE AXÉE SUR LA DÉCOUVERTE
Committee code
1502
Committee name en
Biological Systems and Functions
Committee name fr
Systèmes et fonctions biologiques
Area of application code
1200
Area of application group en
Advancement of knowledge
Area of application group fr
Avancement des connaissances
Area of application en
Advancement of knowledge
Area of application fr
Avancement des connaissances
Research subject code
6307
Research subject group en
Psychology
Research subject group fr
Psychologie
Research subject en
Cognitive science -- other
Research subject fr
Science cognitive -- autres
Installment
inst:2 - 5
Partie
2
Nb partie
5
Application title
The Reasoning Brain
Keyword
NSERC
Application summary
Real-world reasoning is modulated by content, beliefs and emotions. That is, we do not typically reason about X and Y, but about whether climate change is real, or if Mary really prefers to go to the movies with George rather than Paul. The question of how content, beliefs, and emotions affect the reasoning process have been of general intellectual interest for thousands of years. They are still the main issues driving research into logical reasoning in the fields of cognitive psychology, and have led to the popularity of dual mechanism theories (DMT) of reasoning. DMT of reasoning propose two separate systems, one for processing arguments with familiar content that we have beliefs about, and another, formal system, for processing arguments that we have no beliefs about.******We have contributed to this literature by articulating the impact of content, beliefs, and emotions on reasoning at the neural level. A number of outstanding questions remain. The proposed program of research seeks to answer 5 such critical questions:******1. While we know that content and noncontent arguments engage different neural systems, there is also a neural system common to both argument types. Is this common system playing the same or different role in the case of content and noncontent reasoning?******2. The presence of content invariably leads to belief bias effects. Several behavioural studies have recently questioned one aspect of this effect (the detection of conflict and switching of systems) while others suggest that it is a function of cognitive capacity and may be restricted to indeterminate reasoning trials. We ask the question whether indeterminate and inconsistent trials interact differently with belief bias at the neural level, and if the interaction is modulated by cognitive capacity?******3. A further issue with respect to belief bias is raised by Rotello et al.'s claim that the belief bias effect is a misconstrued response bias. We ask the question of what is the relationship between belief bias and response bias at the neural level. ******4. When content acquires valence and arousal, emotions impact the reasoning process. We ask the question whether the orbital/polar prefrontal cortex serve to filter emotional content from arguments before they are passed on to the reasoning system?******5. Finally, we ask the question of what exactly is being filtered by the orbital/polar prefrontal cortex (believability, valence, arousal, or some combination of these).******We propose to carry out neuroimaging and behavioural studies employing univariate, multivariate, and functional connectivity analyses techniques to examine similarities and differences in the underlying neural systems and representations utilized by the brain under various reasoning conditions. The results will augment existing behavioural data and play an important role in resolving key outstanding questions surrounding DMT and be of great interest to cognitive scientists.
York University - $29,000 Grant (2019-20) | Canada Spends