Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual
McGill University
$26,410.00
Designing Price Ladders in Competitive Environments: Theory and Field Experiments
FY 2022-23
Summary
Airlines, e-retailers, and hotels change their fares dynamically. How are these fares determined? Typically, companies begin by creating a fare ladder-i.e., a ladder with multiple price points. Once this ladder is designed, the selling season begins and, as time goes by, the fare progressively changes as a function of sales and inventory. Now consider price ladders in a competitive environment, where different companies offer products of varying "quality" or desirability. Think, for example, of two airlines offering a flight between Montreal and Ottawa-with one offering a direct flight and the other a flight with multiple layovers. In such an environment, how should competitors incorporate quality differences when designing the price ladder? In practice, firms do not typically differentiate their price ladders. For example, airlines and hotels use a "ladder matching strategy," whereby competitors design the same price ladder for a given market. We can verify, via the Airline Tariff Publishing Company database, that ladder matching occurs in 96.5% of the airline markets. In fact, ladder matching happens even when there are outlandish differences in quality-e.g., a direct vs a connecting itinerary, or a short vs a long layover. Why would competitors design the same price ladder when one product is more attractive than the other? Their idea behind this strategy is that the market forces dynamically drive price differentiation. Thus, if a company offers a better product, consumers will buy it aggressively and the fare will quickly escalate up the ladder (while a low-quality product will stay locked to the bottom). Thus, companies do not proactively infuse quality difference into the ladder but, instead, let differentiation be "demand-driven." This strategy may have been efficient in the past, when consumers lacked systems to compare products-e.g., fare aggregators like Expedia-and when quality differentiation was minor. But, as firms themselves admit, times have changed, and it is time to revise how price ladders are designed. In this 5-year research program, my goal is to study price price ladder differentiation in competitive environments. To achieve this goal, my program will be broken into three modules, each with its own short-term objective: In Module I, I seek to find optimal ladder differentiation strategies (and the competitive implications of these strategies) via game-theoretical models. In Module II, I seek to understand, via optimization models, how dynamic pricing should be optimized when competitors use quality-differentiated ladders (as opposed to matched ladders). And, in Module III, my objective is validate the theoretical findings in the real world, via a large-scale field experiment, by leveraging an ongoing research partnership with an airline. This program will help managers increase market efficiency, develop equitable and efficient pricing, and, thus, positively impact on firms and consumers.
Program
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Recipient
Location
Quebec, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data
As published
Application id
RGPIN-2022-04033
Name nom
Serpa, Juan
Department département
Management, Desautels Faculty of - Management, Desautels Faculty of
Organization id
61
Institution établissement
McGill University
Province en
Québec
Province fr
Québec
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2022
Competition year année de concours
2022
Award amount
26410
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
DISCOVERY RESEARCH
Group fr
RECHERCHE AXÉE SUR LA DÉCOUVERTE
Committee code
1509
Committee name en
Civil, Industrial and Systems Engineering
Committee name fr
Génie civil, industriel et des systèmes
Area of application code
520
Area of application group en
Manufacturing processes and products
Area of application group fr
Procédés et produits industriels
Area of application en
Production and operations management
Area of application fr
Production et gestion des opérations
Research subject code
1600
Research subject group en
Industrial engineering
Research subject group fr
Génie industriel
Research subject en
Industrial engineering
Research subject fr
Génie industriel
Installment
inst:1
Partie
1
Nb partie
5
Application title
Designing Price Ladders in Competitive Environments: Theory and Field Experiments
Application summary
Airlines, e-retailers, and hotels change their fares dynamically. How are these fares determined? Typically, companies begin by creating a fare ladder-i.e., a ladder with multiple price points. Once this ladder is designed, the selling season begins and, as time goes by, the fare progressively changes as a function of sales and inventory. Now consider price ladders in a competitive environment, where different companies offer products of varying "quality" or desirability. Think, for example, of two airlines offering a flight between Montreal and Ottawa-with one offering a direct flight and the other a flight with multiple layovers. In such an environment, how should competitors incorporate quality differences when designing the price ladder? In practice, firms do not typically differentiate their price ladders. For example, airlines and hotels use a "ladder matching strategy," whereby competitors design the same price ladder for a given market. We can verify, via the Airline Tariff Publishing Company database, that ladder matching occurs in 96.5% of the airline markets. In fact, ladder matching happens even when there are outlandish differences in quality-e.g., a direct vs a connecting itinerary, or a short vs a long layover. Why would competitors design the same price ladder when one product is more attractive than the other? Their idea behind this strategy is that the market forces dynamically drive price differentiation. Thus, if a company offers a better product, consumers will buy it aggressively and the fare will quickly escalate up the ladder (while a low-quality product will stay locked to the bottom). Thus, companies do not proactively infuse quality difference into the ladder but, instead, let differentiation be "demand-driven." This strategy may have been efficient in the past, when consumers lacked systems to compare products-e.g., fare aggregators like Expedia-and when quality differentiation was minor. But, as firms themselves admit, times have changed, and it is time to revise how price ladders are designed. In this 5-year research program, my goal is to study price price ladder differentiation in competitive environments. To achieve this goal, my program will be broken into three modules, each with its own short-term objective: In Module I, I seek to find optimal ladder differentiation strategies (and the competitive implications of these strategies) via game-theoretical models. In Module II, I seek to understand, via optimization models, how dynamic pricing should be optimized when competitors use quality-differentiated ladders (as opposed to matched ladders). And, in Module III, my objective is validate the theoretical findings in the real world, via a large-scale field experiment, by leveraging an ongoing research partnership with an airline. This program will help managers increase market efficiency, develop equitable and efficient pricing, and, thus, positively impact on firms and consumers.