Grant: Operating Grant
McGill University
$331,195.00
The impact of health insurance vs. unconditional cash transfer on socio-economic and neurobiological welfare measures of the poor: evidence from randomized experiments in the slums of Nairobi, undertaken by an international collaboration between a "Jua kali" community, Kenyan health insurance providers, economists, neuroscientists, and Kenyan policy decision makers
FY 2011-12
Summary
The lack of health insurance and the persistence of poverty are intricately related. According to the 2001 World Development Report, "reducing vulnerability to economic shocks, ill health, disability, and personal violence, is an intrinsic part of enhancing well-being of the poor and encourages investment in human capital and in higher-risk, higher-return activities". In this way, health insurance may mitigate the risks faced by poor individuals.
Health insurance schemes generally improve health care access, but not always for the very poor, if, for example, transport costs to the hospital are in fact the largest expenses. An unconditional cash transfer of the same amount may actually be more beneficial as the poor are better placed to know their needs and if they do not squander their money on unnecessary non-durables.
The relative merit of health insurance over UCT is thus an open empirical question, and has never been studied before. This project will address this gap in the literature by providing the first randomized experiment on the relative merits of health insurance vs UCT, by comparing a group of poor households offered free health insurance to a control group offered the cash equivalent. The survey will include questions regarding the economic situation of the member and his/her family. Moreover, to assess health and psychological well-being, saliva and blood samples will be collected to measure biomarkers of stress, in particular cortisol and cytokine levels. An important question concerns the willingness to pay for insurance. The partnership will thus implement six different interventions aimed at increasing take-up of health insurance.
These randomized experiments will thus directly inform insurance providers and policy makers about the scale-up of health insurance vs UCT provision, not only in Kenya but also elsewhere in the world, and have the potential to benefit the lives of millions of people currently out of reach of these products.
Department
Program
Operating Grant
Recipient
Location
Quebec, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
CIHR Funding Decisions Database
As published
Id
254550
Name
Chemin Matthieu
Region
Québec
Country
Canada
Orgtype
Institution Paid; Research Institution
Instname2
Population and Public Health
Theme2
Social / Cultural / Environmental / Population Health
Prcname2
Health Policy & Systems Management Research
Projecttitle
The impact of health insurance vs. unconditional cash transfer on socio-economic and neurobiological welfare measures of the poor: evidence from randomized experiments in the slums of Nairobi, undertaken by an international collaboration between a "Jua kali" community, Kenyan health insurance providers, economists, neuroscientists, and Kenyan policy decision makers
Programtype2
Operating Grants
Orgnameinp2
McGill University
Cihramount2
$331,195
Cihrequipment2
$0
Programname2
Operating Grant
Keyworddelim
Depression; Health Insurance; Neurobiological Well-Being Measures; Poverty Reduction; Stress; Unconditional Cash Transfer
Abstract
The lack of health insurance and the persistence of poverty are intricately related. According to the 2001 World Development Report, "reducing vulnerability to economic shocks, ill health, disability, and personal violence, is an intrinsic part of enhancing well-being of the poor and encourages investment in human capital and in higher-risk, higher-return activities". In this way, health insurance may mitigate the risks faced by poor individuals.
Health insurance schemes generally improve health care access, but not always for the very poor, if, for example, transport costs to the hospital are in fact the largest expenses. An unconditional cash transfer of the same amount may actually be more beneficial as the poor are better placed to know their needs and if they do not squander their money on unnecessary non-durables.
The relative merit of health insurance over UCT is thus an open empirical question, and has never been studied before. This project will address this gap in the literature by providing the first randomized experiment on the relative merits of health insurance vs UCT, by comparing a group of poor households offered free health insurance to a control group offered the cash equivalent. The survey will include questions regarding the economic situation of the member and his/her family. Moreover, to assess health and psychological well-being, saliva and blood samples will be collected to measure biomarkers of stress, in particular cortisol and cytokine levels. An important question concerns the willingness to pay for insurance. The partnership will thus implement six different interventions aimed at increasing take-up of health insurance.
These randomized experiments will thus directly inform insurance providers and policy makers about the scale-up of health insurance vs UCT provision, not only in Kenya but also elsewhere in the world, and have the potential to benefit the lives of millions of people currently out of reach of these products.
Competitiondate
201203
Approvedterm2
2 yrs 0 mth
Pinamesdelim
Chemin, Matthieu
Approvedterm
2 ans 0 mois
Cihrcontribution2
~ $331,195~ $0~