Canada Spends Logo

Explore our Budget 2026 analysis

Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual

Université du Québec à Montréal

$24,000.00

Fundamental and Statistical Symplectic Topology

FY 2023-24

Summary
From 2004 to 2010, my student Martin Pinsonnault and myself (Silvia Anjos joined us later) discovered what could be considered as the first phase transition in symplectic topology: indeed, we found in some ruled 4-dimensional symplectic manifolds $(M, \omega)$ a critical value $c_{crit}$ for the capacity of balls such that below that value, the infinite dimensional space of symplectic embeddings of the standard 4-ball of given capacity $c < c_{crit}$ inside $(M, \omega)$ retracts on the finite dimensional manifold of symplectic frames on $M$, while beyond that critical value, that space does not retract on any finite dimensional CW complex (it has homology in dimensions as high as we wish). What is spectacular is that the change in homotopy only occurs starting at the $\pi_3$ level, so that this critical value could not have been detected by physicists. This raises three questions: the first one is to understand this phenomenon physically as the expression of uncertainty, which is naturally quantized in our theory. We are looking for a general framework to interpret this phenomenon rigorously as a phase transition. The second question is to try to generalise this to other toric manifolds by using very different techniques. The third and most interesting question is to relate these critical values, which express uncertainty, to other values that express the level of Poisson anti-commutativity of the manifolds. This goes in the following way, according to Leonid Polterovich and al., given a symplectic manifold $(M, \omega)$, consider a covering by a finite number of open sets, and a partition of unity $f_1,..., f_k$, and take the sup over $a_1,...,a_k, b_1,...,b_k$ of the norm of the Poisson bracket of $\sum_i a_if_i$ with $\sum_i b_i f_i$ with the only constraint that $a_i, b_i \in [-1,1]$. Then take the inf over all partitions of unity. This gives a number attached to the open cover. The main result is that this number is bounded below by a constant that depends only on the number of open sets. Polterovich conjectured that there should be a positive constant that does not even depend on the number of open subsets. Our goal here is to extend this theory to coverings given by a continuum of open sets, like the one given by a representative of a homotopy class in the $\pi_3$ of the space of symplectic embeddings of balls of given capacity. We have indeed developed a theory of partitions of unity for coverings made of continuous families of open subsets endowed with corresponding functions where sums are replaced by integrals. We can indeed acheive this if Polterovich conjecture is true. There remains to compare critical values in non-commutativity and uncertainty. This project includes also three other substantial problems related to the cluster complex in the Atiyah-Floer conjecture, the Viterbo conjecture and the problem of determining how hard are the foundations of Symplectic Topology.
Program
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Location
Quebec, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data

As published

Application id
RGPIN-2017-06566
Name nom
Lalonde, François
Department département
Département de mathématiques et statistique
Organization id
57
Institution établissement
Université du Québec à Montréal
Province en
Québec
Province fr
Québec
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2023
Competition year année de concours
2017
Award amount
24000
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
DISCOVERY RESEARCH
Group fr
RECHERCHE AXÉE SUR LA DÉCOUVERTE
Committee code
1508
Committee name en
Mathematics and Statistics
Committee name fr
Mathématiques et statistique
Area of application code
1205
Area of application group en
Advancement of knowledge
Area of application group fr
Avancement des connaissances
Area of application en
Mathematical sciences
Area of application fr
Sciences mathématiques
Research subject code
3152
Research subject group en
Theoretical physics and chemistry
Research subject group fr
Theory of elementary particles and fields
Research subject en
Physique et chimie théoriques
Research subject fr
Théorie des particules élémentaires et théorie des champs
Application title
Fundamental and Statistical Symplectic Topology
Keyword
Capacities as functions; Floer theory; Intrinsic Non-Squeezing Theorem; J-holomorphic methods; Lack of commutativity on symplectic manifolds; Partitions of unity in the continuum setting; Phase transitions; Poisson bracket; Theory of symplectic maps; The topological space of symplectic balls
Application summary
From 2004 to 2010, my student Martin Pinsonnault and myself (Silvia Anjos joined us later) discovered what could be considered as the first phase transition in symplectic topology: indeed, we found in some ruled 4-dimensional symplectic manifolds $(M, \omega)$ a critical value $c_{crit}$ for the capacity of balls such that below that value, the infinite dimensional space of symplectic embeddings of the standard 4-ball of given capacity $c < c_{crit}$ inside $(M, \omega)$ retracts on the finite dimensional manifold of symplectic frames on $M$, while beyond that critical value, that space does not retract on any finite dimensional CW complex (it has homology in dimensions as high as we wish). What is spectacular is that the change in homotopy only occurs starting at the $\pi_3$ level, so that this critical value could not have been detected by physicists. This raises three questions: the first one is to understand this phenomenon physically as the expression of uncertainty, which is naturally quantized in our theory. We are looking for a general framework to interpret this phenomenon rigorously as a phase transition. The second question is to try to generalise this to other toric manifolds by using very different techniques. The third and most interesting question is to relate these critical values, which express uncertainty, to other values that express the level of Poisson anti-commutativity of the manifolds. This goes in the following way, according to Leonid Polterovich and al., given a symplectic manifold $(M, \omega)$, consider a covering by a finite number of open sets, and a partition of unity $f_1,..., f_k$, and take the sup over $a_1,...,a_k, b_1,...,b_k$ of the norm of the Poisson bracket of $\sum_i a_if_i$ with $\sum_i b_i f_i$ with the only constraint that $a_i, b_i \in [-1,1]$. Then take the inf over all partitions of unity. This gives a number attached to the open cover. The main result is that this number is bounded below by a constant that depends only on the number of open sets. Polterovich conjectured that there should be a positive constant that does not even depend on the number of open subsets. Our goal here is to extend this theory to coverings given by a continuum of open sets, like the one given by a representative of a homotopy class in the $\pi_3$ of the space of symplectic embeddings of balls of given capacity. We have indeed developed a theory of partitions of unity for coverings made of continuous families of open subsets endowed with corresponding functions where sums are replaced by integrals. We can indeed acheive this if Polterovich conjecture is true. There remains to compare critical values in non-commutativity and uncertainty. This project includes also three other substantial problems related to the cluster complex in the Atiyah-Floer conjecture, the Viterbo conjecture and the problem of determining how hard are the foundations of Symplectic Topology.