Canada Spends Logo

Explore our Budget 2026 analysis

Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual

McGill University

$72,000.00

Towards a unified theory for element uptake by minerals over the full range of element concentrations

FY 2024-25

Summary
Element mobility in the Earth drives global geochemical cycles and concentrates elements into ore deposits. This mobility can rarely be measured directly, especially not for the deep Earth or the earliest history of our planet. Instead, it has to be reconstructed from the rock record, in particular from the chemistry of minerals that formed in the process of interest. Despite huge progress in developing tools to read the mineral record, there is still major ambiguity in derived data because of a lack of understanding in how minerals get their composition. Indeed, no model correctly predicts the uptake of elements by minerals from the tens to thousands of mg/kg. At trace levels, Lattice-Strain Theory (LST) provides a framework to predict the uptake of elements from melts and fluids, showing it to be controlled by an element's mismatch in the crystal lattice in terms of size and charge. However, LST is only valid at "infinite dilution" and strong deviations are observed at higher concentrations. As a result, LST does not provide meaningful concentration data in modeling ore forming systems to their extreme enrichment. Thermodynamic solid solution models allow for modeling of element incorporation at high concentrations from the Gibbs free energy of element substitutions (e.g. Ca+Al = Na+Si in plagioclase). However, uncertainties in thermodynamic data do not permit extrapolations to low concentrations. There is therefore an urgent need for a model to predict element uptake at all concentrations. This research program aims to develop a unified theory to explain and predict element uptake over the full range of concentrations by gaining fundamental insights into how elements are accommodated in minerals. Experiments will be conducted to characterise the response of mineral lattices to mismatching element incorporation. This will be combined with direct measurements of crystal lattice dimensions and elasticity, and with predictive modelling of the local lattice around mismatching elements at the atom-scale by atomistic simulations. The elemental and isotopic composition of minerals contains a treasure trove of information on pressure, temperature, age, and element mobility in the minerals' growth environment. The fundamental insights developed in this research program will permit us to extract this information without the ambiguity that currently cripples this approach. This allows us to address key material and geoscience questions, from subduction zone element cycling, to the compositions of the Early Earth crust and oceans, to ore formation. Moreover, it has direct applications in industry where the desired behaviour of a material, for example as a catalyst, is directly linked to the abundance of functional elements. This research thereby addresses direct concerns to the Canadian general public, including developing novel materials for green technologies, remediating waste, addressing dwindling natural resources, and the impact of climate change.
Program
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Location
Quebec, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data

As published

Application id
RGPIN-2020-04173
Name nom
van Hinsberg, Vincent
Department département
Earth and Planetary Sciences
Organization id
61
Institution établissement
McGill University
Province en
Québec
Province fr
Québec
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2024
Competition year année de concours
2020
Award amount
72000
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
DISCOVERY RESEARCH
Group fr
RECHERCHE AXÉE SUR LA DÉCOUVERTE
Committee code
1506
Committee name en
Geosciences
Committee name fr
Géosciences
Area of application code
1208
Area of application group en
Advancement of knowledge
Area of application group fr
Avancement des connaissances
Area of application en
Materials sciences
Area of application fr
Sciences des matériaux
Research subject code
4202
Research subject group en
Geochemistry and geochronology
Research subject group fr
Géochimie et géochronologie
Research subject en
Trace element geochemistry
Research subject fr
Géochimie des oligo-éléments
Field of research list names en
Not available
Field of research list names fr
Non disponible
Socioeconomic objective list names en
Not available
Socioeconomic objective list names fr
Non disponible
Application title
Towards a unified theory for element uptake by minerals over the full range of element concentrations
Keywords
element partitioning; crystal structure; lattice strain theory; trace elements; atomistic modeling
Application summary
Element mobility in the Earth drives global geochemical cycles and concentrates elements into ore deposits. This mobility can rarely be measured directly, especially not for the deep Earth or the earliest history of our planet. Instead, it has to be reconstructed from the rock record, in particular from the chemistry of minerals that formed in the process of interest. Despite huge progress in developing tools to read the mineral record, there is still major ambiguity in derived data because of a lack of understanding in how minerals get their composition. Indeed, no model correctly predicts the uptake of elements by minerals from the tens to thousands of mg/kg. At trace levels, Lattice-Strain Theory (LST) provides a framework to predict the uptake of elements from melts and fluids, showing it to be controlled by an element's mismatch in the crystal lattice in terms of size and charge. However, LST is only valid at "infinite dilution" and strong deviations are observed at higher concentrations. As a result, LST does not provide meaningful concentration data in modeling ore forming systems to their extreme enrichment. Thermodynamic solid solution models allow for modeling of element incorporation at high concentrations from the Gibbs free energy of element substitutions (e.g. Ca+Al = Na+Si in plagioclase). However, uncertainties in thermodynamic data do not permit extrapolations to low concentrations. There is therefore an urgent need for a model to predict element uptake at all concentrations. This research program aims to develop a unified theory to explain and predict element uptake over the full range of concentrations by gaining fundamental insights into how elements are accommodated in minerals. Experiments will be conducted to characterise the response of mineral lattices to mismatching element incorporation. This will be combined with direct measurements of crystal lattice dimensions and elasticity, and with predictive modelling of the local lattice around mismatching elements at the atom-scale by atomistic simulations. The elemental and isotopic composition of minerals contains a treasure trove of information on pressure, temperature, age, and element mobility in the minerals' growth environment. The fundamental insights developed in this research program will permit us to extract this information without the ambiguity that currently cripples this approach. This allows us to address key material and geoscience questions, from subduction zone element cycling, to the compositions of the Early Earth crust and oceans, to ore formation. Moreover, it has direct applications in industry where the desired behaviour of a material, for example as a catalyst, is directly linked to the abundance of functional elements. This research thereby addresses direct concerns to the Canadian general public, including developing novel materials for green technologies, remediating waste, addressing dwindling natural resources, and the impact of climate change.