Grant: Discovery Horizons
École Polytechnique de Montréal
$75,000.00
Improving allocation and supporting clinical decision-making for deceased donor kidney offers
FY 2023-24
Summary
End-stage kidney disease is a severe health condition with a rising incidence, currently affecting over 40,000 Canadians. Renal transplantation is considered the best renal replacement therapy, improving longevity, quality of life and cost when compared to dialysis. Organ donation organizations allocate deceased donor kidneys using scores that combine elements of justice (wait time on dialysis) and utility (maximizing graft survival). Once a kidney offer is made to the patient, the decision to accept or refuse it is taken by the transplant candidate and physician dyad.
There is a mismatch between the availability and the need for deceased donor kidneys, with over 3000 patients waiting for a kidney transplant in Canada. One way to increase the number of transplantations is to optimize the donor pool by using kidneys from deceased high-risk donors who have risk features that lead to suboptimal graft survival. Optimizing the use of high-risk donor kidneys necessitates attentive transmission of information on the pros and cons of accepting or refusing these offers. However, there is currently no clinical decision support tool available to help transplant physicians and candidates balance the risks and benefits of accepting or refusing such suboptimal offers. The decision is hence based only on clinical judgment.
The current proposal aims to provide to the patient and the physician quantitative information surrounding the decision to accept or refuse offers from high-risk donors. This will consist in i) estimating the patient and graft survival probability of the current offer if it is accepted; ii) estimating expected wait time before a better offer if the current offer is refused and iii) estimating whether patient and graft survival is more likely from 1 to 15 years post transplant if the current offer is accepted or refused. Stochastic models and survival models will be developed specifically for this context of accepting or refusing a kidney offer under uncertainty.
A complementary objective of the current proposal concerns the current allocation score used by Transplant Quebec. The models that will be developed for the main objective could also be used to verify if the current score successfully meets its goal in terms of justice and utility. It would also be possible to evaluate the impact of a score modification on justice and utility and moreover, to propose an optimal allocation score function.
Program
Discovery Horizons
Recipient
Location
Quebec, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data
As published
Application id
DH-2023-00205
Name nom
Jalbert, Jonathan
Department département
Département de mathématiques et génie industriel - École Polytechnique de Montréal
Organization id
64
Institution établissement
École Polytechnique de Montréal
Province en
Québec
Province fr
Québec
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2023
Competition year année de concours
2023
Award amount
75000
Program id
DH
Program name en
Discovery Horizons
Program name fr
Horizons de la découverte
Group en
DISCOVERY RESEARCH
Group fr
RECHERCHE AXÉE SUR LA DÉCOUVERTE
Committee code
1629
Committee name en
Discovery Horizons Committee
Committee name fr
Comité Horizons de la découverte
Area of application code
9999
Area of application group en
Not available
Area of application group fr
Non disponible
Area of application en
Not available
Area of application fr
Non disponible
Research subject code
10000
Research subject group en
The field of research available
Research subject group fr
The field of research available
Research subject en
Le domaine de recherche disponible
Research subject fr
Le domaine de recherche disponible
Field of research list codes
RDF1010305
Field of research list names en
Statistical learning
Field of research list names fr
Apprentissage statistique
Application title
Improving allocation and supporting clinical decision-making for deceased donor kidney offers
Keyword
kidney transplant; statistical learning; decision theory; machine learning; nephrology; stochastic processes
Application summary
End-stage kidney disease is a severe health condition with a rising incidence, currently affecting over 40,000 Canadians. Renal transplantation is considered the best renal replacement therapy, improving longevity, quality of life and cost when compared to dialysis. Organ donation organizations allocate deceased donor kidneys using scores that combine elements of justice (wait time on dialysis) and utility (maximizing graft survival). Once a kidney offer is made to the patient, the decision to accept or refuse it is taken by the transplant candidate and physician dyad.
There is a mismatch between the availability and the need for deceased donor kidneys, with over 3000 patients waiting for a kidney transplant in Canada. One way to increase the number of transplantations is to optimize the donor pool by using kidneys from deceased high-risk donors who have risk features that lead to suboptimal graft survival. Optimizing the use of high-risk donor kidneys necessitates attentive transmission of information on the pros and cons of accepting or refusing these offers. However, there is currently no clinical decision support tool available to help transplant physicians and candidates balance the risks and benefits of accepting or refusing such suboptimal offers. The decision is hence based only on clinical judgment.
The current proposal aims to provide to the patient and the physician quantitative information surrounding the decision to accept or refuse offers from high-risk donors. This will consist in i) estimating the patient and graft survival probability of the current offer if it is accepted; ii) estimating expected wait time before a better offer if the current offer is refused and iii) estimating whether patient and graft survival is more likely from 1 to 15 years post transplant if the current offer is accepted or refused. Stochastic models and survival models will be developed specifically for this context of accepting or refusing a kidney offer under uncertainty.
A complementary objective of the current proposal concerns the current allocation score used by Transplant Quebec. The models that will be developed for the main objective could also be used to verify if the current score successfully meets its goal in terms of justice and utility. It would also be possible to evaluate the impact of a score modification on justice and utility and moreover, to propose an optimal allocation score function.