Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual
École Polytechnique de Montréal
$37,000.00
Prospective Human Error Analysis in Aviation for Complex Failure Scenarios
FY 2023-24
Summary
Human performance is at the forefront of safety improvements. Complex-system industries have seen an increase in the proportion of injuries due to human error. This is best exemplified by the aerospace industry, where human factors component was the primary causal factor of 66% of fatal accidents, as opposed to 7% for aircraft-related factor. Human error is exacerbated during complex failure scenarios, characterized by multiple alarm messages, startling reaction and compounding sequence of errors. Human factors engineering (HFE) has a clear role to identify proactively which aspects of the work environment are error-prone based on human capacities, and to propose design improvements to fix the issues before an error happens. This is the realm of prospective error analysis. However, existing methods assume a deterministic human behaviour, whereas there is a diversity of problem-solving abilities under stress. They also lack guidance and usability to be used for complex failure scenarios, as the situation evolves into multiple outcomes; yet this is where they would be the most beneficial to improve safety. The long-term vision of this program is to investigate new system-thinking approaches for error analysis of the joint interaction between users and automated systems. Specific objectives are two-fold: 1) develop tools to anticipate the diversity of human behaviour during complex failure scenarios; 2) develop systematic prospective error analysis tools for complex failure scenarios. To this end, we will first characterize the range of human behaviours during complex failure scenarios that will be used as part of the error analysis. This is done via field observations with expert users resolving complex failure and review of past accident reports. Results will be prototypical persona summarizing the cognitive profiles and problem-solving strategies, and series of disruptive events, to include in prospective error analysis. Second, we will develop a scenario-based prospective error analysis to be used for complex failure scenarios. We will improve the guidance and usability of the method to ensure its adoption by the HFE community. Finally, we will conduct comparative studies to measure the performance of our new method with existing error analysis tools. This research program will advance knowledge on error analysis in complex failure scenarios representative of accidents and offer tools and guidance to HFE to improve safety. Our work will also inform regulation authorities on ways to enforce robust prospective error analysis methods to offer an even-playing field between manufacturers, thus benefiting to the Canadian community.
Program
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Recipient
Location
Quebec, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data
As published
Application id
RGPIN-2023-03792
Name nom
Doyon-Poulin, Philippe
Department département
Mathématiques et génie industriel
Organization id
64
Institution établissement
École Polytechnique de Montréal
Province en
Québec
Province fr
Québec
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2023
Competition year année de concours
2023
Award amount
37000
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
DISCOVERY RESEARCH
Group fr
RECHERCHE AXÉE SUR LA DÉCOUVERTE
Committee code
1509
Committee name en
Civil, Industrial and Systems Engineering
Committee name fr
Génie civil, industriel et des systèmes
Area of application code
703
Area of application group en
Transportation systems and services
Area of application group fr
Services et systèmes de transport
Area of application en
Aerospace
Area of application fr
Aérospatial
Research subject code
9999
Research subject group en
Not available
Research subject group fr
Not available
Research subject en
Non disponible
Research subject fr
Non disponible
Application title
Prospective Human Error Analysis in Aviation for Complex Failure Scenarios
Keyword
Aviation human factors; Cognitive engineering; Flight deck design; Human error; Human factors engineering
Application summary
Human performance is at the forefront of safety improvements. Complex-system industries have seen an increase in the proportion of injuries due to human error. This is best exemplified by the aerospace industry, where human factors component was the primary causal factor of 66% of fatal accidents, as opposed to 7% for aircraft-related factor. Human error is exacerbated during complex failure scenarios, characterized by multiple alarm messages, startling reaction and compounding sequence of errors. Human factors engineering (HFE) has a clear role to identify proactively which aspects of the work environment are error-prone based on human capacities, and to propose design improvements to fix the issues before an error happens. This is the realm of prospective error analysis. However, existing methods assume a deterministic human behaviour, whereas there is a diversity of problem-solving abilities under stress. They also lack guidance and usability to be used for complex failure scenarios, as the situation evolves into multiple outcomes; yet this is where they would be the most beneficial to improve safety. The long-term vision of this program is to investigate new system-thinking approaches for error analysis of the joint interaction between users and automated systems. Specific objectives are two-fold: 1) develop tools to anticipate the diversity of human behaviour during complex failure scenarios; 2) develop systematic prospective error analysis tools for complex failure scenarios. To this end, we will first characterize the range of human behaviours during complex failure scenarios that will be used as part of the error analysis. This is done via field observations with expert users resolving complex failure and review of past accident reports. Results will be prototypical persona summarizing the cognitive profiles and problem-solving strategies, and series of disruptive events, to include in prospective error analysis. Second, we will develop a scenario-based prospective error analysis to be used for complex failure scenarios. We will improve the guidance and usability of the method to ensure its adoption by the HFE community. Finally, we will conduct comparative studies to measure the performance of our new method with existing error analysis tools. This research program will advance knowledge on error analysis in complex failure scenarios representative of accidents and offer tools and guidance to HFE to improve safety. Our work will also inform regulation authorities on ways to enforce robust prospective error analysis methods to offer an even-playing field between manufacturers, thus benefiting to the Canadian community.