Canada Spends Logo

Explore our Budget 2026 analysis

Grant: CIHR Fellowship

Direct Payment

$100,000.00

Cognitive bias in the evidence: Sex- and gender-related health disparities in depression

FY 2021-22

Summary
Depression affects over 264 million people worldwide and is 2 times more common among women than men. However, men have an increased tendency for violent behaviour, substance use, and their rate of suicide is 3 to 4 times higher than women. The typical symptoms of depression include depressed mood, worry, fatigue, and difficulty concentrating. In contrast, some men have atypical symptoms of depression such as anger and irritability, and these symptoms are not represented in clinical guidelines. When clinicians decide on a patient's diagnosis, they often compare them to the 'most common type of patient', and for depression the average patient is a woman with typical depression symptoms. As such, biases in clinical decision-making for depression may explain why men are under diagnosed, which has significant risks when untreated. The goal of this research is to understand if biases in clinical decision-making contribute to sex and gender differences in the diagnosis of depression. We will first invite clinicians to complete a survey that presents them with a series of the same patient cases of depression, but where the sex/gender of the case is randomly chosen. This will see whether the patient's diagnosis given varies when all that differs is their sex/gender. Next, we will interview groups of clinicians to learn about how they diagnose depression, how biases may influence their clinical practice, and explore ways to change these biases. This will be the first study of its kind to evaluate if biases in clinical decision-making contribute to the sex and gender differences seen in depression. Findings of this research provide critical knowledge to improve the diagnosis and outcomes of people living with depression.
Program
CIHR Fellowship
Location
California, United States of America
Type
Grant
Source
CIHR Funding Decisions Database

As published

Id
454713
Name
Howren Alyssa M
Region
California
Country
United States of America
Orgtype
Research Institution
Instname2
Gender and Health
Theme2
Health systems / services
Prcname2
Health Research Training A - Post-PhD (HTA)
Projecttitle
Cognitive bias in the evidence: Sex- and gender-related health disparities in depression
Programtype2
Fellowship Programs
Orgnameinp2
Direct Payment
Cihramount2
$100,000
Cihrequipment2
$0
Programname2
CIHR Fellowship
Keyworddelim
Cognitive Bias; Depression; Focus Groups; Gender; Mixed Methods Research; Randomized Experiments; Sex
Abstract
Depression affects over 264 million people worldwide and is 2 times more common among women than men. However, men have an increased tendency for violent behaviour, substance use, and their rate of suicide is 3 to 4 times higher than women. The typical symptoms of depression include depressed mood, worry, fatigue, and difficulty concentrating. In contrast, some men have atypical symptoms of depression such as anger and irritability, and these symptoms are not represented in clinical guidelines. When clinicians decide on a patient's diagnosis, they often compare them to the 'most common type of patient', and for depression the average patient is a woman with typical depression symptoms. As such, biases in clinical decision-making for depression may explain why men are under diagnosed, which has significant risks when untreated. The goal of this research is to understand if biases in clinical decision-making contribute to sex and gender differences in the diagnosis of depression. We will first invite clinicians to complete a survey that presents them with a series of the same patient cases of depression, but where the sex/gender of the case is randomly chosen. This will see whether the patient's diagnosis given varies when all that differs is their sex/gender. Next, we will interview groups of clinicians to learn about how they diagnose depression, how biases may influence their clinical practice, and explore ways to change these biases. This will be the first study of its kind to evaluate if biases in clinical decision-making contribute to the sex and gender differences seen in depression. Findings of this research provide critical knowledge to improve the diagnosis and outcomes of people living with depression.
Competitiondate
202110
Approvedterm2
2 yrs 0 mth
Pinamesdelim
Howren, Alyssa M
Approvedterm
2 ans 0 mois
Cihrcontribution2
~ $100,000~ $0~
Direct Payment - $100,000 Grant (2021-22) | Canada Spends