Grant: Doctoral: Vanier Canada Graduate Scholarships
McMaster University
$150,000.00
Ethical frameworks to assess health technology: A theoretical and empirical study
FY 2012-13
Summary
I will explore how ethical frameworks as decision-making tools are utilized by governmental and non-governmental agencies to assess health technologies for public funding. My research will focus on whether these frameworks achieve their designed aim of providing the relevant social values perspective of the communities affected by the technologies, and how social values can be framed and utilized in this policy context to meaningfully reflect community interests. This question of 'what kind of material objects should one make and accept?' preoccupies policy makers because our commitments to technologies shape not only future technology but the contours of society itself. The ideals that shape a society emerge in part from the technologies it employs. Limited qualitative research has been conducted on this topic in Canada and globally, although the need for this perspective is what gave rise to the field of health technology assessment fifty years ago. My research will address a gap in the foundational theory and implementation of this influential area of health policy by outlining the regulatory/policy and funding context in which HTA is currently practiced, and by comprehensively describing how it is conducted in Canada, focusing on a provincial (Ontario Health Assessment Technology Advisory Committee - OHTAC) and national (Canadian Agency for Drugs and Technologies in Health - CADTH) program. I will use the qualitative participant-observer method, together with focused interviews, to describe and interpret stakeholder views on the nature and justifiability of policies and practices in this area, and use inductive analysis to relate these findings to relevant themes in the areas of science and technology ethics, community engagement theory, and policy studies. Finally, I will propose a model for incorporating social values and ethical expertise into decision-making about health technology that can be utilized as efficiently and effectively as other HTA criteria.
Department
Program
Doctoral: Vanier Canada Graduate Scholarships
Recipient
Location
Ontario, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
CIHR Funding Decisions Database
As published
Id
273540
Name
Winsor Shawn
Region
Ontario
Country
Canada
Orgtype
Institution Paid; Research Institution
Instname2
Health Services and Policy Research
Theme2
Health systems / services
Prcname2
Vanier Canada Graduate Scholarships CIHR
Projecttitle
Ethical frameworks to assess health technology: A theoretical and empirical study
Programtype2
Studentship Programs
Orgnameinp2
McMaster University
Cihramount2
$150,000
Cihrequipment2
$0
Programname2
Doctoral: Vanier Canada Graduate Scholarships
Keyworddelim
Bioethics Theory; Community Engagement Theory; Health Policy Analysis; Health Technology Assessment; Inductive Analysis; Participant-Observer Design; Qualitative Research Methodology; Science And Technology Studies
Abstract
I will explore how ethical frameworks as decision-making tools are utilized by governmental and non-governmental agencies to assess health technologies for public funding. My research will focus on whether these frameworks achieve their designed aim of providing the relevant social values perspective of the communities affected by the technologies, and how social values can be framed and utilized in this policy context to meaningfully reflect community interests. This question of 'what kind of material objects should one make and accept?' preoccupies policy makers because our commitments to technologies shape not only future technology but the contours of society itself. The ideals that shape a society emerge in part from the technologies it employs. Limited qualitative research has been conducted on this topic in Canada and globally, although the need for this perspective is what gave rise to the field of health technology assessment fifty years ago. My research will address a gap in the foundational theory and implementation of this influential area of health policy by outlining the regulatory/policy and funding context in which HTA is currently practiced, and by comprehensively describing how it is conducted in Canada, focusing on a provincial (Ontario Health Assessment Technology Advisory Committee - OHTAC) and national (Canadian Agency for Drugs and Technologies in Health - CADTH) program. I will use the qualitative participant-observer method, together with focused interviews, to describe and interpret stakeholder views on the nature and justifiability of policies and practices in this area, and use inductive analysis to relate these findings to relevant themes in the areas of science and technology ethics, community engagement theory, and policy studies. Finally, I will propose a model for incorporating social values and ethical expertise into decision-making about health technology that can be utilized as efficiently and effectively as other HTA criteria.
Competitiondate
201211
Approvedterm2
3 yrs 0 mth
Pinamesdelim
Winsor, Shawn
Approvedterm
3 ans 0 mois
Cihrcontribution2
~ $150,000~ $0~