Grant: Fellowship - Prize: Knowledge Translation Supplement
McGill University
$5,000.00
Validity, reliability and usability of a tool for appraising the methodological quality of qualitative, quantitative and mixed studies
FY 2012-13
Summary
Systematic reviews of the scientific literature are an important source on which clinicians and decision makers can rely to get reliable and valid information. Systematic reviews follow a rigorous process in which research studies are identified, selected, appraised, and synthesized. Typically, these reviews have given preference to combining similar quantitative research methods. However, more and more researchers are interested in a new form of literature review known as Mixed Studies Review (MSR). MSR combines different types of research (qualitative, quantitative, and/or mixed studies) and allows reviewers to obtain in-depth answers to complex research questions. For example, whilst looking for evidence of effectiveness of an intervention from quantitative research, evidence from qualitative research can provide insight into internal and external factors that may explain why and how an intervention works. One challenge of MSRs is the difficulty to critically appraise the quality of studies since they are of different types. To overcome this challenge, an appraisal tool was developed: the Mixed Method Appraisal Tool (MMAT). The MMAT proposes criteria for appraising the methodological quality of different types of studies. The present project will pursue the development of the MMAT, and ensures that it has enough items and that they adequately covers the methodological quality of studies included in MSRs (content validity), that similar measures are obtained if used by different raters (inter-rater reliability), and that it is usable in practice. To pursue this tool's development and validation, a review of the literature will be conducted, a panel of international experts will be mobilized, and raters will be recruited. Also, a web-application of the MMAT will be created for usability testing and dissemination. The MMAT may become a standard critical appraisal tool that will be used to improve the quality of information in MSRs.
Department
Program
Fellowship - Prize: Knowledge Translation Supplement
Recipient
Location
Quebec, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
CIHR Funding Decisions Database
As published
Id
288163
Name
Hong Quan Nha
Region
Québec
Country
Canada
Orgtype
Institution Paid; Research Institution
Instname2
Health Services and Policy Research
Theme2
Health systems / services
Prcname2
Allied Health Professionals - Fellowships
Projecttitle
Validity, reliability and usability of a tool for appraising the methodological quality of qualitative, quantitative and mixed studies
Programtype2
Fellowship Programs
Orgnameinp2
McGill University
Cihramount2
$5,000
Cihrequipment2
$0
Programname2
Fellowship - Prize: Knowledge Translation Supplement
Keyworddelim
Critical Assessment Tool; E-Delphi; Mixed Methods; Reliability; Systematic Mixed Studies Review; Umbrella Review; Usability; Validity
Abstract
Systematic reviews of the scientific literature are an important source on which clinicians and decision makers can rely to get reliable and valid information. Systematic reviews follow a rigorous process in which research studies are identified, selected, appraised, and synthesized. Typically, these reviews have given preference to combining similar quantitative research methods. However, more and more researchers are interested in a new form of literature review known as Mixed Studies Review (MSR). MSR combines different types of research (qualitative, quantitative, and/or mixed studies) and allows reviewers to obtain in-depth answers to complex research questions. For example, whilst looking for evidence of effectiveness of an intervention from quantitative research, evidence from qualitative research can provide insight into internal and external factors that may explain why and how an intervention works. One challenge of MSRs is the difficulty to critically appraise the quality of studies since they are of different types. To overcome this challenge, an appraisal tool was developed: the Mixed Method Appraisal Tool (MMAT). The MMAT proposes criteria for appraising the methodological quality of different types of studies. The present project will pursue the development of the MMAT, and ensures that it has enough items and that they adequately covers the methodological quality of studies included in MSRs (content validity), that similar measures are obtained if used by different raters (inter-rater reliability), and that it is usable in practice. To pursue this tool's development and validation, a review of the literature will be conducted, a panel of international experts will be mobilized, and raters will be recruited. Also, a web-application of the MMAT will be created for usability testing and dissemination. The MMAT may become a standard critical appraisal tool that will be used to improve the quality of information in MSRs.
Competitiondate
201302
Approvedterm2
1 yr 0 mth
Pinamesdelim
Hong, Quan Nha
Approvedterm
1 an 0 mois
Cihrcontribution2
~ $5,000~ $0~