Canada Spends Logo

Explore our Budget 2026 analysis

Grant: Operating Grant

McMaster University

$168,291.00

Judgments of Equity in Health Care Resource Allocation

FY 2011-12

Summary
There are increasing calls in Canada for resource allocation decisions to be more systematically informed by the views of the public. Major health care commissions since 2000 have called for greater public involvement in decision making, and Listening for Directions III has emphasized this in the priority area, "Values-based Decision-making and Public Engagement." Canadians' views on equity in resource allocation are particularly relevant in this context. Eliciting the views of the public regarding resource allocation, however, raises a number of challenges, of which one of the most important is framing effects. A framing effect is a phenomenon whereby different presentations of an identical underlying choice problem lead to different choices. In a previously published study we documented a type of framing effect whereby people's judgments regarding the equitable, or fair, division of health care resource among individuals differed depending on whether alternative allocation principles were described verbally or quantitatively. The research proposed in this application will extend our earlier study to investigate sources of these differences in judgments and to test how judgments differ between simple allocation problems such as that used in the original study and more realistic, system-level allocation problems involving health regions. In addition, the study will use a national sample (rather than a regional sample) of Canadians and use allocation problems that better distinguish the principles on which people make their judgments. The information generated will both aid in the development of methods for reliably eliciting the views of Canadians on health care resource allocation and provide new insight into the equity-related reasoning of Canadians.
Program
Operating Grant
Location
Ontario, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
CIHR Funding Decisions Database

As published

Id
238014
Name
Hurley Jeremiah E
Region
Ontario
Country
Canada
Orgtype
Institution Paid; Research Institution
Instname2
Health Services and Policy Research
Theme2
Health systems / services
Prcname2
Health Policy & Systems Management Research
Projecttitle
Judgments of Equity in Health Care Resource Allocation
Programtype2
Operating Grants
Orgnameinp2
McMaster University
Cihramount2
$168,291
Cihrequipment2
$0
Programname2
Operating Grant
Keyworddelim
Health Care Analysis; Health Care Equity; Health Care Policy; Health Economics
Abstract
There are increasing calls in Canada for resource allocation decisions to be more systematically informed by the views of the public. Major health care commissions since 2000 have called for greater public involvement in decision making, and Listening for Directions III has emphasized this in the priority area, "Values-based Decision-making and Public Engagement." Canadians' views on equity in resource allocation are particularly relevant in this context. Eliciting the views of the public regarding resource allocation, however, raises a number of challenges, of which one of the most important is framing effects. A framing effect is a phenomenon whereby different presentations of an identical underlying choice problem lead to different choices. In a previously published study we documented a type of framing effect whereby people's judgments regarding the equitable, or fair, division of health care resource among individuals differed depending on whether alternative allocation principles were described verbally or quantitatively. The research proposed in this application will extend our earlier study to investigate sources of these differences in judgments and to test how judgments differ between simple allocation problems such as that used in the original study and more realistic, system-level allocation problems involving health regions. In addition, the study will use a national sample (rather than a regional sample) of Canadians and use allocation problems that better distinguish the principles on which people make their judgments. The information generated will both aid in the development of methods for reliably eliciting the views of Canadians on health care resource allocation and provide new insight into the equity-related reasoning of Canadians.
Competitiondate
201109
Approvedterm2
1 yr 6 mths
Pinamesdelim
Hurley, Jeremiah E
Approvedterm
1 an 6 mois
Cihrcontribution2
~ $168,291~ $0~