Grant: Engage Grants Program
Concordia University
$25,000.00
Optimizing municipal drainage infrastructure design using environment-based design methodology
FY 2013-14
Summary
SMA Consulting Ltd. works primarily with owners, contractors, and other consultants in the field of capitalconstruction. Among the services they provide is an innovative hybrid VE/RA (Value engineering/Riskanalysis) process, which can help organizations to optimize their decision-making process by pooling theknowledge of experts in the fields pertaining to a given project. While the process excels at directing thisexpertise towards identifying the scenarios that best meet the objectives of a project's stakeholders, a significantinefficiency exists in selecting the criteria for evaluating these scenarios. Typically, criteria are assigned basedon expert knowledge about the project's individual components. Although the information phase of the VEmethodology usually includes extensive background into the project that can help to identify the top criteria, itis not always clear whether the criteria selected are the most relevant to the project. Instead, since evaluationcriteria are dependent upon an accurate description of the interactions between a design and its environment, amore structured approach to identifying these interactions is required.The purpose of this project is to adopt Environment-based Design (EBD) methodology for infrastructureplanning as a supplement to SMA's VE/RA model. A municipal drainage infrastructure project will be used asa case study, with the collaboration occurring in parallel to SMA's work on the project. EBD is an innovativedesign methodology for shaping the thinking and guiding the development of design logic in a systematicprocedure. It will aid SMA in reviewing possible solutions and to identify a socially, economically, andenvironmentally beneficial option for mitigating potential risks.The deliverable of this project is a technical report that includes the following three components:1) Adynamic framework to guide a brainstorming workshop to be organized in September 2013. 2) A flexiblequestion-asking template to extract the relevant information from the workshop results. 3) A list of relevantevaluation criteria for the drainage project.
Program
Engage Grants Program
Recipient
Location
Quebec, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data
As published
Application id
452621-2013
Name nom
Zeng, Yong
Department département
Concordia Institute for Information Systems Engineering (CIISE)
Organization id
70
Institution établissement
Concordia University
Province en
Québec
Province fr
Québec
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2013
Competition year année de concours
2013
Award amount
25000
Program id
EGP
Program name en
Engage Grants Program
Program name fr
Programme de subventions d'engagement partenariat
Group en
Research partnerships programs
Group fr
Programmes de partenariat
Committee code
1552
Committee name en
Quebec Internal Decision Committee
Committee name fr
Comité de décision interne pour le Québec
Area of application code
400
Area of application group en
Environment
Area of application group fr
Environnement
Area of application en
Environment
Area of application fr
Environnement
Research subject code
1600
Research subject group en
Industrial engineering
Research subject group fr
Génie industriel
Research subject en
Industrial engineering
Research subject fr
Génie industriel
Partie
1
Nb partie
1
Application title
Optimizing municipal drainage infrastructure design using environment-based design methodology
Keyword
NSERC
Application summary
SMA Consulting Ltd. works primarily with owners, contractors, and other consultants in the field of capitalconstruction. Among the services they provide is an innovative hybrid VE/RA (Value engineering/Riskanalysis) process, which can help organizations to optimize their decision-making process by pooling theknowledge of experts in the fields pertaining to a given project. While the process excels at directing thisexpertise towards identifying the scenarios that best meet the objectives of a project's stakeholders, a significantinefficiency exists in selecting the criteria for evaluating these scenarios. Typically, criteria are assigned basedon expert knowledge about the project's individual components. Although the information phase of the VEmethodology usually includes extensive background into the project that can help to identify the top criteria, itis not always clear whether the criteria selected are the most relevant to the project. Instead, since evaluationcriteria are dependent upon an accurate description of the interactions between a design and its environment, amore structured approach to identifying these interactions is required.The purpose of this project is to adopt Environment-based Design (EBD) methodology for infrastructureplanning as a supplement to SMA's VE/RA model. A municipal drainage infrastructure project will be used asa case study, with the collaboration occurring in parallel to SMA's work on the project. EBD is an innovativedesign methodology for shaping the thinking and guiding the development of design logic in a systematicprocedure. It will aid SMA in reviewing possible solutions and to identify a socially, economically, andenvironmentally beneficial option for mitigating potential risks.The deliverable of this project is a technical report that includes the following three components:1) Adynamic framework to guide a brainstorming workshop to be organized in September 2013. 2) A flexiblequestion-asking template to extract the relevant information from the workshop results. 3) A list of relevantevaluation criteria for the drainage project.