Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual
The University of British Columbia
$59,000.00
Welfare, affect and agency in animals
FY 2023-24
Summary
The long-term aim of my Discovery funded research program is to develop robust approaches for animal welfare assessment, including the assessment of negative affective states such as pain and fear. How we experience the world around us is determined both by characteristics of the stimuli we are exposed to, and by our expectations of the experience. The importance of expectations on affective states is best illustrated in the human pain literature via the placebo effect, showing that the expectation of pain relief results in the experience of less pain. The idea that experiences are determined in part by expectations is known as the Bayesian brain hypothesis. Despite the clear relevance of this hypothesis for animal welfare, little work has assessed the role of expectations on the affective experiences of animals, and how these expectations develop. Thus, the general aim of this proposal is to test welfare-relevant predictions derived from this hypothesis. Three specific aims will be addressed. The first is to determine how affective expectations are acquired and how these expectations influence the way that future aversive stimuli are experienced. The Bayesian brain hypothesis requires that animals update their expectations based upon on-going experiences. When the experience is worse than expected (e.g., when losing access to a reward), animals are predicted to experience negative affect, especially if they are already in a negative state. Hence my second aim is to test if animals already experiencing negative affect (such as pain) show increased responses to reward loss. Negative affect can also interfere with perception and cognitive processes in important ways. For example, the cognitive demand of pain can restrict attention to other cues. Thus, my final aim is to test if negative affective states interfere with memory and learning in animals, and if such deficits become persistent. The proposed research will focus on laboratory rodents and dairy cattle. I have access to excellent research facilities for both systems, and work on these species is socially relevant as they are subjected to routine procedures that can be pain or fear inducing. The proposed studies will contribute to the basic literature on affective states in animals, with important implications for our understanding of the welfare of animals kept in laboratory and agricultural systems. The funding will support the training of five PhD, two MSc and 30 BSc students, all welcomed into a diverse team crafted to provide a high level of individual support. Students will learn and contribute to the creation of techniques for welfare assessment, and will be given opportunities for leadership, professional development, and interaction with end users. The results of their work will help inform improvements to the care and management of farmed and laboratory animals, helping to improve their lives and the lives of the people who care for them.
Program
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Recipient
Location
British Columbia, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data
As published
Application id
RGPIN-2023-04350
Name nom
Weary, Daniel
Department département
Land and Food Systems
Organization id
2
Institution établissement
The University of British Columbia
Province en
British Columbia
Province fr
Colombie-Britannique
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2023
Competition year année de concours
2023
Award amount
59000
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
DISCOVERY RESEARCH
Group fr
RECHERCHE AXÉE SUR LA DÉCOUVERTE
Committee code
1502
Committee name en
Biological Systems and Functions
Committee name fr
Systèmes et fonctions biologiques
Area of application code
1209
Area of application group en
Advancement of knowledge
Area of application group fr
Avancement des connaissances
Area of application en
Agriculture
Area of application fr
Agriculture
Research subject code
5500
Research subject group en
Animal biology
Research subject group fr
Animal biology
Research subject en
Biologie animale
Research subject fr
Biologie animale
Application title
Welfare, affect and agency in animals
Keyword
animal behaviour; animal welfare; Bayesian brain; cognition; expectation; fear; learning; negative affect; pain; suffering
Application summary
The long-term aim of my Discovery funded research program is to develop robust approaches for animal welfare assessment, including the assessment of negative affective states such as pain and fear. How we experience the world around us is determined both by characteristics of the stimuli we are exposed to, and by our expectations of the experience. The importance of expectations on affective states is best illustrated in the human pain literature via the placebo effect, showing that the expectation of pain relief results in the experience of less pain. The idea that experiences are determined in part by expectations is known as the Bayesian brain hypothesis. Despite the clear relevance of this hypothesis for animal welfare, little work has assessed the role of expectations on the affective experiences of animals, and how these expectations develop. Thus, the general aim of this proposal is to test welfare-relevant predictions derived from this hypothesis. Three specific aims will be addressed. The first is to determine how affective expectations are acquired and how these expectations influence the way that future aversive stimuli are experienced. The Bayesian brain hypothesis requires that animals update their expectations based upon on-going experiences. When the experience is worse than expected (e.g., when losing access to a reward), animals are predicted to experience negative affect, especially if they are already in a negative state. Hence my second aim is to test if animals already experiencing negative affect (such as pain) show increased responses to reward loss. Negative affect can also interfere with perception and cognitive processes in important ways. For example, the cognitive demand of pain can restrict attention to other cues. Thus, my final aim is to test if negative affective states interfere with memory and learning in animals, and if such deficits become persistent. The proposed research will focus on laboratory rodents and dairy cattle. I have access to excellent research facilities for both systems, and work on these species is socially relevant as they are subjected to routine procedures that can be pain or fear inducing. The proposed studies will contribute to the basic literature on affective states in animals, with important implications for our understanding of the welfare of animals kept in laboratory and agricultural systems. The funding will support the training of five PhD, two MSc and 30 BSc students, all welcomed into a diverse team crafted to provide a high level of individual support. Students will learn and contribute to the creation of techniques for welfare assessment, and will be given opportunities for leadership, professional development, and interaction with end users. The results of their work will help inform improvements to the care and management of farmed and laboratory animals, helping to improve their lives and the lives of the people who care for them.