Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual
University of Alberta
$71,260.00
Behavioural and neural dynamics during competitive decision-making
FY 2024-25
Summary
There are a number of serious and playful situations where an organism must repeatedly compete with others for mutually-exclusive outcomes: there will be only one Prime Minister, only one winner at Scrabble, only one bird able to forage nectar from any given flower. Competitive decision-making represents a critical test case between behaviorist and cognitive influences on action, where the high-quality thought required for success is compromised by evolutionary impulses. Within these exchanges, we must repeatedly deal with the experience of success and failure, continually monitor the perceived degree of environmental control, and, update dynamic processes that attempt to minimize losses and maximize gains.
Recent work has identified reliable limits in competitive performance including deviations from randomness (such as win-stay and lose-shift) when attempting to avoid losses. Similarly, the experience of negative outcomes (such as losing or drawing) are causal factors in initiating impulsive sub-optimal behavior inhibiting the degree to which we maximize wins. What is less clear is how these potentially catastrophic cycles of irrational behavior are repaired, and, how the early neural processes of attention, outcome categorization and motivational significance interact to modulate these patterns of performance. The proposed work will 1) reconcile the currently confounded roles that temporal delay and response interruption play on perpetuating sub-optimal performance, 2) illuminate the major chain of neural events that cause behavior in these contexts, and, 3) consolidate findings in a comprehensive model regarding the perception of and reaction to competitive threat.
To fulfill the empirical ambitions of the program, behavioral and electrophysiological measurement will be integrated as human participants engage with a variety of opponents within game spaces. Games provide an ideal paradigm to study competitive decision-making since opponent characteristics are perfectly controlled, the resolution of competition is fast yielding a high signal-to-noise ratio, and, games provide intrinsic motivation in a laboratory setting by being both intuitive and fun to play. The theoretical goal of the program will provide a full appreciation of the conditions under which we believe we can and cannot control decision-making quality. Knowing when our losses were due to our lack of ability and when our wins were due to luck are critical mechanisms that cut across a variety of contexts. In education, students devalue self-worth due to negative feedback rather than improve their skills. In industry, fear of forthcoming failure produces inefficient solutions and unethical behavior. In problem gambling, cycles of poor performance are perpetuated by the overweighting of losses relative to wins. This empirical and theoretical synthesis provides clear guidelines for helping individuals improve decision-making when they may be at their most cognitively vulnerable.
Program
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Recipient
Location
Alberta, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data
As published
Application id
RGPIN-2019-04954
Name nom
Dyson, Ben
Department département
Psychology
Organization id
9
Institution établissement
University of Alberta
Province en
Alberta
Province fr
Alberta
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2024
Competition year année de concours
2019
Award amount
71260
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
DISCOVERY RESEARCH
Group fr
RECHERCHE AXÉE SUR LA DÉCOUVERTE
Committee code
1502
Committee name en
Biological Systems and Functions
Committee name fr
Systèmes et fonctions biologiques
Area of application code
1210
Area of application group en
Advancement of knowledge
Area of application group fr
Avancement des connaissances
Area of application en
Psychology
Area of application fr
Psychologie
Research subject code
6308
Research subject group en
Psychology
Research subject group fr
Psychologie
Research subject en
Behavioural neuroscience
Research subject fr
Neurologie du comportement
Field of research list names en
Not available
Field of research list names fr
Non disponible
Socioeconomic objective list names en
Not available
Socioeconomic objective list names fr
Non disponible
Application title
Behavioural and neural dynamics during competitive decision-making
Keywords
competitive decision making; cognitive heuristics; operant conditioning; reinforcement learning; win-stay / lose-shift; electrophysiology; feedback-related negativity (frn)
Application summary
There are a number of serious and playful situations where an organism must repeatedly compete with others for mutually-exclusive outcomes: there will be only one Prime Minister, only one winner at Scrabble, only one bird able to forage nectar from any given flower. Competitive decision-making represents a critical test case between behaviorist and cognitive influences on action, where the high-quality thought required for success is compromised by evolutionary impulses. Within these exchanges, we must repeatedly deal with the experience of success and failure, continually monitor the perceived degree of environmental control, and, update dynamic processes that attempt to minimize losses and maximize gains.
Recent work has identified reliable limits in competitive performance including deviations from randomness (such as win-stay and lose-shift) when attempting to avoid losses. Similarly, the experience of negative outcomes (such as losing or drawing) are causal factors in initiating impulsive sub-optimal behavior inhibiting the degree to which we maximize wins. What is less clear is how these potentially catastrophic cycles of irrational behavior are repaired, and, how the early neural processes of attention, outcome categorization and motivational significance interact to modulate these patterns of performance. The proposed work will 1) reconcile the currently confounded roles that temporal delay and response interruption play on perpetuating sub-optimal performance, 2) illuminate the major chain of neural events that cause behavior in these contexts, and, 3) consolidate findings in a comprehensive model regarding the perception of and reaction to competitive threat.
To fulfill the empirical ambitions of the program, behavioral and electrophysiological measurement will be integrated as human participants engage with a variety of opponents within game spaces. Games provide an ideal paradigm to study competitive decision-making since opponent characteristics are perfectly controlled, the resolution of competition is fast yielding a high signal-to-noise ratio, and, games provide intrinsic motivation in a laboratory setting by being both intuitive and fun to play. The theoretical goal of the program will provide a full appreciation of the conditions under which we believe we can and cannot control decision-making quality. Knowing when our losses were due to our lack of ability and when our wins were due to luck are critical mechanisms that cut across a variety of contexts. In education, students devalue self-worth due to negative feedback rather than improve their skills. In industry, fear of forthcoming failure produces inefficient solutions and unethical behavior. In problem gambling, cycles of poor performance are perpetuated by the overweighting of losses relative to wins. This empirical and theoretical synthesis provides clear guidelines for helping individuals improve decision-making when they may be at their most cognitively vulnerable.