Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual
McMaster University
$44,000.00
The effects of mistakes and action choice on the sense of agency in single and multi-agent settings
FY 2023-24
Summary
Humans are agents: we exert effects on our environment through our actions and feel a sense of control, referred to as the sense of agency (SoA). SoA isn't something that we dwell on in our daily lives. When you flick a switch and the light comes on, you don't deliberate over your causal role. Rather, you "just know" it was you. If someone asks who turned the light on, you are perfectly able to explicitly report that it was you. These two forms of SoA have been termed pre-reflective agency in the case of "just knowing" and reflective agency in the case of reporting that "I did it". These forms of SoA are assessed using a measure called intentional binding (IB) in the case of pre-reflective agency, and explicit agency judgements (EAJ) in the case of reflective agency. When SoA goes awry, the consequences are profound as is the case for some people with schizophrenia who experience delusions of control. We will use cognitive, perceptual and brain measures to answer several questions about the SoA. First, we ask what happens to the SoA for actions that produce mistakes. Our research suggests that IB is stronger (suggesting enhanced SoA) for mistakes. In several experiments, we will shed light on the brain processes that accompany this enhanced SoA for mistakes. It is important to understand this as mistakes are a common part of human experience. Second, we build on prior work from our lab showing that freedom to choose actions enhances SoA (both IB and EAJ). We will perform studies examining which specific aspects of actions people need freedom of choice over for enhanced SoA (e.g., "what" action to make, "when" to make it). These experiments are needed to resolve mixed findings in the literature about the precise relationship between freedom to choose actions and SoA. Importantly, we will address these issues, SoA for mistakes and the relation between SoA and free choice, both when individuals act alone and when they act with others, including when the other is a non-human machine. Finally, we will examine SoA when decisions for action and execution of action are carried out by different agents within a hierarchy (e.g. when one commands another what to do). The short-term goals are to understand i) how mistakes affect the SoA, and ii) how choice demands affect SoA, both when agents act alone and when they share task components with other agents. The long-term goal is to gain a comprehensive understanding of the human SoA, both in terms of its determinants and underlying mechanisms. The impact of this work is primarily to advance basic science but our research also has implications for informing the design of environments and products that maximize human SoA. This is important because SoA is a critical component of autonomy, which is a fundamental human need. Overall, this work could have a positive impact in Canada by increasing the sense of control that Canadians experience in their lives, across a range of settings from work to home.
Program
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Recipient
Location
Ontario, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data
As published
Application id
RGPIN-2023-04772
Name nom
Obhi, Sukhvinder
Department département
Psychology, Neuroscience & Behaviour
Organization id
27
Institution établissement
McMaster University
Province en
Ontario
Province fr
Ontario
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2023
Competition year année de concours
2023
Award amount
44000
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
DISCOVERY RESEARCH
Group fr
RECHERCHE AXÉE SUR LA DÉCOUVERTE
Committee code
1502
Committee name en
Biological Systems and Functions
Committee name fr
Systèmes et fonctions biologiques
Area of application code
1200
Area of application group en
Advancement of knowledge
Area of application group fr
Avancement des connaissances
Area of application en
Advancement of knowledge
Area of application fr
Avancement des connaissances
Research subject code
6304
Research subject group en
Psychology
Research subject group fr
Cognitive science -- fundamental
Research subject en
Psychologie
Research subject fr
Science cognitive -- principes fondamentaux
Application title
The effects of mistakes and action choice on the sense of agency in single and multi-agent settings
Keyword
Electroencephalography; Errors; Group Action; Intentional binding; Joint Action; Mistakes; Sense of Agency; Volition
Application summary
Humans are agents: we exert effects on our environment through our actions and feel a sense of control, referred to as the sense of agency (SoA). SoA isn't something that we dwell on in our daily lives. When you flick a switch and the light comes on, you don't deliberate over your causal role. Rather, you "just know" it was you. If someone asks who turned the light on, you are perfectly able to explicitly report that it was you. These two forms of SoA have been termed pre-reflective agency in the case of "just knowing" and reflective agency in the case of reporting that "I did it". These forms of SoA are assessed using a measure called intentional binding (IB) in the case of pre-reflective agency, and explicit agency judgements (EAJ) in the case of reflective agency. When SoA goes awry, the consequences are profound as is the case for some people with schizophrenia who experience delusions of control. We will use cognitive, perceptual and brain measures to answer several questions about the SoA. First, we ask what happens to the SoA for actions that produce mistakes. Our research suggests that IB is stronger (suggesting enhanced SoA) for mistakes. In several experiments, we will shed light on the brain processes that accompany this enhanced SoA for mistakes. It is important to understand this as mistakes are a common part of human experience. Second, we build on prior work from our lab showing that freedom to choose actions enhances SoA (both IB and EAJ). We will perform studies examining which specific aspects of actions people need freedom of choice over for enhanced SoA (e.g., "what" action to make, "when" to make it). These experiments are needed to resolve mixed findings in the literature about the precise relationship between freedom to choose actions and SoA. Importantly, we will address these issues, SoA for mistakes and the relation between SoA and free choice, both when individuals act alone and when they act with others, including when the other is a non-human machine. Finally, we will examine SoA when decisions for action and execution of action are carried out by different agents within a hierarchy (e.g. when one commands another what to do). The short-term goals are to understand i) how mistakes affect the SoA, and ii) how choice demands affect SoA, both when agents act alone and when they share task components with other agents. The long-term goal is to gain a comprehensive understanding of the human SoA, both in terms of its determinants and underlying mechanisms. The impact of this work is primarily to advance basic science but our research also has implications for informing the design of environments and products that maximize human SoA. This is important because SoA is a critical component of autonomy, which is a fundamental human need. Overall, this work could have a positive impact in Canada by increasing the sense of control that Canadians experience in their lives, across a range of settings from work to home.