Canada Spends Logo

Explore our Budget 2026 analysis

Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual

University of Toronto

$22,000.00

An Ontological Approach to Modelling and Analysing System Performance

FY 2014-15

Summary
This research focuses on one aspect of the design and analysis of integrated systems, namely the formalization, standardization and automated analysis of system performance measurement (referred to as Metrics from here on in). One class of systems we wish to study is cities and the performance measures we wish to formalize and analyze are ?city indicators.? City indicators measure city services and functions, including Education, Health, Safety, Transportation, and Water. ""There are thousands of different sets of city (or urban) indicators and hundreds of agencies compiling and reviewing them. ? However, these indicators are usually not standardized, consistent or comparable (over time or across cities) ...? (Hornweeg et al., 2007). This problem has been exacerbated by the ?Open Data? movement where cities are publishing vast amounts of data, but no two cities nor departments within a city use the same data models (Fox, 2013a). A consequence of this ?babel? of open data is that it is difficult to combine, analyze and compare city data. The problem does not end with an agreement on the surface definition of an indicator, as each term within the definition has to be further defined (i.e., grounded) and supporting data provided. We believe it is possible to identify and create a generic, reusable ontology for Metrics. We believe an ontology can be created by combining existing foundation, heterogeneous ontologies, and extending them with trans-foundation axioms. By heterogeneous, we mean ontologies that span analytical models (e.g., ratios), statistical models (e.g., population measurements), geo-spatial models (e.g., city boundaries), temporal models (e.g., time periods) and description logic models (e.g., definitions of students, teachers, etc.). But also incorporate meta-knowledge such as provenance, validity and trust. We believe that the ontology will make it possible to automate the drilling down and detection of inconsistencies in the supporting, heterogeneous data. Hence, our first objective is to formalize the definition of Metrics using the technology of Formal Ontologies as implemented in the Semantic Web. We believe it is possible to create a logical theory of Metrics analysis. We believe that consistency analysis provides a basis for detecting root causes in changes in Metrics. Hence, our second objective is to develop a reusable, interoperable logical theory of longitudinal and transversal analysis of Metrics. We will extend the Metrics? consistency axioms to address longitudinal (temporal) and transversal (cross city) consistency across heterogeneous models. Strong, successful cities are prerequisites for a strong, vibrant nation. In Canada, over 80% of Canadians currently live in urban areas. The sustainability of urban regions (in environmental, social and fiscal terms), and their resilience to both man-made and natural large-scale events, are thus of first-order national importance to our well-being and quality of life. Dealing intelligently and effectively with the complex problems of urban management and design requires use of the best information, analysis and decision-support tools available. This program?s contributions include: ? The formal definition of Metrics that provide precise, unambiguous and machine interpretable definitions of system performance, ? The ability to perform consistency and comparative analyses of Metrics based upon their definitions (as opposed to ad hoc software implementations), and ? In the case of cities, the standardization of terminology thereby enabling cities to publish their open data using common vocabularies or ontologies.
Program
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Location
Ontario, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data

As published

Application id
RGPIN-2014-06508
Name nom
Fox, Mark
Department département
Mechanical & Industrial Engineering
Organization id
31
Institution établissement
University of Toronto
Province en
Ontario
Province fr
Ontario
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2014
Competition year année de concours
2014
Award amount
22000
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
Discovery grants programs
Group fr
Programmes de subventions à la découverte
Committee code
1509
Committee name en
Civil, Industrial and Systems Engineering
Committee name fr
Génie civil, industriel et des systèmes
Area of application code
802
Area of application group en
Information and communication services
Area of application group fr
Services d'information et de télécommunications
Area of application en
Information systems and technology
Area of application fr
Systèmes d'information et technologie de l'information
Research subject code
1602
Research subject group en
Industrial engineering
Research subject group fr
Génie industriel
Research subject en
Management information systems
Research subject fr
Systèmes d'information de gestion
Partie
1
Nb partie
5
Application title
An Ontological Approach to Modelling and Analysing System Performance
Keyword
NSERC
Application summary
This research focuses on one aspect of the design and analysis of integrated systems, namely the formalization, standardization and automated analysis of system performance measurement (referred to as Metrics from here on in). One class of systems we wish to study is cities and the performance measures we wish to formalize and analyze are ?city indicators.? City indicators measure city services and functions, including Education, Health, Safety, Transportation, and Water. ""There are thousands of different sets of city (or urban) indicators and hundreds of agencies compiling and reviewing them. ? However, these indicators are usually not standardized, consistent or comparable (over time or across cities) ...? (Hornweeg et al., 2007). This problem has been exacerbated by the ?Open Data? movement where cities are publishing vast amounts of data, but no two cities nor departments within a city use the same data models (Fox, 2013a). A consequence of this ?babel? of open data is that it is difficult to combine, analyze and compare city data. The problem does not end with an agreement on the surface definition of an indicator, as each term within the definition has to be further defined (i.e., grounded) and supporting data provided. We believe it is possible to identify and create a generic, reusable ontology for Metrics. We believe an ontology can be created by combining existing foundation, heterogeneous ontologies, and extending them with trans-foundation axioms. By heterogeneous, we mean ontologies that span analytical models (e.g., ratios), statistical models (e.g., population measurements), geo-spatial models (e.g., city boundaries), temporal models (e.g., time periods) and description logic models (e.g., definitions of students, teachers, etc.). But also incorporate meta-knowledge such as provenance, validity and trust. We believe that the ontology will make it possible to automate the drilling down and detection of inconsistencies in the supporting, heterogeneous data. Hence, our first objective is to formalize the definition of Metrics using the technology of Formal Ontologies as implemented in the Semantic Web. We believe it is possible to create a logical theory of Metrics analysis. We believe that consistency analysis provides a basis for detecting root causes in changes in Metrics. Hence, our second objective is to develop a reusable, interoperable logical theory of longitudinal and transversal analysis of Metrics. We will extend the Metrics? consistency axioms to address longitudinal (temporal) and transversal (cross city) consistency across heterogeneous models. Strong, successful cities are prerequisites for a strong, vibrant nation. In Canada, over 80% of Canadians currently live in urban areas. The sustainability of urban regions (in environmental, social and fiscal terms), and their resilience to both man-made and natural large-scale events, are thus of first-order national importance to our well-being and quality of life. Dealing intelligently and effectively with the complex problems of urban management and design requires use of the best information, analysis and decision-support tools available. This program?s contributions include: ? The formal definition of Metrics that provide precise, unambiguous and machine interpretable definitions of system performance, ? The ability to perform consistency and comparative analyses of Metrics based upon their definitions (as opposed to ad hoc software implementations), and ? In the case of cities, the standardization of terminology thereby enabling cities to publish their open data using common vocabularies or ontologies.