Canada Spends Logo

Explore our Budget 2026 analysis

Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual

University of Toronto

$33,000.00

Expanding our horizons in understanding brain and dietary evolution in Primates and their kin

FY 2022-23

Summary
The evolution of the diet is central to the process of primate origins. All of the competing scenarios for primate origins have a dietary component: visual predation focusing on adaptations for insectivory; terminal branch feeding involving an expansion of the arboreal dietary niche to include more fruit; and the grasp-leaping hypothesis, which incorporates a shift to greater herbivory in early primate evolution. Diet is of particular importance in understanding the evolution of the enlarged and complex primate brain. Building such a brain requires access to high energy food, while retrieving such broadly dispersed and irregularly available foodstuffs (e.g., fruit) requires greater degrees of processing power. Although analyses of modern primates have supported the important role of diet in brain evolution, they necessarily simplify the origin of primates down to a single node. The fossil record demonstrates that there were many lineages of stem primates, making it clear that the story is much more complex than the idealized version implied by such studies. Although there have been strides in recent years, there are still several lineages of early primates for which no quantitative work has been done to estimate aspects of diet. A critical component of this shortfall is that early primates have patterns of adaptations not found among living primates, meaning that living members of the order are insufficient models for reconstructing diet in those groups. The current study will seek to fill some of these gaps by considering a much broader range of model taxa and by using cutting edge dental topographic methods to allow for precise quantification of dental form. This study will also seek to expand the types of information that can be collected and compared with respect to the early evolution of the brain in primates. The strong evidence for rampant parallelism in primate brain size evolution implies that studies that are limited to living taxa will be constrained in reconstructing the size and shape of the brain in the common ancestor of all primates. This underscores the importance of fossils to an understanding of the early stages of primate brain evolution. Since the brain does not fossilize, the data available from even the best-preserved fossils is limited to the imprint of the brain preserved on the internal surface of the cranium (i.e., the endocast). The current study will seek to use geometric morphometric and DiceCT methods to expand the information about changing shape and function that can be extracted from such endocasts. Ultimately, the goal of this study will be to amass a dataset that will allow for a synthetic consideration of how shifting diets are aligned (or not) with changes in brain size and shape, using a phylogenetic framework that incorporates both fossil and extant members of Primates, and of closely related groups.
Program
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Location
Ontario, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data

As published

Application id
RGPIN-2022-03073
Name nom
Silcox, Mary
Department département
Anthropology and Health Studies (Scarborough) - Anthropology and Health Studies (Scarborough)
Organization id
31
Institution établissement
University of Toronto
Province en
Ontario
Province fr
Ontario
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2022
Competition year année de concours
2022
Award amount
33000
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
DISCOVERY RESEARCH
Group fr
RECHERCHE AXÉE SUR LA DÉCOUVERTE
Committee code
1503
Committee name en
Evolution and Ecology
Committee name fr
Évolution et écologie
Area of application code
1200
Area of application group en
Advancement of knowledge
Area of application group fr
Avancement des connaissances
Area of application en
Advancement of knowledge
Area of application fr
Avancement des connaissances
Research subject code
4700
Research subject group en
Evolution and ecology
Research subject group fr
Évolution et écologie
Research subject en
Evolution and ecology
Research subject fr
Évolution et écologie
Installment
inst:1
Partie
1
Nb partie
5
Application title
Expanding our horizons in understanding brain and dietary evolution in Primates and their kin
Application summary
The evolution of the diet is central to the process of primate origins. All of the competing scenarios for primate origins have a dietary component: visual predation focusing on adaptations for insectivory; terminal branch feeding involving an expansion of the arboreal dietary niche to include more fruit; and the grasp-leaping hypothesis, which incorporates a shift to greater herbivory in early primate evolution. Diet is of particular importance in understanding the evolution of the enlarged and complex primate brain. Building such a brain requires access to high energy food, while retrieving such broadly dispersed and irregularly available foodstuffs (e.g., fruit) requires greater degrees of processing power. Although analyses of modern primates have supported the important role of diet in brain evolution, they necessarily simplify the origin of primates down to a single node. The fossil record demonstrates that there were many lineages of stem primates, making it clear that the story is much more complex than the idealized version implied by such studies. Although there have been strides in recent years, there are still several lineages of early primates for which no quantitative work has been done to estimate aspects of diet. A critical component of this shortfall is that early primates have patterns of adaptations not found among living primates, meaning that living members of the order are insufficient models for reconstructing diet in those groups. The current study will seek to fill some of these gaps by considering a much broader range of model taxa and by using cutting edge dental topographic methods to allow for precise quantification of dental form. This study will also seek to expand the types of information that can be collected and compared with respect to the early evolution of the brain in primates. The strong evidence for rampant parallelism in primate brain size evolution implies that studies that are limited to living taxa will be constrained in reconstructing the size and shape of the brain in the common ancestor of all primates. This underscores the importance of fossils to an understanding of the early stages of primate brain evolution. Since the brain does not fossilize, the data available from even the best-preserved fossils is limited to the imprint of the brain preserved on the internal surface of the cranium (i.e., the endocast). The current study will seek to use geometric morphometric and DiceCT methods to expand the information about changing shape and function that can be extracted from such endocasts. Ultimately, the goal of this study will be to amass a dataset that will allow for a synthetic consideration of how shifting diets are aligned (or not) with changes in brain size and shape, using a phylogenetic framework that incorporates both fossil and extant members of Primates, and of closely related groups.