Canada Spends Logo

Explore our Budget 2026 analysis

Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual

University of Toronto

$28,000.00

Knowledge Networks For Decision Making in Infrastructure Asset Management

FY 2020-21

Summary
Managing our urban infrastructure systems decision making is increasingly becoming complex. A study found that in one municipality, the water management system spans 200 business processes. In Ontario, the cost of environmental assessment process rose 340% between 2010 and 2014. Average duration jumped from 19 to 27 months. According to one study, about 40% of expenditure in infrastructure construction can be saved if owners utilize advanced tools and deploy best practices. The goal of this proposal is to study, model and develop an environment for using social-semantic network analysis of project networks to infuse best practices in the decision making system. Project networks (PN) encompass the social networks of decision makers and citizens, networks of project documents, networks of physical project elements as represented in BIM (Building Information Modeling), their cost network (budget) and activity network (schedule). Students, through engagement in actual projects, will build at least 10 case studies. First, they will capture, through surveys, key attributes of each projectsuch as its actual social network of each (who communicates with who), decision paths, levels of actor influence. They will also collect (through Twitter interface) social media debates by citizens. Students will collect project documents, which form a semantic network of concepts. They will survey project teams to define top topics, performance levels, and the sentiment regarding both. Second, students will use relevant social and semantic network analysis algorithms to extract indicators for the same key attributes for each project. The two sets of key attributes (driven from surveys and from algorithms) will be compared, which can help define the suitability of social and semantic network analysis algorithms to the infrastructure domain. Through case studies and comparative analysis of surveys and algorithmic analysis students can develop models for: Formation of sub groups or what is known communities of interest: the aim is to contrast formal and informal decision paths. Opinion dynamics: to measure changes of stakeholders' (including local communities) position and sentiment regarding main project topics. Analysis of trust: monitor trust formation between major project players. Ontology for PN: enumerating appropriate algorithms and their potential usage in infrastructure systems. BIM dashboard: develop a portal to embed the results of PN analytics into the practice of project management. The contribution of this research work is full understating of PN and how to ingrain knowledge gained from their analysis into decision making cycles. This can help in 1) improve community engagement, 2) enhance decision making process, 3) reduce costs. All project participants can benefit from the resultsparticularly public officials and project decision makers as well as members of communities.
Program
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Location
Ontario, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data

As published

Application id
RGPIN-2017-06675
Name nom
El-Diraby, Tamer
Department département
Civil Engineering
Organization id
31
Institution établissement
University of Toronto
Province en
Ontario
Province fr
Ontario
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2020
Competition year année de concours
2017
Award amount
28000
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
Discovery grants programs
Group fr
Programmes de subventions à la découverte
Committee code
1509
Committee name en
Civil, Industrial and Systems Engineering
Committee name fr
Génie civil, industriel et des systèmes
Area of application code
603
Area of application group en
Construction, urban and rural planning
Area of application group fr
Construction, urbanisme et aménagement rural
Area of application en
Construction methods
Area of application fr
Méthodes de construction
Research subject code
1001
Research subject group en
Civil engineering
Research subject group fr
Génie civil
Research subject en
Construction engineering and management
Research subject fr
Génie et gestion du bâtiment
Installment
inst:4-5
Partie
2
Nb partie
5
Application title
Knowledge Networks For Decision Making in Infrastructure Asset Management
Keyword
NSERC
Application summary
Managing our urban infrastructure systems decision making is increasingly becoming complex. A study found that in one municipality, the water management system spans 200 business processes. In Ontario, the cost of environmental assessment process rose 340% between 2010 and 2014. Average duration jumped from 19 to 27 months. According to one study, about 40% of expenditure in infrastructure construction can be saved if owners utilize advanced tools and deploy best practices. The goal of this proposal is to study, model and develop an environment for using social-semantic network analysis of project networks to infuse best practices in the decision making system. Project networks (PN) encompass the social networks of decision makers and citizens, networks of project documents, networks of physical project elements as represented in BIM (Building Information Modeling), their cost network (budget) and activity network (schedule). Students, through engagement in actual projects, will build at least 10 case studies. First, they will capture, through surveys, key attributes of each projectsuch as its actual social network of each (who communicates with who), decision paths, levels of actor influence. They will also collect (through Twitter interface) social media debates by citizens. Students will collect project documents, which form a semantic network of concepts. They will survey project teams to define top topics, performance levels, and the sentiment regarding both. Second, students will use relevant social and semantic network analysis algorithms to extract indicators for the same key attributes for each project. The two sets of key attributes (driven from surveys and from algorithms) will be compared, which can help define the suitability of social and semantic network analysis algorithms to the infrastructure domain. Through case studies and comparative analysis of surveys and algorithmic analysis students can develop models for: Formation of sub groups or what is known communities of interest: the aim is to contrast formal and informal decision paths. Opinion dynamics: to measure changes of stakeholders' (including local communities) position and sentiment regarding main project topics. Analysis of trust: monitor trust formation between major project players. Ontology for PN: enumerating appropriate algorithms and their potential usage in infrastructure systems. BIM dashboard: develop a portal to embed the results of PN analytics into the practice of project management. The contribution of this research work is full understating of PN and how to ingrain knowledge gained from their analysis into decision making cycles. This can help in 1) improve community engagement, 2) enhance decision making process, 3) reduce costs. All project participants can benefit from the resultsparticularly public officials and project decision makers as well as members of communities.