Canada Spends Logo

Explore our Budget 2026 analysis

Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual

University of Ottawa

$22,000.00

Modeling and Optimization of Risk Measures

FY 2015-16

Summary
Stunning financial losses have been witnessed in recent years due to risk underestimation. The management of pension funds is one of the many examples, where the failure of measuring the actual risk involved has led to widespread economic instability. This raises a pressing need to design new risk measures that capture risk overlooked by existing measures. Off-the-shelf measures such as Value-at-Risk (VaR) generate numerical risk estimates by assuming that all uncertainty can be represented by a probability distribution, and the rest is just a statistical exercise. The real world however, as evidenced by the 2008 financial crisis, is far more uncertain than what a distribution can describe. This multifaceted uncertainty has now gradually learned by decision makers, but a risk measure that embodies this knowledge is still lacking. More sophisticated measures have been proposed lately. In the area of Robust Optimization (RO), a series of works have been done to design robust measures that allow the use of multiple distributions to describe uncertainty. Meanwhile, in Risk Analysis, axioms have been introduced that define the properties of ideal risk measures. While these works provide a whole new spectrum of measures, they leave the following question open: Which one of them accounts precisely for the actual uncertainty and risk facing decision makers? Modern risk analysis theory does not provide a definite answer to this - largely because there is no single measure that can fit all situations. Decision makers from different sectors or industries can have different perspectives of risk, depending on the nature of the work undertaken. Current models of risk measures provide only narrow views of risk and are not amenable to incorporating decision makers' knowledge of risk. This gap between what current models offer and what decision makers need to measure is one of the greatest impediments toward the widespread deployment of risk measures. The goal of this research program is to close the gap by developing a new interactive scheme that allows decision makers' knowledge of risk to be explored and incorporated into the design of risk measures. This scheme shares the same spirit as Interactive Optimization (IO), where the solution procedure involves user input in seeking preferable solutions. Important research questions to ask while developing this scheme include: - How should we interact with users to best elicit their knowledge of risk? - How can this information be incorporated into the design of risk measures? - How can we provide guarantees on the quality of risk estimates even if only limited resource is available for elicitation? - How can we ensure, given enough resource for elicitation, that the resulting risk measure converges to the one that best represents a user's knowledge of risk? - How can the resulting measures be integrated into a decision optimization process? Our methodology will be developed based on three streams of research: Robust Optimization, axiomatic approaches in Risk Analysis, and Interactive Optimization, which if successfully developed will also provide theoretical evidence of how these approaches can be integrated in the context of risk analytics. The end result of this research program will be a new decision support system that enables decision makers to model their knowledge of risk and to minimize them. The system will be validated using case studies from the sectors of finance, energy, and health care. This will bridge the gap between theory and practice in risk analytics, and encourage practitioners to approach risk management problems analytically, which is critically important in today's ever-changing environment.
Program
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Location
Ontario, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data

As published

Application id
RGPIN-2014-05602
Name nom
Li, Jonathan
Department département
Telfer School of Management
Organization id
28
Institution établissement
University of Ottawa
Province en
Ontario
Province fr
Ontario
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2015
Competition year année de concours
2014
Award amount
22000
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
Discovery grants programs
Group fr
Programmes de subventions à la découverte
Committee code
1509
Committee name en
Civil, Industrial and Systems Engineering
Committee name fr
Génie civil, industriel et des systèmes
Area of application code
405
Area of application group en
Environment
Area of application group fr
Environnement
Area of application en
Modelling and mathematical simulation of natural processes
Area of application fr
Modélisation et simulation mathématique des processus naturels
Research subject code
1601
Research subject group en
Industrial engineering
Research subject group fr
Génie industriel
Research subject en
Operations research and management science
Research subject fr
Recherche opérationnelle et science de la gestion
Partie
2
Nb partie
5
Application title
Modeling and Optimization of Risk Measures
Keyword
NSERC
Application summary
Stunning financial losses have been witnessed in recent years due to risk underestimation. The management of pension funds is one of the many examples, where the failure of measuring the actual risk involved has led to widespread economic instability. This raises a pressing need to design new risk measures that capture risk overlooked by existing measures. Off-the-shelf measures such as Value-at-Risk (VaR) generate numerical risk estimates by assuming that all uncertainty can be represented by a probability distribution, and the rest is just a statistical exercise. The real world however, as evidenced by the 2008 financial crisis, is far more uncertain than what a distribution can describe. This multifaceted uncertainty has now gradually learned by decision makers, but a risk measure that embodies this knowledge is still lacking. More sophisticated measures have been proposed lately. In the area of Robust Optimization (RO), a series of works have been done to design robust measures that allow the use of multiple distributions to describe uncertainty. Meanwhile, in Risk Analysis, axioms have been introduced that define the properties of ideal risk measures. While these works provide a whole new spectrum of measures, they leave the following question open: Which one of them accounts precisely for the actual uncertainty and risk facing decision makers? Modern risk analysis theory does not provide a definite answer to this - largely because there is no single measure that can fit all situations. Decision makers from different sectors or industries can have different perspectives of risk, depending on the nature of the work undertaken. Current models of risk measures provide only narrow views of risk and are not amenable to incorporating decision makers' knowledge of risk. This gap between what current models offer and what decision makers need to measure is one of the greatest impediments toward the widespread deployment of risk measures. The goal of this research program is to close the gap by developing a new interactive scheme that allows decision makers' knowledge of risk to be explored and incorporated into the design of risk measures. This scheme shares the same spirit as Interactive Optimization (IO), where the solution procedure involves user input in seeking preferable solutions. Important research questions to ask while developing this scheme include: - How should we interact with users to best elicit their knowledge of risk? - How can this information be incorporated into the design of risk measures? - How can we provide guarantees on the quality of risk estimates even if only limited resource is available for elicitation? - How can we ensure, given enough resource for elicitation, that the resulting risk measure converges to the one that best represents a user's knowledge of risk? - How can the resulting measures be integrated into a decision optimization process? Our methodology will be developed based on three streams of research: Robust Optimization, axiomatic approaches in Risk Analysis, and Interactive Optimization, which if successfully developed will also provide theoretical evidence of how these approaches can be integrated in the context of risk analytics. The end result of this research program will be a new decision support system that enables decision makers to model their knowledge of risk and to minimize them. The system will be validated using case studies from the sectors of finance, energy, and health care. This will bridge the gap between theory and practice in risk analytics, and encourage practitioners to approach risk management problems analytically, which is critically important in today's ever-changing environment.