Grant: Engage Grants Program
Centre de recherche informatique de Montréal
$25,000.00
Test categorization for the automatic discovery of valuable comments to be shared among a community of medical practitioners
FY 2012-13
Summary
MD Physician Services Inc. (MDPS), delivers by email, synopses of clinical research called InfoPOEMs?. To
transform simple reading of the InfoPOEMs? into an actual learning experience, research in education states
the importance of having the reader(learner) reflect on the value of his reading by answering some questions.
While questions on the content only test short-term memory, questions on the value of the information for
clinical practice can stimulate reflective learning.
Researchers at McGill developed the Information Assessment Method (IAM), an individual brief reflective
e-learning activity specifically geared toward the continuing education of health professionals. Since 2006,
MDPS includes the IAM method with the InfoPOEMs? delivered.
Collaborative environments (Web 2.0) show how individual knowledge can benefit other members of a
community. MDPS has already implemented a mechanism for finding the ""views of others"" by gathering
statistics on the InfoPOEMS rated by the readers. MDPS posts on CMA (Canadian Medical Association)
website evaluations of specific InfoPOEM using a ""thumbs up or thumbs down"" graphic.
MDPS wishes to move toward the sharing of textual comments from physician raters, but this requires a
more complex analysis than computing statistics. MDPS does not have the human resources for reading,
gathering and digesting such comments to give back to their members. This proposal suggest that human
resources could be, to some extent, simulated by automatic text categorization. This research project is to
develop a method, based on a supervised machine learning approach, which could learn to categorize valuable
from non-valuable comments from a subset of comments annotated by medical practitioners, and then infer the
categories of future comments. As we anticipate this to be a difficult task, confidence estimation must be
included to allow MDPS to share the comments that the automatic method would categorize as valuable with a
high enough confidence.
Program
Engage Grants Program
Location
Quebec, Canada
Recipient Type
Not-for-profit organization or charity
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data
As published
Application id
431186-2012
Name nom
Barrière, Caroline
Department département
Recherche et Développement
Organization id
71
Institution établissement
Centre de recherche informatique de Montréal
Province en
Québec
Province fr
Québec
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2012
Competition year année de concours
2012
Award amount
25000
Program id
EGP
Program name en
Engage Grants Program
Program name fr
Programme de subventions d'engagement partenariat
Group en
Research partnerships programs
Group fr
Programmes de partenariat
Committee code
1552
Committee name en
Quebec Internal Decision Committee
Committee name fr
Comité de décision interne pour le Québec
Area of application code
802
Area of application group en
Information and communication services
Area of application group fr
Services d'information et de télécommunications
Area of application en
Information systems and technology
Area of application fr
Systèmes d'information et technologie de l'information
Research subject code
2805
Research subject group en
Artificial intelligence
Research subject group fr
Intelligence artificielle
Research subject en
Learning and inference theories
Research subject fr
Théories de l'apprentissage et l'inférence
Partie
1
Nb partie
1
Application title
Test categorization for the automatic discovery of valuable comments to be shared among a community of medical practitioners
Keyword
NSERC
Application summary
MD Physician Services Inc. (MDPS), delivers by email, synopses of clinical research called InfoPOEMs?. To
transform simple reading of the InfoPOEMs? into an actual learning experience, research in education states
the importance of having the reader(learner) reflect on the value of his reading by answering some questions.
While questions on the content only test short-term memory, questions on the value of the information for
clinical practice can stimulate reflective learning.
Researchers at McGill developed the Information Assessment Method (IAM), an individual brief reflective
e-learning activity specifically geared toward the continuing education of health professionals. Since 2006,
MDPS includes the IAM method with the InfoPOEMs? delivered.
Collaborative environments (Web 2.0) show how individual knowledge can benefit other members of a
community. MDPS has already implemented a mechanism for finding the ""views of others"" by gathering
statistics on the InfoPOEMS rated by the readers. MDPS posts on CMA (Canadian Medical Association)
website evaluations of specific InfoPOEM using a ""thumbs up or thumbs down"" graphic.
MDPS wishes to move toward the sharing of textual comments from physician raters, but this requires a
more complex analysis than computing statistics. MDPS does not have the human resources for reading,
gathering and digesting such comments to give back to their members. This proposal suggest that human
resources could be, to some extent, simulated by automatic text categorization. This research project is to
develop a method, based on a supervised machine learning approach, which could learn to categorize valuable
from non-valuable comments from a subset of comments annotated by medical practitioners, and then infer the
categories of future comments. As we anticipate this to be a difficult task, confidence estimation must be
included to allow MDPS to share the comments that the automatic method would categorize as valuable with a
high enough confidence.