Canada Spends Logo

Explore our Budget 2026 analysis

Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual

University of Toronto

$62,000.00

Nonlinear Assessment and Optimization Methods for Concrete Structures

FY 2022-23

Summary
The current practice of Canadian structural engineering is based on traditional analysis methods that go back many years and have shown themselves to be safe, economical and efficient. At the same time there are analysis and design methods in Canadian and International Universities that go well beyond this level of understanding and allow structures to be designed and built which have a series of advantages: a) improved safety against unexpected events such as earthquakes, b) lower overall cost for the same, or higher, level of safety, and c) higher efficiency in terms of lower consumption of energy-intensive construction materials. The problem with these advanced methods is that they tend to be slow to operate and complex to use.Over the past decades, there has also been a dramatic increase in computer power and structural engineers are not yet using that in the most efficient way possible. Indeed we are now at the state where it is possible to achieve some of the goals in the first paragraph with computers doing the optimization process "by themselves" with the engineer merely watching the computer act. This form of unguided optimization is of a concern from the perspective of generation of understanding for engineers but it hasn't generally been a problem yet as the analysis tools are often too complex to be used with optimization methods anyway. Given that such tools are now possible, however, there is a research need to develop optimization methods which include the engineer as a fundamental part of the process.To achieve design optimization of this type, it is necessary that the faster methods of analysis be extended to 3D. In my previous NSERC Discovery grant I planned to generate efficient 2D methods of analysis that more accurately can predict building behaviour accounting for the nonlinear aspects of cracking, yielding and crushing of the concrete. This has now been achieved and it is now possible to extend this to 3D models of buildings with slabs and walls. This type of modelling will allow optimization of 3D buildings to go ahead reasonably efficiently While using computers to optimize designs will allow more efficient structures to be designed, it will also be necessary to develop the optimization process in a way that increases the engineer's understanding of the problems rather than decreasing it as "blind" optimization could do. Thus it will be a key component of the proposed guided optimization that human beings remain part of the design process as the skills generated from that are what are needed to diagnose problems in buildings and come up with truly new design options for the future. That is: the design process must itself be designed to ensure that Canadian engineers remain at the forefront of methods and technologies used around the world.
Program
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Location
Ontario, Canada
Recipient Type
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data

As published

Application id
RGPIN-2018-05643
Name nom
Bentz, Evan
Department département
Civil Engineering - Civil Engineering
Organization id
31
Institution établissement
University of Toronto
Province en
Ontario
Province fr
Ontario
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2022
Competition year année de concours
2018
Award amount
62000
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
DISCOVERY RESEARCH
Group fr
RECHERCHE AXÉE SUR LA DÉCOUVERTE
Committee code
1509
Committee name en
Civil, Industrial and Systems Engineering
Committee name fr
Génie civil, industriel et des systèmes
Area of application code
601
Area of application group en
Construction, urban and rural planning
Area of application group fr
Construction, urbanisme et aménagement rural
Area of application en
Structural engineering
Area of application fr
Génie des charpentes
Research subject code
1100
Research subject group en
Structural engineering
Research subject group fr
Génie des structures
Research subject en
Structural engineering
Research subject fr
Génie des structures
Installment
inst:5;6
Partie
2
Nb partie
6
Application title
Nonlinear Assessment and Optimization Methods for Concrete Structures
Application summary
The current practice of Canadian structural engineering is based on traditional analysis methods that go back many years and have shown themselves to be safe, economical and efficient. At the same time there are analysis and design methods in Canadian and International Universities that go well beyond this level of understanding and allow structures to be designed and built which have a series of advantages: a) improved safety against unexpected events such as earthquakes, b) lower overall cost for the same, or higher, level of safety, and c) higher efficiency in terms of lower consumption of energy-intensive construction materials. The problem with these advanced methods is that they tend to be slow to operate and complex to use.Over the past decades, there has also been a dramatic increase in computer power and structural engineers are not yet using that in the most efficient way possible. Indeed we are now at the state where it is possible to achieve some of the goals in the first paragraph with computers doing the optimization process "by themselves" with the engineer merely watching the computer act. This form of unguided optimization is of a concern from the perspective of generation of understanding for engineers but it hasn't generally been a problem yet as the analysis tools are often too complex to be used with optimization methods anyway. Given that such tools are now possible, however, there is a research need to develop optimization methods which include the engineer as a fundamental part of the process.To achieve design optimization of this type, it is necessary that the faster methods of analysis be extended to 3D. In my previous NSERC Discovery grant I planned to generate efficient 2D methods of analysis that more accurately can predict building behaviour accounting for the nonlinear aspects of cracking, yielding and crushing of the concrete. This has now been achieved and it is now possible to extend this to 3D models of buildings with slabs and walls. This type of modelling will allow optimization of 3D buildings to go ahead reasonably efficiently While using computers to optimize designs will allow more efficient structures to be designed, it will also be necessary to develop the optimization process in a way that increases the engineer's understanding of the problems rather than decreasing it as "blind" optimization could do. Thus it will be a key component of the proposed guided optimization that human beings remain part of the design process as the skills generated from that are what are needed to diagnose problems in buildings and come up with truly new design options for the future. That is: the design process must itself be designed to ensure that Canadian engineers remain at the forefront of methods and technologies used around the world.