Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Dalhousie University
$40,000.00
Adaptive evolution across multi-scale biological systems: finding a bridge between molecular evolution and multi-species dynamics.
EF 2023-24
Résumé
Genes exist within species, species exist within communities, and communities exist within ecosystems. Consider the emergent complexity of a multi-species community; it is a self-organizing system shaped by the combined activities of its species, with the information required for those activities stored at "lower levels" within genes. The biological activities occurring inside of the species, or the community, can manifest externally (e.g., changing the ecosystem), and thereby influence the properties and dynamics of the community itself. The key insight here is that the fitness landscape that genes "perceive" cannot be independent of how those genes affect higher levels of complexity. Therefore a complex biological system (e.g., a community) can develop a complex network of causal interactions over evolutionary time, with feedback between levels (e.g., genes, species and community) influencing each gene's adaptive landscape. However, the classical account of adaptive gene evolution, as embodied by neo-Darwinian theory, is reductionist and largely assumes unidirectional causal pathways. Thus, the classical approach has struggled to provide a full account of how evolution can establish and fine-tune links within multi-scale biological systems. Such multi-level causality motivated the highly-regarded philosopher of biology, Evelyn Fox Keller, to question the way biologists use the concept of "the gene for." to explain complex biological systems. If Evelyn Fox Keller is correct, then fundamental questions about the origin and evolution of complexity cannot be solved if we persist in pursuing purely reductive explanations. Indeed, Keller has recently called on biologists to adapt their analysis and modelling techniques to address multi-scale systems, and to consider a "pluralistic mosaic" of different strategies. The proposed research program is a response to Keller's call from my perspective as an evolutionary biologist. Fundamental questions about biological complexity, such as those surrounding adaptive evolution across multi-scale systems, have fallen through the cracks of investigation because they lie on the boundary of two or more fields. The traditional approach to adaptive gene evolution is firmly rooted in population genetic theory and, while necessary, its scope is limited by a highly reductive view of adaptive landscapes. A complete understanding of adaptive evolution will require us to consider (i) the effect of multi-scale dynamics (e.g., multi-gene and multi-species interactions) on adaptive landscapes, (ii) a de-centralized mapping of genotype and phenotype, and (iii) multiple fields of biology. Because we are asking new questions, we will need to develop new research tools. Hence, this project seeks to develop theory and methods appropriate for understanding adaptive dynamics of genes (and genomes) across multi-scale biological systems. Trainees will acquire data science and genomics skills suitable to a broad the range of careers.
Programme
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Bénéficiaire
Emplacement
Nova Scotia, Canada
Type de bénéficiaire
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data
Tel que publié
Application id
RGPIN-2020-04109
Name nom
Bielawski, Joseph
Department département
Biology - Biology
Organization id
79
Institution établissement
Dalhousie University
Province en
Nova Scotia
Province fr
Nouvelle-Écosse
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2023
Competition year année de concours
2020
Award amount
40000
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
DISCOVERY RESEARCH
Group fr
RECHERCHE AXÉE SUR LA DÉCOUVERTE
Committee code
1503
Committee name en
Evolution and Ecology
Committee name fr
Évolution et écologie
Area of application code
1200
Area of application group en
Advancement of knowledge
Area of application group fr
Avancement des connaissances
Area of application en
Advancement of knowledge
Area of application fr
Avancement des connaissances
Research subject code
5005
Research subject group en
Genetics
Research subject group fr
Evolutionary genetics
Research subject en
Génétique
Research subject fr
Génétique évolutive
Application title
Adaptive evolution across multi-scale biological systems: finding a bridge between molecular evolution and multi-species dynamics.
Keyword
adaptive landscape; codon models; community interactions; gene and genome evolution; hierarchical biological systems; metabolic networks; metagenomes; microbial nutrient cycling; simulation; theory and modelling
Application summary
Genes exist within species, species exist within communities, and communities exist within ecosystems. Consider the emergent complexity of a multi-species community; it is a self-organizing system shaped by the combined activities of its species, with the information required for those activities stored at "lower levels" within genes. The biological activities occurring inside of the species, or the community, can manifest externally (e.g., changing the ecosystem), and thereby influence the properties and dynamics of the community itself. The key insight here is that the fitness landscape that genes "perceive" cannot be independent of how those genes affect higher levels of complexity. Therefore a complex biological system (e.g., a community) can develop a complex network of causal interactions over evolutionary time, with feedback between levels (e.g., genes, species and community) influencing each gene's adaptive landscape. However, the classical account of adaptive gene evolution, as embodied by neo-Darwinian theory, is reductionist and largely assumes unidirectional causal pathways. Thus, the classical approach has struggled to provide a full account of how evolution can establish and fine-tune links within multi-scale biological systems. Such multi-level causality motivated the highly-regarded philosopher of biology, Evelyn Fox Keller, to question the way biologists use the concept of "the gene for." to explain complex biological systems. If Evelyn Fox Keller is correct, then fundamental questions about the origin and evolution of complexity cannot be solved if we persist in pursuing purely reductive explanations. Indeed, Keller has recently called on biologists to adapt their analysis and modelling techniques to address multi-scale systems, and to consider a "pluralistic mosaic" of different strategies. The proposed research program is a response to Keller's call from my perspective as an evolutionary biologist. Fundamental questions about biological complexity, such as those surrounding adaptive evolution across multi-scale systems, have fallen through the cracks of investigation because they lie on the boundary of two or more fields. The traditional approach to adaptive gene evolution is firmly rooted in population genetic theory and, while necessary, its scope is limited by a highly reductive view of adaptive landscapes. A complete understanding of adaptive evolution will require us to consider (i) the effect of multi-scale dynamics (e.g., multi-gene and multi-species interactions) on adaptive landscapes, (ii) a de-centralized mapping of genotype and phenotype, and (iii) multiple fields of biology. Because we are asking new questions, we will need to develop new research tools. Hence, this project seeks to develop theory and methods appropriate for understanding adaptive dynamics of genes (and genomes) across multi-scale biological systems. Trainees will acquire data science and genomics skills suitable to a broad the range of careers.