Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual
McMaster University
$26,000.00
Uncertainty and Calibration of the Security Motivation System
EF 2014-15
Résumé
In their natural environments, organisms must be able to cope with the possibility of events that occur relatively rarely and can be anticipated only with considerable uncertainty, but nonetheless have serious potential consequences, including death. These potential threats include, for example, the possibility that a predator may be near or that contagion may take place. Because such potential dangers are typically not yet openly present (such as a predator) or hidden (such as germs), the organism must rely on relatively subtle and indirect cues to detect them. In addition, because the cost of error in responding to potential dangers is severe, including injury or death, these events allow for only limited learning through the experience of natural consequences. Thus, the organism must rely on robust precautionary responses, including probing the environment for information, such as checking for further signs, or taking action that would ameliorate the effect of a potential danger, such as washing. Indeed, the underlying mechanisms that mediate responses to potential threats may be reasonably distinct from the mechanisms that govern other kinds of behavior. Because potential dangers have very substantial consequences for reproductive fitness, it is likely that evolution shaped brain systems particularly adapted for managing them. Along these lines, several researchers (including us) have posited the existence of a special motivation system, a dedicated module in the brain that evolved to manage the adaptive challenges of potential threats such as predation and disease. We have entitled it the ?security motivation system? (Szechtman & Woody, 2004). Proposed studies The security motivation system (SMS) addresses uncertain indicators of possible upcoming danger. This requires quite different operations from the actual presence of danger. Immediate danger requires actions guided to a large extent by the attributes of the physical threat and environment; e.g., sudden flight if the predator is far enough away. However, potential threat requires protracted precautionary and probing behavior but the environment provides minimal or no guidance as to the amount or the specific form of it. The present proposal will investigate how the SMS is calibrated and in particular how early life events set and bias the parameters of SMS activation towards the potential threats encountered at start of life. The major hypothesis is: early life experience with a specific danger biases security motivation of the adult towards such particular type of potential threats. To investigate this hypothesis a ?double dissociation? kind of paradigm will be employed, given that there exist distinct domains of potential threat to which security motivation responds (contagion-contamination, predation, food scarcity, unstable environment, and social status threat). Study design will include two separate domains of potential threat, where the expected selectivity in the calibration of security motivation would be evidenced by observing effects in the manipulated domain but not in another domain; for instance, manipulation in the contagion-contamination domain should have security-related effects in this domain but little security motivation effects in, say, the predation domain, and vice versa for manipulation in the other (here, predation) domain.
Programme
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Bénéficiaire
Emplacement
Ontario, Canada
Type de bénéficiaire
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data
Tel que publié
Application id
RGPIN-2014-05587
Name nom
Szechtman, Henry
Department département
Psychiatry & Behav Neurosc
Organization id
27
Institution établissement
McMaster University
Province en
Ontario
Province fr
Ontario
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2014
Competition year année de concours
2014
Award amount
26000
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
Discovery grants programs
Group fr
Programmes de subventions à la découverte
Committee code
1502
Committee name en
Biological Systems and Functions
Committee name fr
Systèmes et fonctions biologiques
Area of application code
1210
Area of application group en
Advancement of knowledge
Area of application group fr
Avancement des connaissances
Area of application en
Psychology
Area of application fr
Psychologie
Research subject code
6308
Research subject group en
Psychology
Research subject group fr
Psychologie
Research subject en
Behavioural neuroscience
Research subject fr
Neurologie du comportement
Partie
1
Nb partie
1
Application title
Uncertainty and Calibration of the Security Motivation System
Keyword
NSERC
Application summary
In their natural environments, organisms must be able to cope with the possibility of events that occur relatively rarely and can be anticipated only with considerable uncertainty, but nonetheless have serious potential consequences, including death. These potential threats include, for example, the possibility that a predator may be near or that contagion may take place. Because such potential dangers are typically not yet openly present (such as a predator) or hidden (such as germs), the organism must rely on relatively subtle and indirect cues to detect them. In addition, because the cost of error in responding to potential dangers is severe, including injury or death, these events allow for only limited learning through the experience of natural consequences. Thus, the organism must rely on robust precautionary responses, including probing the environment for information, such as checking for further signs, or taking action that would ameliorate the effect of a potential danger, such as washing. Indeed, the underlying mechanisms that mediate responses to potential threats may be reasonably distinct from the mechanisms that govern other kinds of behavior. Because potential dangers have very substantial consequences for reproductive fitness, it is likely that evolution shaped brain systems particularly adapted for managing them. Along these lines, several researchers (including us) have posited the existence of a special motivation system, a dedicated module in the brain that evolved to manage the adaptive challenges of potential threats such as predation and disease. We have entitled it the ?security motivation system? (Szechtman & Woody, 2004). Proposed studies The security motivation system (SMS) addresses uncertain indicators of possible upcoming danger. This requires quite different operations from the actual presence of danger. Immediate danger requires actions guided to a large extent by the attributes of the physical threat and environment; e.g., sudden flight if the predator is far enough away. However, potential threat requires protracted precautionary and probing behavior but the environment provides minimal or no guidance as to the amount or the specific form of it. The present proposal will investigate how the SMS is calibrated and in particular how early life events set and bias the parameters of SMS activation towards the potential threats encountered at start of life. The major hypothesis is: early life experience with a specific danger biases security motivation of the adult towards such particular type of potential threats. To investigate this hypothesis a ?double dissociation? kind of paradigm will be employed, given that there exist distinct domains of potential threat to which security motivation responds (contagion-contamination, predation, food scarcity, unstable environment, and social status threat). Study design will include two separate domains of potential threat, where the expected selectivity in the calibration of security motivation would be evidenced by observing effects in the manipulated domain but not in another domain; for instance, manipulation in the contagion-contamination domain should have security-related effects in this domain but little security motivation effects in, say, the predation domain, and vice versa for manipulation in the other (here, predation) domain.