Canada Spends Logo

Explorez notre analyse du budget 2026

Grant: Knowledge Synthesis Grant

University of Ottawa

$100,000.00

A critical interpretive synthesis of recommendations for De-intensification and de-IMPLEmentation from population Screening (DIMPLES).

EF 2014-15

Résumé
What factors influence decisions to recommend disinvestment from screening programs, even in the face of controversy, or when other programs continue to proceed or expand? Addressing this question is consistent with recent calls for research to better understand the elements that facilitate or hinder the withdrawal of health technologies and a need to elucidate decision-making processes around population screening. This includes assessing the socio-ethical issues that inform decision making: disinvestment decisions include strong ethical foundations based on nonmaleficence, promoting beneficence, or the just use of scare healthcare resources. The extent to which particular ethical issues influence evidence evaluation and decision making has not been explored in the context of decisions to disinvest from screening. The goal of this review is to conduct a critical interpretive synthesis (CIS) to better understand the stated rationales for disinvestment from established population screening programs. In doing so we will: 1. Identify examples of population screening programs recommended for disinvestment and describe their characteristics 2. Generate a matrix of factors associated with recommendations to disinvest from existing screening programs and compare these with established criteria for the implementation of population screening 3. Elicit the implicit values which underpin disinvestment recommendations. 4. Generate a categorization framework of disinvestment decision types. To address these questions we have engaged institutional knowledge users identified as key stakeholders within population screening in Canada and brought together an international team of experts in synthesis methods, population screening, health policy, and public health ethics. These include the creators of Health Systems Evidence, the world’s most comprehensive, free access point for high-quality evidence about how to strengthen or reform health systems, a Tier 1 Canada Research Chair in Health Knowledge Transfer and Uptake, a Professor and Canada Research Chair in Human Genome Epidemiology and members provincial screening committees and international bodies that oversee screening policy decisions. Our approach, a Critical Interpretive Synthesis, will combine a traditional bibliographic search with an extensive assessment of the grey literature in which the goal is both to synthesise the existing body of evidence, but also to generate theory. Our synthesis will include both within, and cross case analyses, and will follow a strategy similar to that undertaken in primary qualitative research. As such, data will be analysed, coded and labeled in an inductive manner using the constant comparative method. The main output of this project will be an explanatory framework regarding disinvestment from screening programs, consisting of a matrix of influential factors within existing decisions, the values (implicit and explicit) that underpin these decisions, and a categorization framework of decision-types for classifying de-intensification or de-implementation decisions. As part of this process, we will convene a full-day workshop with key stakeholders with the aim of soliciting targeted feedback about the framework.
Programme
Knowledge Synthesis Grant
Bénéficiaire
Emplacement
Ontario, Canada
Type de bénéficiaire
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
CIHR Funding Decisions Database

Tel que publié

Id
319541
Name
Little Julian
Region
Ontario
Country
Canada
Orgtype
Institution Paid; Research Institution
Instname2
Health Services and Policy Research
Theme2
Health systems / services
Prcname2
Knowledge Synthesis Grant
Projecttitle
A critical interpretive synthesis of recommendations for De-intensification and de-IMPLEmentation from population Screening (DIMPLES).
Programtype2
Operating Grants
Orgnameinp2
University of Ottawa
Cihramount2
$100,000
Cihrequipment2
$0
Programname2
Knowledge Synthesis Grant
Keyworddelim
Decision Making; Disinvestment; Health Policy; Public Health Ethics; Screening
Abstract
<html> <body> <b>What factors influence decisions to recommend disinvestment from screening programs, even in the face of controversy, or when other programs continue to proceed or expand?</b> Addressing this question is consistent with recent calls for research to better understand the elements that facilitate or hinder the withdrawal of health technologies and a need to elucidate decision-making processes around population screening. This includes assessing the socio-ethical issues that inform decision making: disinvestment decisions include strong ethical foundations based on nonmaleficence, promoting beneficence, or the just use of scare healthcare resources. The extent to which particular ethical issues influence evidence evaluation and decision making has not been explored in the context of decisions to disinvest from screening. <br> <br> The <b>goal</b> of this review is to conduct a <b>critical interpretive synthesis</b> (CIS) to better understand the stated rationales for disinvestment from established population screening programs. In doing so we will:<br> 1. Identify <b>examples of population screening programs</b> recommended for disinvestment and describe their characteristics <br> 2. Generate a <b>matrix of factors associated with recommendations to disinvest</b> from existing screening programs and <b>compare these with established criteria for the implementation</b> of population screening<br> 3. Elicit the implicit <b>values which underpin disinvestment recommendations</b>. <br> 4. Generate a <b>categorization framework of disinvestment decision types</b>.<br> <br> To address these questions we have engaged institutional knowledge users identified as key stakeholders within population screening in Canada and brought together an international team of experts in synthesis methods, population screening, health policy, and public health ethics. These include the creators of Health Systems Evidence, the world&rsquo;s most comprehensive, free access point for high-quality evidence about how to strengthen or reform health systems, a Tier 1 Canada Research Chair in Health Knowledge Transfer and Uptake, a Professor and Canada Research Chair in Human Genome Epidemiology and members provincial screening committees and international bodies that oversee screening policy decisions. <br> <br> Our approach, a Critical Interpretive Synthesis, will combine a traditional bibliographic search with an extensive assessment of the grey literature in which the goal is both to synthesise the existing body of evidence, but also to generate theory. Our synthesis will include both within, and cross case analyses, and will follow a strategy similar to that undertaken in primary qualitative research. As such, data will be analysed, coded and labeled in an inductive manner using the constant comparative method. <br> The main output of this project will be an <b>explanatory framework regarding disinvestment from screening programs</b>, consisting of a matrix of influential factors within existing decisions, the values (implicit and explicit) that underpin these decisions, and a categorization framework of decision-types for classifying de-intensification or de-implementation decisions. As part of this process, we will <b>convene a full-day workshop</b> with key stakeholders with the aim of soliciting targeted feedback about the framework.</body> </html>
Competitiondate
201411
Approvedterm2
1 yr 0 mth
Pinamesdelim
Clifford, Tammy J; Little, Julian
Approvedterm
1 an 0 mois
Cihrcontribution2
~ $100,000~ $0~