Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual
University of Waterloo
$33,000.00
Simulator Wear Testing Protocols to Avoid Clinical Disaster
EF 2012-13
Résumé
| The ASR (articular surface replacement) systems made by DePuy Orthopaedics are metal-on-metal (MM) hip implants that consist of a thin-walled cup with a porous coated back surface for bone ingrowth. The cup articulates with a large diameter head that is directly attached to the femur (thigh bone) as a resurfacing component or taper locked to a stem that is attached to the femur. The ASR implant systems were used on 93,000 patients worldwide and the failure level at 5 years has exceeded 10% and is climbing higher as more early failures are being reported. The failure level for other similar MM hip implants at 5 years is about 1% and thus DePuy has recalled the ASR. This is perhaps the most extensive orthopaedic implant disaster in history and seems to be a consequence of excessive wear at the contacting metal surfaces of the implant.
The present author performed the first wear simulator testing of modern small diameter MM hip implants in North America starting in 1994. Testing of this kind helped such small diameter implants achieve clinical success. The move to larger diameter implants, like the ASR, was intended to benefit patients by reducing the risk of dislocation and providing them with the option of a less invasive ""resurfacing"" of diseased or damaged hip joints.
The proposed research intends to find the specific cause(s) of the excessive MM wear of the ASR through a series of simulator testing experiments supported by advanced analytical techniques. This will provide valuable insight into improving the designs of MM hip implants. To prevent future large-scale recalls, the proposed research will develop methods to generate MM hip testing protocols that encompass a ""worst-case scenario"" philosophy rather than the ""testing under ideal conditions"" approach that is now imposed by the standards organizations and required by the regulatory bodies. If successful, the proposed research will specify improved MM hip implant designs and changes to the approval process that will help prevent future clinical disasters. |
Programme
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Bénéficiaire
Emplacement
Ontario, Canada
Type de bénéficiaire
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data
Tel que publié
Application id
1660-2012
Name nom
Medley, John
Department département
Mechanical Engineering and Mechatronics
Organization id
33
Institution établissement
University of Waterloo
Province en
Ontario
Province fr
Ontario
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2012
Competition year année de concours
2012
Award amount
33000
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
Discovery grants programs
Group fr
Programmes de subventions à la découverte
Committee code
1512
Committee name en
Mechanical Engineering
Committee name fr
Génie mécanique
Area of application code
1102
Area of application group en
Health, education and social services
Area of application group fr
Santé publique, éducation et services sociaux
Area of application en
Biomedical engineering
Area of application fr
Génie biomédical
Research subject code
1900
Research subject group en
Biomedical engineering
Research subject group fr
Génie biomédical
Research subject en
Biomedical engineering
Research subject fr
Génie biomédical
Partie
1
Nb partie
1
Application title
Simulator Wear Testing Protocols to Avoid Clinical Disaster
Keyword
NSERC
Application summary
| The ASR (articular surface replacement) systems made by DePuy Orthopaedics are metal-on-metal (MM) hip implants that consist of a thin-walled cup with a porous coated back surface for bone ingrowth. The cup articulates with a large diameter head that is directly attached to the femur (thigh bone) as a resurfacing component or taper locked to a stem that is attached to the femur. The ASR implant systems were used on 93,000 patients worldwide and the failure level at 5 years has exceeded 10% and is climbing higher as more early failures are being reported. The failure level for other similar MM hip implants at 5 years is about 1% and thus DePuy has recalled the ASR. This is perhaps the most extensive orthopaedic implant disaster in history and seems to be a consequence of excessive wear at the contacting metal surfaces of the implant.
The present author performed the first wear simulator testing of modern small diameter MM hip implants in North America starting in 1994. Testing of this kind helped such small diameter implants achieve clinical success. The move to larger diameter implants, like the ASR, was intended to benefit patients by reducing the risk of dislocation and providing them with the option of a less invasive ""resurfacing"" of diseased or damaged hip joints.
The proposed research intends to find the specific cause(s) of the excessive MM wear of the ASR through a series of simulator testing experiments supported by advanced analytical techniques. This will provide valuable insight into improving the designs of MM hip implants. To prevent future large-scale recalls, the proposed research will develop methods to generate MM hip testing protocols that encompass a ""worst-case scenario"" philosophy rather than the ""testing under ideal conditions"" approach that is now imposed by the standards organizations and required by the regulatory bodies. If successful, the proposed research will specify improved MM hip implant designs and changes to the approval process that will help prevent future clinical disasters. |