Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual
University of Guelph
$41,480.00
Developmental issues in animals' responses to captive husbandry: the causation of stereotypic behaviour
EF 2007-08
Résumé
Worldwide, over 85 million farm, laboratory, pet and zoo animals show stereotypic behaviours: repetitive, apparently functionless, and rather disturbing activities like pacing, manger-biting or over-grooming. Environments giving rise to stereotypic behaviours typically cause other signs of stress (e.g. the release of 'stress hormones' like adrenaline/corticosteroids): thus they generally indicate an environment sub-optimal for welfare. However, questions remain as to how best to use them in practical animal welfare assessment (e.g. should we genetically select for animals not showing this behaviour? does a farm where 10% of animals show it have 'double the welfare' as a farm where 20% animals show it?). These doubts are because of some paradoxical findings. For instance, caged wild-caught animals are typically less stereotypic than are captive-born animals. Is their welfare thus better than animals born in captivity? It seems unlikely. Furthermore, stereotypic behaviours in animals kept lifelong in barren cages often become resistent to amelioration by environmental enrichments. It has been argued that such behaviours have then become mere 'scars' of past problems; but is this correct? We do not know. Recent research suggests that environments generating this behaviour do so by causing brain dysfunction and thence generalised changes in all behaviour patterns, with affected animals becoming more generally prone to persistence and reiteration. Such changes could explain the welfare anomalies above. My research will therefore integrate techniques for measuring stress/frustration with behavioural tests that psychologists use for assessing certain brain dysfunctions, to investigate: whether these behaviours are a sign of abnormality; why older forms become so hard to treat; why some individuals do not develop them at all; and how naturalistic rearing conditions protect animals from developing these problems. This work will improve the validity with which we use these behaviours to identify low-welfare environments or low-welfare phenotypes. Furthermore, if stereotypic behaviours are found to be a sign of dysfunction, this would have practical and ethical implications for some current forms of animal-use.
Programme
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Bénéficiaire
Emplacement
Ontario, Canada
Type de bénéficiaire
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data
Tel que publié
Application id
328100-2006
Name nom
Mason, Georgia
Department département
Animal and Poultry Science
Organization id
24
Institution établissement
University of Guelph
Province en
Ontario
Province fr
Ontario
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2007
Competition year année de concours
2006
Award amount
41480
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
Discovery grants programs
Group fr
Programmes de subventions à la découverte
Committee code
1011
Committee name en
Integrative Animal Biology
Committee name fr
Biologie Animale Intégrative
Area of application code
1200
Area of application group en
Advancement of knowledge
Area of application group fr
Avancement des connaissances
Area of application en
Advancement of knowledge
Area of application fr
Avancement des connaissances
Research subject code
5500
Research subject group en
Animal biology
Research subject group fr
Biologie animale
Research subject en
Animal biology
Research subject fr
Biologie animale
Partie
2
Nb partie
5
Application title
Developmental issues in animals' responses to captive husbandry: the causation of stereotypic behaviour
Keyword
NA
Application summary
Worldwide, over 85 million farm, laboratory, pet and zoo animals show stereotypic behaviours: repetitive, apparently functionless, and rather disturbing activities like pacing, manger-biting or over-grooming. Environments giving rise to stereotypic behaviours typically cause other signs of stress (e.g. the release of 'stress hormones' like adrenaline/corticosteroids): thus they generally indicate an environment sub-optimal for welfare. However, questions remain as to how best to use them in practical animal welfare assessment (e.g. should we genetically select for animals not showing this behaviour? does a farm where 10% of animals show it have 'double the welfare' as a farm where 20% animals show it?). These doubts are because of some paradoxical findings. For instance, caged wild-caught animals are typically less stereotypic than are captive-born animals. Is their welfare thus better than animals born in captivity? It seems unlikely. Furthermore, stereotypic behaviours in animals kept lifelong in barren cages often become resistent to amelioration by environmental enrichments. It has been argued that such behaviours have then become mere 'scars' of past problems; but is this correct? We do not know. Recent research suggests that environments generating this behaviour do so by causing brain dysfunction and thence generalised changes in all behaviour patterns, with affected animals becoming more generally prone to persistence and reiteration. Such changes could explain the welfare anomalies above. My research will therefore integrate techniques for measuring stress/frustration with behavioural tests that psychologists use for assessing certain brain dysfunctions, to investigate: whether these behaviours are a sign of abnormality; why older forms become so hard to treat; why some individuals do not develop them at all; and how naturalistic rearing conditions protect animals from developing these problems. This work will improve the validity with which we use these behaviours to identify low-welfare environments or low-welfare phenotypes. Furthermore, if stereotypic behaviours are found to be a sign of dysfunction, this would have practical and ethical implications for some current forms of animal-use.