Grant: Master's Award: Canada Graduate Scholarships
University of Toronto
$17,500.00
Effect of Fruits and Body Weight: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Observational and Intervention Trials
EF 2013-14
Résumé
Background
Obesity contributes to the global burden of chronic disease, often preceding the development related health complications. Dietary guidelines by international organizations have recommended increasing fruit and vegetable intake to mitigate the development of obesity, however, few studies have assessed the contributions of fruit alone. The high sugar content of fruit and fruit products has gained recent attention, as they constitute the third largest source of the fructose in the American diet. High Fructose Corn Syrup (HFCS) is a common sweetener composed of the sugars, fructose and glucose in varying compositions (42 or 55% fructose). With the widespread use of HFCS as a common additive to many processed foods paralleling increases in obesity rates over the past 50 years, fructose has come under particular scrutiny as a putative culprit towards the obesity epidemic. Despite the high fructose composition of fruits, an association between fruit intake and body weight remains inconclusive. Widespread concerns to limit fructose consumption have drawn from associative rather than causal evidence, as well as animal models with different modes of metabolism and supraphysiological doses of fructose overfeeding. Furthermore, the effects of fructose-containing whole foods in the form of fruits requires further exploration. To our knowledge, no published systematic review and meta-analysis has assessed the role of fruit intake on body weight to date. In order to solve this active controversy using the highest levels of evidence for nutrition guidelines, I propose to conduct two systematic reviews and meta-analyses to review and synthesize available evidence from observational and intervention trials in humans on the relationship between fruit intake and body weight changes. This work represents an extension of our CIHR programmatic grant to develop a Nutritional Trialists Network (NTN).
Study Design
This systematic review and meta-analysis will be conducted in accordance with established guidelines. Four online library databases will be used to identify appropriate studies, which will be supplemented with by searches from reference lists of selected papers. Search criteria will be limited to human trials investigating the effect of increasing or decreasing fruit intake on body weight for a minimum follow-up period of seven days. Full article review and data extraction will be conducted by two independent investigators, with all disparities reconciled through consensus.
Significance of Proposed Research
This project represents a continuation of a CIHR Funded Knowledge Synthesis by our group assessing the effect of fructose on various cardiometabolic endpoints. In a series of meta-analyses we conducted, fructose was shown to behave no differently when exchanged for other carbohydrates while keeping calories constant with respect to body weight, blood lipids and uric acid. Furthermore, improvements in blood pressure and sugar levels in these analyses provide interesting implications for the benefits of fruit as a source of fructose in diabetic patients. Although concerns have linked the high fructose content of fruits with a potential for weight gain, their low energy density, high water content, and composition of soluble fibers may decrease total energy intake by promoting satiation, subsequently leading to total body weight reduction. Findings from this study will provide valuable insights to gain a better understanding of the role of fruits on body weight, and underpin dietary recommendations for future obesity and weight management.
Programme
Master's Award: Canada Graduate Scholarships
Bénéficiaire
Emplacement
Ontario, Canada
Type de bénéficiaire
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
CIHR Funding Decisions Database
Tel que publié
Id
311747
Name
Choo Vivian L
Region
Ontario
Country
Canada
Orgtype
Institution Paid; Research Institution
Prcname2
Special Cases - Awards Programs
Projecttitle
Effect of Fruits and Body Weight: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Observational and Intervention Trials
Programtype2
Studentship Programs
Orgnameinp2
University of Toronto
Cihramount2
$17,500
Cihrequipment2
$0
Programname2
Master's Award: Canada Graduate Scholarships
Keyworddelim
Body Weight; Fructose; Fruit; Meta-Analysis
Abstract
Background
Obesity contributes to the global burden of chronic disease, often preceding the development related health complications. Dietary guidelines by international organizations have recommended increasing fruit and vegetable intake to mitigate the development of obesity, however, few studies have assessed the contributions of fruit alone. The high sugar content of fruit and fruit products has gained recent attention, as they constitute the third largest source of the fructose in the American diet. High Fructose Corn Syrup (HFCS) is a common sweetener composed of the sugars, fructose and glucose in varying compositions (42 or 55% fructose). With the widespread use of HFCS as a common additive to many processed foods paralleling increases in obesity rates over the past 50 years, fructose has come under particular scrutiny as a putative culprit towards the obesity epidemic. Despite the high fructose composition of fruits, an association between fruit intake and body weight remains inconclusive. Widespread concerns to limit fructose consumption have drawn from associative rather than causal evidence, as well as animal models with different modes of metabolism and supraphysiological doses of fructose overfeeding. Furthermore, the effects of fructose-containing whole foods in the form of fruits requires further exploration. To our knowledge, no published systematic review and meta-analysis has assessed the role of fruit intake on body weight to date. In order to solve this active controversy using the highest levels of evidence for nutrition guidelines, I propose to conduct two systematic reviews and meta-analyses to review and synthesize available evidence from observational and intervention trials in humans on the relationship between fruit intake and body weight changes. This work represents an extension of our CIHR programmatic grant to develop a Nutritional Trialists Network (NTN).
Study Design
This systematic review and meta-analysis will be conducted in accordance with established guidelines. Four online library databases will be used to identify appropriate studies, which will be supplemented with by searches from reference lists of selected papers. Search criteria will be limited to human trials investigating the effect of increasing or decreasing fruit intake on body weight for a minimum follow-up period of seven days. Full article review and data extraction will be conducted by two independent investigators, with all disparities reconciled through consensus.
Significance of Proposed Research
This project represents a continuation of a CIHR Funded Knowledge Synthesis by our group assessing the effect of fructose on various cardiometabolic endpoints. In a series of meta-analyses we conducted, fructose was shown to behave no differently when exchanged for other carbohydrates while keeping calories constant with respect to body weight, blood lipids and uric acid. Furthermore, improvements in blood pressure and sugar levels in these analyses provide interesting implications for the benefits of fruit as a source of fructose in diabetic patients. Although concerns have linked the high fructose content of fruits with a potential for weight gain, their low energy density, high water content, and composition of soluble fibers may decrease total energy intake by promoting satiation, subsequently leading to total body weight reduction. Findings from this study will provide valuable insights to gain a better understanding of the role of fruits on body weight, and underpin dietary recommendations for future obesity and weight management.
Competitiondate
201312
Approvedterm2
1 yr 0 mth
Pinamesdelim
Choo, Vivian L
Approvedterm
1 an 0 mois
Cihrcontribution2
~ $17,500~ $0~