Canada Spends Logo

Explorez notre analyse du budget 2026

Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual

Queen's University

$38,000.00

How do vaccine resistors recruit evidence to support their beliefs and meta-beliefs?

EF 2023-24

Résumé
Canada and the world face a common problem: vaccine hesitancy threatens to prolong ongoing pandemics (e.g., COVID-19) and resurrect old ones (e.g., measles). In 2020, almost half of Canadians reported some degree of vaccine hesitancy. Mortality in countries with high vaccine hesitancy is projected to be 7.6 times higher than in countries with optimal vaccine intake. This problem is exacerbated by the fact that scientists lack understanding of how vaccine hesitant individuals form their beliefs. While past research has identified personal characteristics that predict vaccine hesitancy, personal characteristics are stable and difficult to change. Instead of investigating who is vaccine hesitant, our research program investigates why someone becomes vaccine hesitant. Understanding the cognitive mechanisms driving vaccine hesitancy is the first step to developing effective interventions to lessen it and improve public health in Canada and worldwide. Our program of research assesses how vaccine resistors form their beliefs. Many vaccine hesitant individuals claim they arrived at their beliefs after a thorough examination of the evidence about vaccines. However, people who resist vaccines also tend to believe in other conspiracy theories, and conspiratorial thinking is strongly associated with a jumping to conclusions (JTC) cognitive style (i.e., forming conclusions after seeing minimal amounts of information). Recent progress in our lab suggests that vaccine resistance is associated with a JTC cognitive style; those who resist vaccines tend to recruit very little information before reaching overconfident conclusions. Several experiments will examine whether the JTC cognitive style predicts anti-vaccination beliefs over and above personal characteristics, in cross-national representative samples, and in situations when people are learning specifically about vaccines. If vaccine resistors do indeed have a JTC cognitive style, this raises additional questions - why do vaccine resistors have inaccurate meta beliefs about how their attitudes are formed? And how do they cope with disconfirmatory evidence? These questions, and the links between JTC and science skepticism in general, will be explored. One line of experiments will investigate whether overconfidence in assessments, attitudes towards vaccines, and attitudes towards scientific beliefs that are prone to skepticism (e.g., climate change) predict overestimates of evidence consultation. Another line of experiments will determine whether JTC predicts a bias against disconfirmatory evidence about vaccines and scientific beliefs that are prone to skepticism. Ultimately, the research will advance academic understanding of vaccine hesitancy and science skepticism by shedding light on the cognitive mechanisms behind why people resist vaccines and science. This understanding could suggest actionable interventions that could be incorporated into Canadian public policy.
Programme
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Bénéficiaire
Emplacement
Ontario, Canada
Type de bénéficiaire
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data

Tel que publié

Application id
RGPIN-2023-04345
Name nom
Hauser, David
Department département
Psychology
Organization id
29
Institution établissement
Queen's University
Province en
Ontario
Province fr
Ontario
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2023
Competition year année de concours
2023
Award amount
38000
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
DISCOVERY RESEARCH
Group fr
RECHERCHE AXÉE SUR LA DÉCOUVERTE
Committee code
1502
Committee name en
Biological Systems and Functions
Committee name fr
Systèmes et fonctions biologiques
Area of application code
1101
Area of application group en
Health, education and social services
Area of application group fr
Santé publique, éducation et services sociaux
Area of application en
Human health (including medically-related psychological research)
Area of application fr
Santé publique (y compris recherche psychologique liée à la médecine)
Research subject code
6304
Research subject group en
Psychology
Research subject group fr
Cognitive science -- fundamental
Research subject en
Psychologie
Research subject fr
Science cognitive -- principes fondamentaux
Application title
How do vaccine resistors recruit evidence to support their beliefs and meta-beliefs?
Keyword
belief updating; evidence search; health decision-making; information gathering; judgment and decision making; science skepticism; vaccine skepticism
Application summary
Canada and the world face a common problem: vaccine hesitancy threatens to prolong ongoing pandemics (e.g., COVID-19) and resurrect old ones (e.g., measles). In 2020, almost half of Canadians reported some degree of vaccine hesitancy. Mortality in countries with high vaccine hesitancy is projected to be 7.6 times higher than in countries with optimal vaccine intake. This problem is exacerbated by the fact that scientists lack understanding of how vaccine hesitant individuals form their beliefs. While past research has identified personal characteristics that predict vaccine hesitancy, personal characteristics are stable and difficult to change. Instead of investigating who is vaccine hesitant, our research program investigates why someone becomes vaccine hesitant. Understanding the cognitive mechanisms driving vaccine hesitancy is the first step to developing effective interventions to lessen it and improve public health in Canada and worldwide. Our program of research assesses how vaccine resistors form their beliefs. Many vaccine hesitant individuals claim they arrived at their beliefs after a thorough examination of the evidence about vaccines. However, people who resist vaccines also tend to believe in other conspiracy theories, and conspiratorial thinking is strongly associated with a jumping to conclusions (JTC) cognitive style (i.e., forming conclusions after seeing minimal amounts of information). Recent progress in our lab suggests that vaccine resistance is associated with a JTC cognitive style; those who resist vaccines tend to recruit very little information before reaching overconfident conclusions. Several experiments will examine whether the JTC cognitive style predicts anti-vaccination beliefs over and above personal characteristics, in cross-national representative samples, and in situations when people are learning specifically about vaccines. If vaccine resistors do indeed have a JTC cognitive style, this raises additional questions - why do vaccine resistors have inaccurate meta beliefs about how their attitudes are formed? And how do they cope with disconfirmatory evidence? These questions, and the links between JTC and science skepticism in general, will be explored. One line of experiments will investigate whether overconfidence in assessments, attitudes towards vaccines, and attitudes towards scientific beliefs that are prone to skepticism (e.g., climate change) predict overestimates of evidence consultation. Another line of experiments will determine whether JTC predicts a bias against disconfirmatory evidence about vaccines and scientific beliefs that are prone to skepticism. Ultimately, the research will advance academic understanding of vaccine hesitancy and science skepticism by shedding light on the cognitive mechanisms behind why people resist vaccines and science. This understanding could suggest actionable interventions that could be incorporated into Canadian public policy.