Grant: Master's Award: Canada Graduate Scholarships
University of British Columbia
$17,500.00
VALUING ELECTRONIC MEDICAL RECORD USE: BRITISH COLUMBIA AS A CASE STUDY
EF 2013-14
Résumé
Electronic medical records (EMR) in physician offices are functional cornerstones of an integrated health care system and have the potential to generate fundamental improvements in patient-centered care through better identification of routine and preventive care services, patient engagement, more efficient communication between providers, and analyses of system performance through secondary use of data. Canadian physicians are late adopters of EMRs globally, but uptake is increasing and in BC is expected to reach ~80% by 2015. Given these increasing levels of EMR adoption, the answer to the question of adoption effects on practice productivity is timely and can help push further diffusion and more comprehensive use of EMRs by physicians.
Results from the emerging literature on this topic indicate equivocal effects of EMR adoption on practice productivity. The highly-cited Hillestad paper talked about a “productivity loss of 15 percent for three months, $3,000 per physician for additional hardware costs, and yearly maintenance costs equal to 20 percent of the one-time cost” for adopting EMRs. However, research shows that it is not just the presence of an EMR, but the level of implementation that is more strongly related to performance on quality metrics. Given the uncertainty regarding the value creation of EMRs in the Canadian health care context, this study will focus on answering the following questions related to their adoption among general practice physicians in BC:
1. What is the impact on total service volume and total Fee-For-Service billings during and after EMR implementation?
2. What is the effect of EMR adoption on health care services use and guideline care for chronic conditions (as a proximate measure of influence on patient health outcomes)?
This project will use data from two sources: the BC Physician Information and Technology Office and the BC Ministry of Health through Population Data BC, capturing a period between 2008 and 2013. This will be analyzed as a time series, with monthly measures of activity before, during and after EMR adoption. I will construct a comparison group based on time of adoption. That is, adopters in 2008 will be compared with adopters at time 2008 + 18 months, and so on.
Results from this study will provide much needed information on the value for money proposition for physicians adopting EMRs in BC, and potentially Canada, depending on generalizability of the provincial eHealth context. The federal government of Canada, through Canada Infoway, and the provinces have substantially subsidized EMR adoption and have great interest in measuring their return on investment
Programme
Master's Award: Canada Graduate Scholarships
Bénéficiaire
Emplacement
British Columbia, Canada
Type de bénéficiaire
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
CIHR Funding Decisions Database
Tel que publié
Id
311933
Name
Stevenson Benjamin
Region
British Columbia
Country
Canada
Orgtype
Institution Paid; Research Institution
Prcname2
Special Cases - Awards Programs
Projecttitle
VALUING ELECTRONIC MEDICAL RECORD USE: BRITISH COLUMBIA AS A CASE STUDY
Programtype2
Studentship Programs
Orgnameinp2
University of British Columbia
Cihramount2
$17,500
Cihrequipment2
$0
Programname2
Master's Award: Canada Graduate Scholarships
Keyworddelim
Chronic Disease Management; Health Care Policy; Health Economics; Health Information Technology; High Performance Health Systems; Implementation Research; Patient-Engagement; Primary Health Care; Quality Improvement; Time Series Analysis
Abstract
Electronic medical records (EMR) in physician offices are functional cornerstones of an integrated health care system and have the potential to generate fundamental improvements in patient-centered care through better identification of routine and preventive care services, patient engagement, more efficient communication between providers, and analyses of system performance through secondary use of data. Canadian physicians are late adopters of EMRs globally, but uptake is increasing and in BC is expected to reach ~80% by 2015. Given these increasing levels of EMR adoption, the answer to the question of adoption effects on practice productivity is timely and can help push further diffusion and more comprehensive use of EMRs by physicians.
Results from the emerging literature on this topic indicate equivocal effects of EMR adoption on practice productivity. The highly-cited Hillestad paper talked about a “productivity loss of 15 percent for three months, $3,000 per physician for additional hardware costs, and yearly maintenance costs equal to 20 percent of the one-time cost” for adopting EMRs. However, research shows that it is not just the presence of an EMR, but the level of implementation that is more strongly related to performance on quality metrics. Given the uncertainty regarding the value creation of EMRs in the Canadian health care context, this study will focus on answering the following questions related to their adoption among general practice physicians in BC:
1. What is the impact on total service volume and total Fee-For-Service billings during and after EMR implementation?
2. What is the effect of EMR adoption on health care services use and guideline care for chronic conditions (as a proximate measure of influence on patient health outcomes)?
This project will use data from two sources: the BC Physician Information and Technology Office and the BC Ministry of Health through Population Data BC, capturing a period between 2008 and 2013. This will be analyzed as a time series, with monthly measures of activity before, during and after EMR adoption. I will construct a comparison group based on time of adoption. That is, adopters in 2008 will be compared with adopters at time 2008 + 18 months, and so on.
Results from this study will provide much needed information on the value for money proposition for physicians adopting EMRs in BC, and potentially Canada, depending on generalizability of the provincial eHealth context. The federal government of Canada, through Canada Infoway, and the provinces have substantially subsidized EMR adoption and have great interest in measuring their return on investment
Competitiondate
201312
Approvedterm2
1 yr 0 mth
Pinamesdelim
Stevenson, Benjamin
Approvedterm
1 an 0 mois
Cihrcontribution2
~ $17,500~ $0~