Grant: Master's Award: Canada Graduate Scholarships
McGill University
$17,500.00
Experiences that Contribute to Clinicians’ Perceptions of Progress Monitoring
EF 2013-14
Résumé
Approximately 5-10% of clients worsen while in psychotherapy. Progress Monitoring (PM) measures successfully improve outcomes in therapy for clients not responding as expected. Still, the majority of clinicians have not integrated these tools or other forms of standardized outcome assessment into their practice. Even after outcome measures training, many clinicians remain unconvinced of the usefulness of these tools. Conversely, among clinicians that use PM, usefulness is cited as the main motivator for use. This difference in perception may be related to clinical experiences, as psychologists identify past clinical experience as the most important influence on treatment decisions. Users of PM tools may have had different experiences with PM than non-users, and this may be contributing to their differing perceptions of PM usefulness. The proposed research project will investigate why some clinicians who have experience using PM tools perceive them as useful, while others do not. Specifically, I hope to identify experiences that convince and the experiences that dissuade clinicians from using PM.
A collective case study will be conducted to better understand the experiences of PM users and non-users. Additionally, case examples will be constructed from interviewees that discuss positive PM experiences or changes in perceptions regarding PM, as psychologists are more responsive to case studies than to research reviews of data. Clinicians, half endorsing PM usefullness and half not, will be interviewed until no new themes are surfacing in the interviews. Semi-structured interview guides will be developed to assess experiences that contribute to perceptions of PM usefulness. Three researchers will transcribe, code and identify patterns in the interviews. Interview interpretations will be cross-validated among researchers to maximize validity. Participants will be given the opportunity to review the researchers’ interpretations to confirm the representativeness and validity of the analysis.
The results of the proposed research will contribute to psychotherapy training, theory, research and practice. The insight obtained in this project will inform the development of effective PM training programs, as issues that demotivate PM usage will be able to be addressed. Theoretically, this research will advance our understanding of knowledge uptake among psychotherapists. From a research perspective, this project will develop case studies that will be used in an ongoing program of research evaluating case-based knowledge translation. Finally, improved PM knowledge translation is expected to increase the proportion of clinicians using these measures, which will subsequently improve clinical practice.
Programme
Master's Award: Canada Graduate Scholarships
Bénéficiaire
Emplacement
Quebec, Canada
Type de bénéficiaire
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
CIHR Funding Decisions Database
Tel que publié
Id
311698
Name
Knoll Megan
Region
Québec
Country
Canada
Orgtype
Institution Paid; Research Institution
Prcname2
Special Cases - Awards Programs
Projecttitle
Experiences that Contribute to Clinicians’ Perceptions of Progress Monitoring
Programtype2
Studentship Programs
Orgnameinp2
McGill University
Cihramount2
$17,500
Cihrequipment2
$0
Programname2
Master's Award: Canada Graduate Scholarships
Keyworddelim
Evidence Based Practice; Health Systems; Knowledge Translation; Mental Health; Progress Monitoring; Routine Outcome Measures
Abstract
Approximately 5-10% of clients worsen while in psychotherapy. Progress Monitoring (PM) measures successfully improve outcomes in therapy for clients not responding as expected. Still, the majority of clinicians have not integrated these tools or other forms of standardized outcome assessment into their practice. Even after outcome measures training, many clinicians remain unconvinced of the usefulness of these tools. Conversely, among clinicians that use PM, usefulness is cited as the main motivator for use. This difference in perception may be related to clinical experiences, as psychologists identify past clinical experience as the most important influence on treatment decisions. Users of PM tools may have had different experiences with PM than non-users, and this may be contributing to their differing perceptions of PM usefulness. The proposed research project will investigate why some clinicians who have experience using PM tools perceive them as useful, while others do not. Specifically, I hope to identify experiences that convince and the experiences that dissuade clinicians from using PM.
A collective case study will be conducted to better understand the experiences of PM users and non-users. Additionally, case examples will be constructed from interviewees that discuss positive PM experiences or changes in perceptions regarding PM, as psychologists are more responsive to case studies than to research reviews of data. Clinicians, half endorsing PM usefullness and half not, will be interviewed until no new themes are surfacing in the interviews. Semi-structured interview guides will be developed to assess experiences that contribute to perceptions of PM usefulness. Three researchers will transcribe, code and identify patterns in the interviews. Interview interpretations will be cross-validated among researchers to maximize validity. Participants will be given the opportunity to review the researchers’ interpretations to confirm the representativeness and validity of the analysis.
The results of the proposed research will contribute to psychotherapy training, theory, research and practice. The insight obtained in this project will inform the development of effective PM training programs, as issues that demotivate PM usage will be able to be addressed. Theoretically, this research will advance our understanding of knowledge uptake among psychotherapists. From a research perspective, this project will develop case studies that will be used in an ongoing program of research evaluating case-based knowledge translation. Finally, improved PM knowledge translation is expected to increase the proportion of clinicians using these measures, which will subsequently improve clinical practice.
Competitiondate
201312
Approvedterm2
1 yr 0 mth
Pinamesdelim
Knoll, Megan
Approvedterm
1 an 0 mois
Cihrcontribution2
~ $17,500~ $0~