Canada Spends Logo

Explorez notre analyse du budget 2026

Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual

University of Toronto

$54,000.00

Applied computational models of discourse, argument, and text

EF 2015-16

Résumé
Our research is in computational linguistics (CL), natural language processing (NLP), and their applications. Themes that run through the work are (i) computationally determining the structure of discourse and argumentation; (ii) computational notions of paraphrase and of the semantic distance between words, larger linguistic expressions, or documents; and (iii) the use of statistical classification methods in text analysis. We propose the following new research: (1) Finding the structure and framing of discourse and arguments: Understanding a speaker's argument entails understanding not only what is presented as evidence and what as conclusion but also how the conclusion follows from the evidence, what the unstated premises (enthymemes) are, and what the implicit framing of the issue is. We will look in particular at opinionated texts in which argumentation structure is fairly explicit on the surface but determining enthymemes and framing is crucial to full understanding. For automatic text analysis, we take quantifiable semantic characteristics of the speaker's presentation of a position as indicators or proxies of the framing, which can then be interpreted qualitatively. In a simple analysis, this could be merely a statistical analysis of the key concepts of the text, as denoted by content words and significant collocations -- something like a topic model. Here, however, we propose a novel, more-sophisticated analysis in which we also look at the actual argumentation structures and discourse relationships of the text and how the concepts adduced by the lower-level linguistic components are used in these structures. This will draw on and extend our recent work on discourse parsing and the identification of argumentation schemes in text. Although these are difficult tasks for which the state-of-the-art is far from perfect, we hypothesize that typical political speech contains a sufficiently well-cued discourse structure that the analyses that we can achieve, although still quite imperfect, will be usefully indicative of issue framing. (2) Finding precedent scientific literature: Researchers often have difficulty searching for past research relevant to, or precedent to, their new or proposed research, and often resort simply to Google keyword searches, which are rarely adequate. We will develop methods for searching scientific literature that use semantic and structural relationships to find publications that are possibly relevant to a new text. We will concentrate in particular on the legacy literature of biodiversity, for which conventional keyword searches are almost invariably insufficient because in this literature, more so than most other fields of science, related concepts are often described or explained in different terms, or in completely different conceptual frameworks, from those of contemporary research. As a result, relevant legacy publications, or even whole literatures, may remain hidden to term-based methods. This goal will not be reached in five years, but it motivates the next stage of our work because it requires bringing together many of the methods of natural language processing developed in our own and other researchers' work of the past decade or more: (a) the recognition of paraphrase and of textual entailment, and measurement of semantic similarity at the sentence level and above; (b) the automatic analysis of the structure and argumentation of scholarly papers and scientific discourse (this is a point of overlap with (1) above, but in scientific texts we expect the micro-structure to be less explicit and the macro-structure more explicit than in opinion texts). (3) We will continue our work on automatic authorship identification; on characterizing aphasic speech; and on the philosophy of CL.
Programme
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Bénéficiaire
Emplacement
Ontario, Canada
Type de bénéficiaire
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data

Tel que publié

Application id
RGPIN-2014-06020
Name nom
Hirst, Graeme
Department département
Computer and Mathematical Sciences (Scarborough) - Computer and Mathematical Sci
Organization id
31
Institution établissement
University of Toronto
Province en
Ontario
Province fr
Ontario
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2015
Competition year année de concours
2014
Award amount
54000
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
Discovery grants programs
Group fr
Programmes de subventions à la découverte
Committee code
1507
Committee name en
Computer Science
Committee name fr
Sciences informatiques
Area of application code
802
Area of application group en
Information and communication services
Area of application group fr
Services d'information et de télécommunications
Area of application en
Information systems and technology
Area of application fr
Systèmes d'information et technologie de l'information
Research subject code
2801
Research subject group en
Artificial intelligence
Research subject group fr
Intelligence artificielle
Research subject en
Natural language and speech understanding
Research subject fr
Langage naturel et reconnaissance de la parole
Partie
2
Nb partie
5
Application title
Applied computational models of discourse, argument, and text
Keyword
NSERC
Application summary
Our research is in computational linguistics (CL), natural language processing (NLP), and their applications. Themes that run through the work are (i) computationally determining the structure of discourse and argumentation; (ii) computational notions of paraphrase and of the semantic distance between words, larger linguistic expressions, or documents; and (iii) the use of statistical classification methods in text analysis. We propose the following new research: (1) Finding the structure and framing of discourse and arguments: Understanding a speaker's argument entails understanding not only what is presented as evidence and what as conclusion but also how the conclusion follows from the evidence, what the unstated premises (enthymemes) are, and what the implicit framing of the issue is. We will look in particular at opinionated texts in which argumentation structure is fairly explicit on the surface but determining enthymemes and framing is crucial to full understanding. For automatic text analysis, we take quantifiable semantic characteristics of the speaker's presentation of a position as indicators or proxies of the framing, which can then be interpreted qualitatively. In a simple analysis, this could be merely a statistical analysis of the key concepts of the text, as denoted by content words and significant collocations -- something like a topic model. Here, however, we propose a novel, more-sophisticated analysis in which we also look at the actual argumentation structures and discourse relationships of the text and how the concepts adduced by the lower-level linguistic components are used in these structures. This will draw on and extend our recent work on discourse parsing and the identification of argumentation schemes in text. Although these are difficult tasks for which the state-of-the-art is far from perfect, we hypothesize that typical political speech contains a sufficiently well-cued discourse structure that the analyses that we can achieve, although still quite imperfect, will be usefully indicative of issue framing. (2) Finding precedent scientific literature: Researchers often have difficulty searching for past research relevant to, or precedent to, their new or proposed research, and often resort simply to Google keyword searches, which are rarely adequate. We will develop methods for searching scientific literature that use semantic and structural relationships to find publications that are possibly relevant to a new text. We will concentrate in particular on the legacy literature of biodiversity, for which conventional keyword searches are almost invariably insufficient because in this literature, more so than most other fields of science, related concepts are often described or explained in different terms, or in completely different conceptual frameworks, from those of contemporary research. As a result, relevant legacy publications, or even whole literatures, may remain hidden to term-based methods. This goal will not be reached in five years, but it motivates the next stage of our work because it requires bringing together many of the methods of natural language processing developed in our own and other researchers' work of the past decade or more: (a) the recognition of paraphrase and of textual entailment, and measurement of semantic similarity at the sentence level and above; (b) the automatic analysis of the structure and argumentation of scholarly papers and scientific discourse (this is a point of overlap with (1) above, but in scientific texts we expect the micro-structure to be less explicit and the macro-structure more explicit than in opinion texts). (3) We will continue our work on automatic authorship identification; on characterizing aphasic speech; and on the philosophy of CL.