Canada Spends Logo

Explorez notre analyse du budget 2026

Grant: Discovery Grants Program - Individual

McGill University

$40,000.00

Heuristics and Biases are (Nearly) Optimal: A Fresh Programmatic Study of Heuristics and Biases in Human Decision-Making

EF 2021-22

Résumé
Our decisions shape our lives: what career path to choose; how to invest; choice of partner; how to achieve happiness. Our application proposes computer simulations, math modeling, and psychology experiments to understand and explain central issues in human decision-making. The broad goal of our research program is to provide a new way of understanding heuristics and biases in human decision-making, by systematically developing a rational basis for them. Our research program challenges the widely held view that human cognition is systematically erroneous, offering instead a new and positive view of cognition by demonstrating that decision-making is nearly optimal given environmental conditions and cognitive limitations. The prevailing view is that judgment and decision-making are filled with cognitive biases and deviations from rationality, because people use fast but inaccurate (sub-optimal) heuristics. We will establish mathematically rigorous optimality guarantees for heuristics that strongly challenge this dominant view, thus offering a radically different perspective on heuristics. Our new framework complements rationality research, developing it into a richer research program by attempting to show that heuristics are nearly optimal given environmental conditions and cognitive limitations. Providing supporting evidence for this line of work, our preliminary work shows that our framework yields strong optimally guarantees for a well-known heuristic, Take-the-Best. Also, in contrast to Nobel-winning Prospect Theory and other current approaches, we present a new heuristic model of decision-making, called SbEU (Sample-based Expected Utility). Effectively combining two highly successful theories of cognition, expected utility theory and bounded optimality, SbEU uniquely simulates and thus explains a wide range of major findings in human decision-making. Notably, SbEU is the first, and so far the only, boundedly-optimal heuristic model that bridges between risky, value-based, and game-theoretic decision-making. Our research program provides a novel, unified, precise, formal explanation of several vast literatures on human decision-making. Our preliminary models will be refined, extended, and applied to more empirical findings. Novel predictions of our models will be empirically tested in new psychology experiments. Our hypothesis is that humans make decisions in a boundedly-optimal fashion: making rational decisions, subject to environmental conditions and the computational and cognitive limitations they are faced with. We expect this work to provoke a major paradigm shift in cognitive science, from a seemingly endless list of unexplained biases to a unified theory of bounded rationality. This would fundamentally change the way we currently understand human cognition, with far-reaching implications for decision sciences, policymaking, and daily-life decisions. As such, our research is of great importance for scientists and laypeople alike.
Programme
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Bénéficiaire
Emplacement
Quebec, Canada
Type de bénéficiaire
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
NSERC's Awards Data

Tel que publié

Application id
RGPIN-2021-03434
Name nom
Shultz, Thomas
Department département
Psychology
Organization id
61
Institution établissement
McGill University
Province en
Québec
Province fr
Québec
Country en
CANADA
Country fr
CANADA
Fiscal year exercice financier
2021
Competition year année de concours
2021
Award amount
40000
Program id
RGPIN
Program name en
Discovery Grants Program - Individual
Program name fr
Programme de subventions à la découverte - individuelles
Group en
Discovery grants programs
Group fr
Programmes de subventions à la découverte
Committee code
1502
Committee name en
Biological Systems and Functions
Committee name fr
Systèmes et fonctions biologiques
Area of application code
1200
Area of application group en
Advancement of knowledge
Area of application group fr
Avancement des connaissances
Area of application en
Advancement of knowledge
Area of application fr
Avancement des connaissances
Research subject code
6304
Research subject group en
Psychology
Research subject group fr
Psychologie
Research subject en
Cognitive science -- fundamental
Research subject fr
Science cognitive -- principes fondamentaux
Installment
inst:1
Partie
1
Nb partie
5
Application title
Heuristics and Biases are (Nearly) Optimal: A Fresh Programmatic Study of Heuristics and Biases in Human Decision-Making
Keyword
NSERC
Application summary
Our decisions shape our lives: what career path to choose; how to invest; choice of partner; how to achieve happiness. Our application proposes computer simulations, math modeling, and psychology experiments to understand and explain central issues in human decision-making. The broad goal of our research program is to provide a new way of understanding heuristics and biases in human decision-making, by systematically developing a rational basis for them. Our research program challenges the widely held view that human cognition is systematically erroneous, offering instead a new and positive view of cognition by demonstrating that decision-making is nearly optimal given environmental conditions and cognitive limitations. The prevailing view is that judgment and decision-making are filled with cognitive biases and deviations from rationality, because people use fast but inaccurate (sub-optimal) heuristics. We will establish mathematically rigorous optimality guarantees for heuristics that strongly challenge this dominant view, thus offering a radically different perspective on heuristics. Our new framework complements rationality research, developing it into a richer research program by attempting to show that heuristics are nearly optimal given environmental conditions and cognitive limitations. Providing supporting evidence for this line of work, our preliminary work shows that our framework yields strong optimally guarantees for a well-known heuristic, Take-the-Best. Also, in contrast to Nobel-winning Prospect Theory and other current approaches, we present a new heuristic model of decision-making, called SbEU (Sample-based Expected Utility). Effectively combining two highly successful theories of cognition, expected utility theory and bounded optimality, SbEU uniquely simulates and thus explains a wide range of major findings in human decision-making. Notably, SbEU is the first, and so far the only, boundedly-optimal heuristic model that bridges between risky, value-based, and game-theoretic decision-making. Our research program provides a novel, unified, precise, formal explanation of several vast literatures on human decision-making. Our preliminary models will be refined, extended, and applied to more empirical findings. Novel predictions of our models will be empirically tested in new psychology experiments. Our hypothesis is that humans make decisions in a boundedly-optimal fashion: making rational decisions, subject to environmental conditions and the computational and cognitive limitations they are faced with. We expect this work to provoke a major paradigm shift in cognitive science, from a seemingly endless list of unexplained biases to a unified theory of bounded rationality. This would fundamentally change the way we currently understand human cognition, with far-reaching implications for decision sciences, policymaking, and daily-life decisions. As such, our research is of great importance for scientists and laypeople alike.