Grant: Catalyst Grant: Ethics
McGill University
$80,804.00
Social Determinants of Health and Theories of Justice: What is the normative relation between health inequalities and socio-economic inequalities? An ethical analysis
EF 2009-10
Résumé
Health inequalities exist in every society. Even societies that feature universal and free access to health care display considerable health inequalities. Health inequalities will not be eradicated by simply promoting equal access to health care services. While health is a non-divisible and non-transferable good, it is possible to reduce health inequalities by redistributing other goods, such as income, housing, employment, and workplace autonomy. This idea is known as the social determinants of health (SDH). Health policy-makers take health inequalities to be a matter of social justice, but there is no ethical justification for this judgment. The goal of this project is to offer a novel ethical framework, which we call the luck egalitarian approach, for the promotion of population-wide health through the redistribution of SDH, and to lay out the methodological foundations for a comprehensive theory of SDH in health equity. We will pursue two specific objectives. The first is to reject the theory of justice as applied to SDH, which was proposed by John Rawls and Norman Daniels. The Rawls-Daniels theory of justice is the dominant, and in fact the only, ethical theory on SDH. We will argue that it encounters serious theoretical problems. The second objective is to propose and develop the luck egalitarian approach to SDH and health equity and to show its relative advantages over the Rawls-Daniels theory. Luck egalitarianism contends that justice requires correcting disadvantages for which individuals cannot be held responsible. According to this theory, justice requires reducing health inequalities created by some SDH, but not all SDH. It allows for some health inequalities to exist. The results of this project will introduce a radical paradigm shift in our understanding of SDH and serve as the methodological foundations for our larger, interdisciplinary research program on SDH and health equity in future.
Programme
Catalyst Grant: Ethics
Bénéficiaire
Emplacement
Quebec, Canada
Type de bénéficiaire
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
CIHR Funding Decisions Database
Tel que publié
Id
192788
Name
Hirose Iwao
Region
Québec
Country
Canada
Orgtype
Institution Paid; Research Institution
Instname2
Population and Public Health
Theme2
Social / Cultural / Environmental / Population Health
Prcname2
Catalyst Grant : Ethics (2016-2017)
Projecttitle
Social Determinants of Health and Theories of Justice: What is the normative relation between health inequalities and socio-economic inequalities? An ethical analysis
Programtype2
Operating Grants
Orgnameinp2
McGill University
Cihramount2
$80,804
Cihrequipment2
$4,530
Programname2
Catalyst Grant: Ethics
Keyworddelim
Distributive Justice; Health Inequalities; Health Policy; Medical Ethics; Population Health; Social Determinants Of Health
Abstract
Health inequalities exist in every society. Even societies that feature universal and free access to health care display considerable health inequalities. Health inequalities will not be eradicated by simply promoting equal access to health care services. While health is a non-divisible and non-transferable good, it is possible to reduce health inequalities by redistributing other goods, such as income, housing, employment, and workplace autonomy. This idea is known as the social determinants of health (SDH). Health policy-makers take health inequalities to be a matter of social justice, but there is no ethical justification for this judgment. The goal of this project is to offer a novel ethical framework, which we call the luck egalitarian approach, for the promotion of population-wide health through the redistribution of SDH, and to lay out the methodological foundations for a comprehensive theory of SDH in health equity. We will pursue two specific objectives. The first is to reject the theory of justice as applied to SDH, which was proposed by John Rawls and Norman Daniels. The Rawls-Daniels theory of justice is the dominant, and in fact the only, ethical theory on SDH. We will argue that it encounters serious theoretical problems. The second objective is to propose and develop the luck egalitarian approach to SDH and health equity and to show its relative advantages over the Rawls-Daniels theory. Luck egalitarianism contends that justice requires correcting disadvantages for which individuals cannot be held responsible. According to this theory, justice requires reducing health inequalities created by some SDH, but not all SDH. It allows for some health inequalities to exist. The results of this project will introduce a radical paradigm shift in our understanding of SDH and serve as the methodological foundations for our larger, interdisciplinary research program on SDH and health equity in future.
Competitiondate
200911
Approvedterm2
2 yrs 0 mth
Pinamesdelim
Hirose, Iwao
Approvedterm
2 ans 0 mois
Cihrcontribution2
~ $80,804~ $4,530~