Grant: Fellowship - Priority Announcement: Knowledge Translation
University of Toronto
$135,000.00
Informing evidence-based policy using public engagement methodology: The case of expanded newborn screening
EF 2009-10
Résumé
Historically, newborn screening (NBS) programs identified serious conditions where early detection and urgent pre-symptomatic treatment were necessary to avert clinical harm. Today NBS continues to operate as a mandatory or implied-consent program, justified on the basis of anticipated health benefits for infants. Due to increased technological capacity, newborn screening is expanding - in Canada and around the world - allowing the early detection of increasing numbers of primarily genetic conditions, including those for which treatment is not established and others which generate incidental results. As the potential scope of newborn screening increases and the benefits pursued by NBS become more heterogeneous and contested, complex ethical and policy dilemmas develop regarding: the conditions that should be screened, the scope of storage and secondary research and the scope of options that should be offered to individual parents. Continued debate about expanded NBS has led to calls for stakeholder engagement to inform policy. Much research reports the attitudes of consumers and health professionals, but little reflects the perspectives of the general public - important stakeholders of public health initiatives. Using deliberative dialogue techniques along with discrete choice experimental survey design, the objective of this study is to engage the general public in Ontario regarding: (1) the relevance of increased parental discretion; (2) the types of conditions to be screened (e.g., treatable or not), (3) whether and how incidental results (i.e., carrier status, benign variants) should be disclosed, and (4) whether and how long infant blood samples generated should be stored and made available for research. The findings will be disseminated to the academic realm and to the Ontario Advisory Committee on Newborn and Childhood Screening, with the ultimate aim of informing policy makers faced with the challenge of developing sound policy in this controversial domain.
Programme
Fellowship - Priority Announcement: Knowledge Translation
Bénéficiaire
Emplacement
Ontario, Canada
Type de bénéficiaire
Academia
Type
Grant
Source
CIHR Funding Decisions Database
Tel que publié
Id
194135
Name
Bombard Yvonne
Region
Ontario
Country
Canada
Orgtype
Institution Paid; Research Institution
Instname2
Genetics
Theme2
Health systems / services
Prcname2
Health Research Training A - Post-PhD (HTA)
Projecttitle
Informing evidence-based policy using public engagement methodology: The case of expanded newborn screening
Programtype2
Fellowship Programs
Orgnameinp2
University of Toronto
Cihramount2
$135,000
Cihrequipment2
$0
Programname2
Fellowship - Priority Announcement: Knowledge Translation
Keyworddelim
Deliberative Focus Groups; Discrete Choice Experimental Survey Design; Genetic Testing/Screening; Genetics Related Ethical; Health Service Research; Public Engagement; Public Health Genomics; Public Health Policy; Social And Policy Issues; Societal Implications Of Genetic Discoveries; Translation Of Knowledge Into Health Policy And Practice
Abstract
Historically, newborn screening (NBS) programs identified serious conditions where early detection and urgent pre-symptomatic treatment were necessary to avert clinical harm. Today NBS continues to operate as a mandatory or implied-consent program, justified on the basis of anticipated health benefits for infants. Due to increased technological capacity, newborn screening is expanding - in Canada and around the world - allowing the early detection of increasing numbers of primarily genetic conditions, including those for which treatment is not established and others which generate incidental results. As the potential scope of newborn screening increases and the benefits pursued by NBS become more heterogeneous and contested, complex ethical and policy dilemmas develop regarding: the conditions that should be screened, the scope of storage and secondary research and the scope of options that should be offered to individual parents. Continued debate about expanded NBS has led to calls for stakeholder engagement to inform policy. Much research reports the attitudes of consumers and health professionals, but little reflects the perspectives of the general public - important stakeholders of public health initiatives. Using deliberative dialogue techniques along with discrete choice experimental survey design, the objective of this study is to engage the general public in Ontario regarding: (1) the relevance of increased parental discretion; (2) the types of conditions to be screened (e.g., treatable or not), (3) whether and how incidental results (i.e., carrier status, benign variants) should be disclosed, and (4) whether and how long infant blood samples generated should be stored and made available for research. The findings will be disseminated to the academic realm and to the Ontario Advisory Committee on Newborn and Childhood Screening, with the ultimate aim of informing policy makers faced with the challenge of developing sound policy in this controversial domain.
Competitiondate
200910
Approvedterm2
3 yrs 0 mth
Pinamesdelim
Bombard, Yvonne
Approvedterm
3 ans 0 mois
Cihrcontribution2
~ $135,000~ $0~